Maroons Edge Mons
STL's 3rd Straight Prez Trophy, Toronto #2 Seed
It came down to the penultimate game of the season, but the St. Louis Maroons are the best regular season team for the third time running, and fourth time in six years. St. Louis finished 98-64, just two games ahead of their arch-nemesis Washington. It was an uncomfortably close finish for a team that won the Gulf Division by 13 games in each of the last two seasons. The clubs were tied heading into their final two-game set at Griffith Stadium on Sept. 29-30, which the Dark Reds swept. The Mons blew a late 4-1 lead in the first game as Teddy Higuera allowed three straight homers to Darrell Porter, Tony Phillips, and Dan Pasqua. Steven Ontiveros then dueled Floyd Bannister to a 0-0 draw before the Maroons won it in the 11th. Alvin Davis reached after SS Rey Quinones bobbled the ball, and then scored on Phillips' double. Mark Eichhorn then locked down the win with a 1-2-3 inning and the Maroons uncorked the champagne.
The clubs surged ahead of the pack in July, were 1-2 throughout the second half, and both posted 55 wins after June 30. Washington now has the distinction of being the first team with 96 wins to not win their division since the 1965 Brooklyn Superbas.
Toronto #2 Seed
With most of the focus on the Gulf battle for first overall and the four-way scramble out west, Toronto flew under the radar to some extent. While they face a challenge from Chicago, the division title was never seriously in jeopardy. Toronto won 95 games again and piece together one of the most power lineups in recent years. Four Polar Bears were named to the All-UL Team, including first-timers Roberto Alomar and Ellis Burks.
Toronto exited in five games last year, but don't look past them as favorites to win their first UL championship in 1989.
Outlaws Steal Pacific
L.A. Stuns Seattle, Makes Ninth Playoffs in a Row
Chicago, Denver Wilt Under Pressure
With three teams tied for sixth heading into the last eight games, the wildcard race looked poised for a dramatic finish. Instead, Los Angeles surged to an 11-1 finish, left Chicago and Denver in the dust, closed a five-game deficit in 12 days, and won a tiebreaker on the road to steal the Pacific Division flag from Seattle. It amounted to one of the most dramatic come-from-behind pennant wins in UL history. L.A.'s pitching was dominant, holding opponents to three runs or less in 10 of the 11 wins.
Meanwhile, while both Chicago and Denver wilted down the stretch. At one point, the Colts had two hits in two games, while Denver lost eight games on the trot to plummet into fourth in the Pacific.
The killer blow for Chicago came on Sept. 27. Needing a win in Detroit to stay within one game of L.A. going into the final three games, the Colts were shutout by Jimmy Jones, a 48th overall pick who had a losing record in B.C. this season and just three major league wins coming into the game. Jones not only won, he dominanted, tossing a one-hit shutout with one walk and seven strikeouts in what BNN ranked as the fourth best pitching performance of the season. Lions-Bears, Pistons-Bulls, Red Wings-Black Hawks, Griffins-Colts: Detroit loves beating Chicago...
The killer blow for Denver came over four days in which they could muster just two runs in four games, at home. They lost 0-4 and 1-2 to Los Angeles, then 0-4 and 1-4 to San Francisco. Needing a miracle in Seattle, they instead gave up a combined nine runs in the first three innings of 1-6 and 3-7 defeats. The walkoff 0-1 loss in the final game at Arroyo Seco was deeply symbolic of Denver's entire season. A gallant—at times excellent effort—that was ultimately all for naught.
Oct. 1 Tiebreaker
At the end of Sept. 30, it was already determined that L.A. and Seattle would meet in the Hex Series. The only question was which team would get home field advantage.
The tiebreaker game on Oct. 1 would determine who won the Pacific, and hence would get the #3 seed, with the other team dropping to the #6 seed.
Both teams started pitchers who had not seen action for months, choosing to save their core starters for the playoff games. The Outlaws started Ron Darling and the Rainiers went with 40-year-old Jim Barr. In a see-saw battle with six errors and four lead changes, L.A. emerged on top, taking the lead for good with a 3-run 7th inning. Cory Snyder doubled in Mike Scioscia for the go-ahead run. L.A. lost CF Jesse Barfield for the season, however. Barfield, who had the second highest bWAR on the team, strained his hamstring making a diving catch in the fifth inning. The catch save two runs, so essentially earned L.A. home field advantage in the Hex Series.
Hex Series Preview
Manhattan Gets Washington in Rematch
The Manhattan Gray Sox and Washington Monuments will face off in the Hex Series for the third time since 1984, after Washington fell two games short in its bid to dethrone the Gulf Division champion St. Louis Maroons. Washington ended the season the with second best overall record, but landed in the 5th seed. Meanwhile, the Dingy Hose tied for 7th best overall but earned the 4th seed complements of their sixth straight Atlantic Division crown. The Mons will have to guard against overconfidence heading into the series. Washington is 8-2 against Manhattan in the playoffs and was 8-2 against them in the regular season. The Mons beat the Sox in six games in 1984 and swept them in 1987 en route to GM Mark Waller's first UL title.
The other Hex Series will feature the Seattle Rainiers and Los Angeles Outlaws, the two survivors of a heated four-way battle in the Pacific Division. A World Series team a year ago, the Rainiers are making their first playoff return in club history, while Los Angeles has won 90 games and made the playoffs nine years in a row.
L.A. beat Seattle in seven games in the 1981 Hex Series, Seattle's first playoff series in franchise history, taking Game 7 in the Dome with a 3-run homer by catcher Milt May in the 10th inning en route to their first UL title.
1989 All-UL Team
Four Polar Bears Picked, Trammell Gets Eighth Ullie
A quartet of Toronto Polar Bears were named to the 1989 All-UL Team, the first time four players from one team won the honor since five Boston Federals made the team in 1979. Dwight Gooden won his fifth nomination and Wally Joyner his second, while Roberto Alomar and Ellis Burks each got their first award.
Alan Trammell got his eight Ullie—his first with Chicago—while Ivan Calderon and Rob Dibble help give Chicago their first multiple nominations since 1978.
Washington's ERA champion Bret Saberhagen and Teddy Higuera became the first starting tandem named to the team since Cleveland's Johnny Podres and Earl Francis in 1967. Wade Boggs won his fourth straight nomination at third base.
Atlanta's Brian Harper got his fourth Ullie in a tightly contested race at catcher, and Boston's Barry Bonds got his second nomination ahead of an almost certain second MVP Award. Gooden is widely expected to capture his fourth Cy Young Award, which would put him in elite company. Only Larry Dierker has more Cy Youngs in his career.
The All-UL Team, the most prestigious award after the MVP and Cy Young Award, is chosen by the commissioner and consists of one player at each position, three starting pitchers, and one reliever. The league has announced that beginning in 1990, the team will expand from 12 to 15 players, with a fourth starting pitcher and new wildcard slots for infielder and outfielder.
1989 All-UL Team
C Brian Harper, ATL (4)
1B Wally Joyner, TOR (2)
2B Roberto Alomar, TOR (1)
3B Wade Boggs, WAS (4)
SS Alan Trammell, CHI (8)
LF Barry Bonds, BOS (2)
CF Ellis Burks, TOR (1)
RF Ivan Calderon, CHI (1)
SP Dwight Gooden, TOR (5)
SP Bret Saberhagen, WAS (2)
SP Teddy Higuera, WAS (1)
RP Rob Dibble, CHI (1)
Four By Four
Assessing the UL's Four-Division Era
With the United League's sixth expansion less than a month away and the imminent return of the two-division alignment, the editors of Circuit Clouts thought this an opportune moment to look back at the six years of the league's four-division format. (While others asked, why don't you wait until the playoffs are done, boneheads?)
The league moved to four divisions in 1984, when the addition of Toronto and Havana brought the league to a deliciously arithmatic 16 teams. In fit of exponential ecstasy, the powers that be could not resist carving the 16 teams into four divisions of four.
The format called for the division winners to be joined by two wildcard teams, with the top two division winners earning byes into the Semi Semis. While popular from the outset, the format has led to some wacky playoff seedings—none wackier than this year when 96-win Washington got the fifth seed with the second best record, while Manhattan got the fourth seed tied for the seventh best record. Nevertheless, the format has provided consistently thrilling playoff races at overall, divisional, and wildcard levels—often at the same time. And in five seasons so far, five different teams have lifted the UL Championship Trophy. So what more do you want?
Here's a ranking each of the four divisions based on how their teams have fared over the last six years. [This article will be updated with a final tally after the 1989 playoffs.]
4. Atlantic Division
1 titles (MAN 1986)
Playoff Record: 16-25
The Manhattan Gray Sox have the distinction of being the only team to win their division every year. The ManSox' consistency has been exemplary, even if this mini-dynasty is a far cry from the capital-D Dynasty of the C-Rob '70s. Critics may credit some of the Sox' success to playing in the weakest of the four division. Indeed, half of the division flags came despite winning less than 90 games, and the Sox have struggled in the postseason, going 14-21 with a single World Series win (1986). Still, six straight division wins is no small feat in an era.
Brooklyn is the only other Atlantic team to make the playoffs. That came in 1984 and required a one-game playoff win against Toronto, after which the Bas crashed out 2-4 in the Hex Series to Los Angeles. More recently, the division has been weak, with no winning teams below Manhattan in 1988 and 1989.
3. Lakes Division
1 title (DET 1984)
Playoff Record: 17-27
Detroit was king of the Lakes, with the division created at the midpoint of the Griffins' peak years, 1982-85, when they averaged 99.5 wins per year, captured three President's Trophies, and won back-to-back titles in 1983 and 1984. Though Detroit declined, they still won four straight Lakes crowns before finishing second and falling to a wildcard in 1988. In the last two years, Toronto has dominated, with back-to-back 95-win seasons and first round byes.
Detroit's playoff record during the four-division era was 13-19, including a 2-12 stretch from 1985-87 when they were bounced by Gulf foes St. Louis and Atlanta (twice). Toronto was a disappointing 1-4 last year, and Chicago was 3-4 in its lone Hex Series appearance in 1985.
2. Pacific Division
1 titles (LA 1985)
Playoff Record: 39-39
Once the weakest division by far (with 68-94 earning second place in 1984), the Pacific ends the era as arguably the strongest, or at least most competitive of the dour divisions. Much like Detroit in the Lakes, Los Angeles dominated in the early years, winning by 29 games in 1984, 18 in 1986, and 20 in 1987. But in 1988, a resurgent Seattle took the division by one game and in 1989, all four teams were in contention going into the final week. The Pacific has sent two teams to the playoffs in three of the last four seasons.
Los Angeles made the playoffs all six years, including a three-year run as a top-2 seed from 1985-87. They won the title in '85, but lost to Manhattan in six in the '86 Fall Classic, and were bounced 1-4 by Washington in '87. In '84, '86, and '87, they were eliminated by the eventual league champions.
The Outlaws playoff record is 39-41. San Francisco was 3-4 in 1986, losing a Hex Series Game 7 to St. Louis, while Seattle's was 10-8 with a deep run to the World Series in 1988.
1. Gulf Division
2 titles (WAS 1987, STL 1988)
Playoff Record: 71-54
From the day the divisions were created, the Gulf was lauded by pundits as the group of death. And while St. Louis has won the flag five of six times—missing by a single game in 1985—the Gulf Division was consistently the most competitive of the four divisions. The division has sent two teams to the playoffs every year but one, and sent three teams in 1987, with 92-win Atlanta finishing third. Washington averaged just under 90 wins throughout the era, won the division in 1985, and wildcards three other years, including the 1987 championship season.
St. Louis' playoff record was lackluster for a four-time #1 seed: 33-32, with one World Series win, two World Series losses, and two Semi Series exits. Washington was 27-17, including deep runs to the World Series as a wildcard team in 1984 and 1987. Atlanta qualified in 1986 and 1987, with an exemplary 11-9 record, advancing to the Semi Series both times.
A Look Ahead
Next year's reconsituted West Division will feature all four teams from the highly competitive Pacific Division, plus juggernaught St. Louis, contender Chicago, Atlanta, Havana, and expansion Florida. St. Louis, Los Angeles, and Seattle figure to be favorites for the three playoff spots.
The 1990 East Division will have the four Atlantic teams, plus Toronto, Washington, Cleveland, Detroit, and Keystone. Washington, Toronto, and Manhattan figure to be the top three.
Atlantic W L GB 2ndH R RA
Manhattan 84 78 - 39-43 2 13
Boston 79 83 5 36-47 5 14
Montreal 62 100 22 29-53 12 12
Brooklyn 62 100 22 32-50 15 16
Gulf W L GB 2ndH R RA
St. Louis 98 64 - 55-27 4 1
Washinton 96 66 2 55-28 9 2
Havana 72 90 26 36-47 7 15
Atlanta 71 91 27 35-47 10 11
Lakes W L GB Last R RA
Toronto 95 67 - 47-35 1 9
Chicago 87 75 8 47-36 16 3
Cleveland 76 86 19 40-43 14 6
Detroit 67 95 28 31-51 13 10
Pacific W L GB Last R RA
Los Angeles 91 72 - 46-36 11 4
Seattle 90 73 1 51-31 3 8
San Francisco 84 78 6½ 40-42 8 5
Denver 83 79 7½ 40-43 6 7
Overall W L GB
1 STL 98 64 +2
2 TOR 95 67 +8
3 LA 91 72 +1
4 MAN 84 78 +5
5 WAS 96 66 +5½
6 SEA 90 73 -
7 CHI 87 75 2½
8 SF 84 78 5½
9 DEN 83 79 6½
10 BOS 79 83 10½
11 CLE 76 86 13½
12 HAV 72 90 17½
13 ATL 71 91 18½
12 DET 67 95 22½
15 MON 62 100 27½
16 BRO 62 100 27½
Top seed - 1st round bye
Division winner
Wildcard
+GB refers to divisional lead
Batting Average
Tony Gwynn ATL .377
Wade Boggs WAS .367
Chris Brown SEA .350
Mark Grace SF .348
Willie McGee SEA .340
Willie Upshaw SEA .337
Kirby Puckett BOS .334
Barry Bonds BOS .334
Brian Harper SEA .332
Tim Raines WAS .329
Home Runs
Jose Canseco MAN 50
Rafael Palmeiro TOR 49
Ellis Burks TOR 44
Barry Bonds BOS 42
Sixto Lezcano DEN 42
Mark McGwire ATL 42
John Shelby SEA 42
Howard Johnson TOR 41
Eric Davis ATL 37
Rob Deer SF 36
Eddie Murray CLE 36
RBIs
Jose Canseco MAN 142
Rafael Palmeiro TOR 137
Eddie Murray CLE 131
Ellis Burks TOR 122
Barry Bonds BOS 121
Sixto Lezcano DEN 118
Wally Joyner TOR 116
Ruben Sierra MON 111
Chris Brown SEA 109
John Shelby SEA 109
bWAR
Barry Bonds BOS 10.2
Wade Boggs WAS 8.0
Ivan Calderon CHI 7.4
Ellis Burks TOR 6.9
Eric Davis ATL 6.7
Lenny Dykstra STL 6.5
Alan Trammell CHI 6.5
Chris Brown SEA 6.4
Kal Daniels HAV 6.3
Roberto Alomar TOR 6.3
Earned Run Average
Bret Saberhagen WAS 2.04
Joe Magrane CLE 2.41
Dwight Gooden TOR 2.46
Dave Schmidt STL 2.51
Ed Whitson STL 2.65
Stvn Ontiveros STL 2.86
Teddy Higuera WAS 3.02
Floyd Bannister WAS 3.07
Dave Beard LA 3.25
Fern Valenzuela ATL 3.33
Wins
Dwight Gooden TOR 20
Bret Saberhagen WAS 19
Ed Whitson STL 19
Greg Hibbard SF 18
Steven Ontiveros STL 18
Dave Schmidt STL 18
Tommy Boggs MAN 17
Don Robinson SEA 17
Mario Soto TOR 17
Floyd Bannister WAS 16
Rick Reuschel DEN 16
Strikeouts
Dwight Gooden TOR 271
Fern Valenzuela ATL 252
Dave Beard LA 235
Floyd Youmans MON 228
Teddy Higuera WAS 227
Jose Rijo SF 225
Rick Reuschel DEN 193
Jose DeLeon SF 191
Don Robinson SEA 191
Bret Saberhagen WAS 186
pWAR
Dwight Gooden TOR 11.3
Fern Valenzuela ATL 8.0
Bret Saberhagen WAS 7.6
Dave Beard LA 6.5
Bob Shirley ATL 5.4
Ed Whitson STL 5.3
Stvn Ontiveros STL 5.2
Tommy Boggs MAN 5.1
Dave Schmidt STL 5.0
Teddy Higuera WAS 5.0
Infield Zone Rating
Ozzie Smith DEN 15.2
Cal Ripken Jr. BOS 12.8
Ozzie Guillen SEA 8.8
Robin Yount WAS 8.8
Gary Gaetti DEN 8.5
Outfield Zone Rating
Stan Javier DEN 15.5
Tom Brunansky LA 14.9
Lloyd Moseby WAS 12.8
Andy Van Slyke LA 10.7
Ellis Valentine MAN 10.2
Batter of the Month
APR Barry Bonds BOS
MAY Rafael Palmeiro TOR
JUN Dave Winfield WAS
JUL John Shelby SEA
AUG Jose Canseco MAN
SEP Wally Joyner TOR
Pitcher of the Month
APR Dave Schmidt STL
MAY Ed Whitson STL
JUN Allan Anderson SEA
JUL Terry Mulholland CHI
AUG Dave Schmidt STL
SEP Steven Ontiveros STL
Rookie of the Month
APR Jeff M. Robinson CHI
MAY Steve Olin CLE
JUN Dwight Smith DET
JUL Ken Griffey Jr. BRO
AUG Greg Hibbard SF
SEP Scott Scudder HAV
Player of the Week
4/10 Lonnie Smith MON
4/17 Wally Joyner TOR
4/24 Brian Harper SEA
5/1 Barry Bonds BOS
5/8 Jose Canseco MAN
5/15 Jesse Barfield LA
5/22 Shane Mack HAV
5/29 Rafael Palmeiro TOR
6/5 Chris Brown SEA
6/12 Dave Winfield WAS
6/19 Terry Pendleton HAV
6/26 Ozzie Guillen SEA
7/3 Rafael Palmeiro TOR
7/10 Danny Tartabull MAN
7/17 Ivan Calderon CHI
7/24 Barry Bonds BOS
7/31 Barry Bonds BOS
8/7 Wade Boggs WAS
8/14 Tony Gwynn ATL
8/21 Jose Canseco MAN
8/28 Mark Grace SF
9/4 Mark McGwire ATL
9/11 Tony Gwynn ATL
9/18 Mike Stanley ATL
9/25 Barry Bonds BOS
LA SP Rick Camp (7 mo)
SEA SP Scott Garrelts (5 wk)
TOR SP Allen Ripley (10 mo)
TOR RP Michael Jackson (3 mo)