Unit 9.7 - Resistance to Globalization After 1900

THEMATIC FOCUS

Cultural Developments and Interactions

The development of ideas, beliefs, and religions illustrates how groups in society view themselves, and the interactions of societies and their beliefs often have political, social, and cultural implications

LEARNING OBJECTIVE

Explain the various responses to increasing globalization from 1900 to present.

HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENTS

KC-6.3.IV.iv Responses to rising cultural and economic globalization took a variety of forms.

ILLUSTRATIVE EXAMPLES

Responses to economic globalization:

§ Anti-IMF and anti-World Bank activism

§ Advent of locally developed social media (Weibo in China)

State Responses to economic globalization

§ Advent of locally developed social media (Weibo in China)

  • Chinese political leaders/authorities are going to great lengths to ensure that China and its communications system control the information from capitalist powers such as the United States.

  • officials of China’s Public Security Bureau (an agency that concerns itself with crimes ranging from murder to cultural espionage)

      • are trying to contain the influence of the Internet by erecting around China a so called “firewall” or fanghuo qiang (a direct translation from the English).

      • The more prevailing and popular phrase for it is wangguan (literally, “net wall”), a name that invokes many centuries of Chinese efforts to repulse foreign invaders.

Sina Weibo

  • microblogging service that has been called a Twitter clone

      • launched on August 14, 2009

      • allows people to create, distribute, and discover Chinese-language content

  • has become the premier platform for important political and social discourse in China

  • March 2017 -- Sina launched Sina Weibo International Version

  • June 2020, Weibo was among 58 other Chinese apps that were banned by the government of India

  • carefully censored by the Cybersecurity Administration of China

      • Sina Weibo has attracted criticism over censoring its users

      • sets strict controls over the posts on its service

          • URL shortening services (including Google's goo.gl), or containing blacklisted keywords are not allowed on Sina Weibo

          • Posts on politically sensitive topics are deleted after manual checking

          • Nearly 30% of the total deletion events occur within 5–30 minutes

          • nearly 90% of the deletions happen within the first 24 hours

Activist Responses to economic globalization

§ Anti-IMF and anti-World Bank activism

Background on the IMF

  • International Monetary Fund (IMF) was founded at the Bretton Woods Conference in New Hampshire in 1944

  • Goals: the IMF promotes market economies, free trade, and high growth rates

Supporters of the IMF believe:

  • the global economy delivers markets that operate with maximum efficiency, speedily directing goods and services wherever there is demand for them and always expecting the highest returns possible

  • the new economy is the only way to bring prosperity

      • the kind previously enjoyed only by industrialized nations to the developing world

Overview of Criticism of the IMF

  • Who they are:

      • nongovernmental organizations ranging from labor unions to tribal-rights activists

  • their view:

      • the global economy is an untamed juggernaut that is neither inevitable nor desirable

      • a force that rewards the few and impoverishes the many

      • They assert that globalization diminishes the sovereignty of local and national governments

      • transfers the power to shape economic and political destinies to transnational corporations and global institutions such as the IMF and the WTO

      • the hallmark of globalization—rapid economic development—is responsible for:

          • the destruction of the environment

          • the widening gap between rich and poor societies

          • the worldwide homogenization of local, diverse, and indigenous cultures

  • in recent years, many of the nations who created the IMF (United States, United Kingdom, etc.) have joined the criticism

Anti-IMF movement after the Cold War

  • global justice movement emerged in the 1990s

      • international coalition of political activists, concerned scholars and students, trade unions, women’s and religious organizations, environmental groups, and others, hailing from rich and poor countries alike

  • believed that free-trade, market-driven corporate globalization had:

      • lowered labor standards

      • fostered ecological degradation

      • prevented poor countries from protecting themselves against financial speculators

      • ignored local cultures

      • disregarded human rights

      • enhanced global inequality, while favoring the interests of large corporations and the rich countries

  • late 1999 -- in Seattle at a meeting of the World Trade Organization (WTO) tens of thousands of protesters—academics, activists, farmers, labor union leaders from all over the world—descended on Seattle in what became a violent, chaotic, and much-publicized protest.

  • 2001 -- alternative globalization activists created the World Social Forum, an annual gathering to coordinate strategy, exchange ideas, and share experiences, under the slogan “Another world is possible.”

CLASS ACTIVITY -- SAQ (IMF)

Activity

1.) See the links below--you don't really have to view them all. I simply wanted you to see the scope of the anti-IMF movement.

2.) Answer all parts of the SAQ questions below:

A.) Identify a pre-20th century example of states attempting to establish a balance of power for the purpose of stability

B.) Identify a check on the role of the IMF during the period 1945-1990.

C.) Explain the criticism of the IMF that emerged after 1990.

DEBRIEF AND SUMMARY

Key Takeaways

A.) Many resisted the powerful international lending agencies such as the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund imposing free-market and pro-business conditions on many poor countries if they were to qualify for much needed loans.

  • favored the reduction of tariff

  • free global movement of capital

  • a mobile and temporary workforce

  • the privatization of many state-run enterprises

  • the curtailing of government efforts to regulate the economy

  • both tax and spending cuts

B.) Widening gap between the Global North and the Global South

  • disparities in incomes, medical care, availability of clean drinking water, educational and employment opportunities, access to the Internet, and dozens of other ways

  • Trade issues have included:

      • the rules for world trade

      • availability of and terms for foreign aid

      • representation in international economic organizations

      • the mounting problem of indebtedness

      • environmental standards

      • labor standards

C.) Obstacle to reforming the world economy in favor of the poor lay in growing disparities among the developing countries themselves

  • oil-rich economies of the Middle East had little in common with the banana-producing countries of Central America

  • industrializing states of China, India, and South Korea had quite different economic agendas than impoverished African countries

Unit 9 Topic 7 - RESISTANCE to Globalization after 1900

Unit 9.7 - Resistance to Globalization After 1900

How China Tracks Everyone

Censorship on China's Sina Weibo

Vice Podcast

A Tour of Weibo - China's Twitter/Facebook

Gravitas Plus: Who is responsible for Climate Change?