The process by which societies group their members and the norms that govern the interactions between these groups and between individuals influence political, economic, and cultural institutions and organization.
LEARNING OBJECTIVE
Explain the various causes and consequences of mass atrocities in the period from 1900 to the present.
HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENTS
KC-6.2.III.C The rise of extremist groups in power led to the attempted destruction of specific populations, notably the Nazi killing of the Jews in the Holocaust during World War II, and to other atrocities, acts of genocide, or ethnic violence.
ILLUSTRATIVE EXAMPLES
Genocide, ethnic violence, or attempted destruction of specific populations:
§ Armenians in the Ottoman Empire during and after World War I
§ Cambodia during the late 1970s
§ Tutsi in Rwanda in the 1990s
§ Ukraine in the Soviet Union in the 1920s and 1930s
§ Holocaust during World War II
After 1913 the Ottoman state adopted a new policy of Turkish nationalism intended to shore up the crumbling imperial edifice
The new nationalism stressed Turkish culture and traditions, which only aggravated tensions between Turkish rulers and non-Turkish subjects of the empire.
the state viewed Christian minorities as an obstacle to Turkism
During the Great War, the Ottoman government branded Armenians as a traitorous internal enemy, who threatened the security of the state, and then unleashed a murderous campaign against them
Forced mass evacuations, accompanied by starvation, dehydration, and exposure, led to the death of tens of thousands of Armenians.
An equally deadly assault on the Armenians came by way of governmentorganized massacres that claimed victims through mass drowning, incineration, or assaults with blunt instruments
Those wartime atrocities that took place principally between 1915 and 1917 have become known as Armenian genocide.
Best estimates suggest that close to a million Armenians perished.
it is generally agreed that the Armenian genocide did occur, the Turkish government in particular rejects the label of genocide and claims that Armenian deaths resulted not from a state-sponsored plan of mass extermination but from communal warfare perpetrated by Christians and Muslims, disease, and famine
Timeline of the Khmer Rouge led by Pol Pot
1969 -- The US begins a secret bombing campaign against North Vietnamese forces on Cambodian soil
1970-1975 -- Under the Marxist leader Pol Pot a civil war broke out: The Khmer Rouge used the United States’ actions to recruit followers and as an excuse for the brutal policies they exercised when in power.
1975 -- Cambodia Year Zero-All city dwellers are forcibly moved to the countryside to become agricultural workers. Money becomes worthless, basic freedoms are curtailed and religion is banned. The Khmer Rouge coin the phrase "Year Zero".
1975-1978 -- Hundreds of thousands of the educated middle-classes are tortured and executed in special centers. Others starve, or die from disease or exhaustion. The total death toll during the next three years is estimated to be at least 1.7 million out of a population of 7,890,000
21% of the population of Cambodia was killed
1979 (January) -- The Vietnamese take Phnom Penh. Pol Pot and Khmer Rouge forces flee to the border region with Thailand
Tutsi formed the traditional aristocratic minority in:
Rwanda-about 9 percent of the population
Burundi--about 14 percent of the population
14th-15th century, Tutsi came to establish dominance and establish a feudal relationship with the Hutu (Tutsi brought cattle and more advanced military knowledge)
Hutu-Bantu culture and viewed as racially inferior by Belgium. Background Video
Belgian colony from 1916-1961.
Tutsi’s favored by Europeans politically, economically, etc.
1972-unsuccessful Hutu rebellion in Burundi was suppressed by the government at a cost of 100,000 lives, most of them Hutu
April-July 1994-in the midst of a military campaign by Tutsi exiles to retake Rwanda, the Hutu-dominated government there instigated genocidal massacres of hundreds of thousands of Tutsi.
100 Days of slaughter--Est. 800,000 (mostly Tutsi) killed
This did not prevent the Tutsi exiles’ army (Rwandese Patriotic Front) from overrunning the country soon afterward and ousting the Hutu regime.
The RPF victory created 2 million more refugees (mainly Hutus) from Rwanda
Holodomor: Forced Famine in Ukraine, 1932-1933
Holodomor (meaning, “hunger-extermination” in Ukrainian)
Yale University historian Timothy Snyder estimates that 3.3 million people died as a result of the Holodomor
By the end of 1933, nearly 25 percent of the population of the Ukraine, including three million children, had perished
Stalin refused international aid offers from Britain, French and the United States
official policy of the Soviet Union to deny the existence of a famine and thus to refuse any outside assistance
The Soviets then sealed off the borders of the Ukraine, preventing any food from entering, in effect turning the country into a gigantic concentration camp
Soviet police troops inside the Ukraine also went house to house seizing any stored up food, leaving farm families without a morsel.
Soviet-controlled granaries were said to be bursting at the seams from huge stocks of 'reserve' grain, which had not yet been shipped out of the Ukraine
spring of 1933, the height of the famine, an estimated 25,000 persons died every day in the Ukraine
Stalin's view of the Ukraine
With the collapse of the Czarist rule in March 1917 Ukrainians declared their country to be an independent People's Republic and re-established the ancient capital city of Kiev as the seat of government
By 1921 Lenin's Red Army, and also against Russia's White Army (troops still loyal to the Czar) as well as other invading forces including the Germans and Poles defeated Ukrainian national troops
western part of the Ukraine was divided-up among Poland, Romania, and Czechoslovakia
Soviets immediately began shipping out huge amounts of grain to feed the hungry people of Moscow and other big Russian cities
Under NEP
Lenin relaxed his grip on the country, stopped taking out so much grain, and even encouraged a free-market exchange of goods.
This breath of fresh air renewed the people's interest in independence and resulted in a national revival movement
Under Stalin
1929 -- over 5,000 Ukrainian scholars, scientists, cultural and religious leaders were arrested after being falsely accused of plotting an armed revolt. Those arrested were either shot without a trial or deported to prison camps in remote areas of Russia.
Stalin also imposed the Soviet system of land management known as collectivization
By mid 1932, nearly 75 percent of the farms in the Ukraine had been forcibly collectivized.
Stalin's orders, mandatory quotas of foodstuffs to be shipped out to the Soviet Union were drastically increased in August, October and again in January 1933, until there was simply no food remaining to feed the people of the Ukraine.
The Holocaust, the near destruction of European Jews by Germany, was a human disaster on a scale previously unknown.
Nazi determination to destroy the Jewish population and Europeans’ passive acceptance of anti-Semitism laid the groundwork for genocide
Initially, the regime encouraged Jewish emigration
tens of thousands of Jews availed themselves of the opportunity to escape from Germany and Austria, many more were unable to do so
Most nations outside the Nazi orbit limited the migration of Jewish refugees, especially if the refugees were impoverished, as most of them were because Nazi authorities had previously appropriated their wealth
Post 1939 -- after the start of WWII
Nazi “racial experts” toyed with the idea of deporting Jews to Nisko, a proposed reservation in eastern Poland, or to the island of Madagascar, near Africa
The concentration of Jews in one area led to the dangerous possibility of the creation of a separate Jewish state
SS Einsatzgruppen (“action squads”)
When German armies invaded the Soviet Union in June 1941, the Nazis also dispatched three thousand troops in mobile detachments known as SS Einsatzgruppen
purpose was to kill entire populations of Jews and Roma (or Gypsies) and many non-Jewish Slavs in the newly occupied territories.
The action squads undertook mass shootings in ditches and ravines that became mass graves
By the spring of 1943, the special units had killed over one million Jews, and tens of thousands of Soviet citizens and Roma.
“final solution”
Wannsee Conference on 20 January 1942, fifteen leading Nazi bureaucrats gathered to discuss and coordinate the implementation of the final solution of the Jewish question
They agreed to:
evacuate all Jews from Europe to camps in eastern Poland
where they would be worked to death or exterminated
Jewish victims packed into these suffocating railway cars never knew their destinations
camps such as Kulmhof (Chelmno), Belzec, Majdanek, Sobibòr, Treblinka, and Auschwitz, the final solution took on an organized and technologically sophisticated character
Nazi's used gassing as the most efficient means for mass extermination
The German commandant of Auschwitz explained proudly how his camp became the most efficient at killing Jews:
by using the fast-acting crystallized prussic acid Zyklon B as the gassing agent
by enlarging the size of the gas chambers
and by lulling victims into thinking they were going through a delousing process.
other means of destruction were always retained, such as electrocution, phenol injections, flamethrowers, hand grenades, and machine guns
The largest of the camps was Auschwitz, where at least one million Jews perished.
Nazi camp personnel subjected victims from all corners of Europe to industrial work, starvation, medical experiments, and outright extermination
the Germans also constructed large crematories to incinerate the bodies of gassed Jews and hide the evidence of their crimes
This systematic murder of Jews constituted what war crime tribunals later termed a “crime against humanity”
Approximately 5.7 million Jews perished in the Holocaust
Jewish Resistance
The best-known uprising took place in the Warsaw ghetto in the spring of 1943
Lacking adequate weapons, sixty thousand Jews who remained in the ghetto that had once held four hundred thousand rose against their tormentors.
It took German security forces using tanks and flamethrowers three weeks to crush the uprising
Other Notable Examples:
The impetus behind the establishment of comfort houses for Japanese soldiers came from the horrors of Nanjing, where the mass rape of Chinese women had taken place.
forced into brothels set up by the Japanese military during World War II
women came from all over southeast Asia, but the majority were Korean or Chinese
Between 20,000 and 410,000 women had been enslaved in at least 125 brothels
Estimated that at the end of World War II, 90 percent of the “comfort women” had died
Women who had been forced into sexual slavery became societal outcasts. Many died of sexually transmitted infections or complications from their violent treatment at the hands of Japanese soldiers; others committed suicide.
the “comfort women” catered to between twenty and thirty men each day
Stationed in war zones, the women often confronted the same risks as soldiers, and many became casualties of war
many were killed by Japanese soldiers, especially if they tried to escape or contracted venereal diseases
After the war
At the end of the war, Japanese soldiers massacred large numbers of comfort women to cover up the operation
United States authorities allowed “comfort stations” to operate well past the end of the war and that tens of thousands of women in the brothels had sex with American men until Douglas MacArthur shut the system down in 1946
the practiced was continued by the Communists during the Chinese Civil War
Japan denied the practice existed until 1993
2015-Japanese government announced it would give reparations to surviving Korean “comfort women”
Cause
In January 1904, the Herero people – also called the Ovaherero – rebelled. More than a hundred German civilians were killed. The smaller Nama tribe joined the uprising the following year.
German Response
German Colonial rulers responded without mercy. Tens of thousands of Herero were forced into the Kalahari desert, their wells poisoned and food supplies cut.
Gen Lothar von Trotha, sent to quell the revolt, ordered his men to shoot “any Herero, with or without a rifle, with or without cattle”
“I do not accept women or children either: drive them back to their people or shoot them,” he told his troops
Results:
Half of the total Nama population were also killed
As many as 3,000 Herero skulls were sent to Berlin for German scientists to examine for signs that they were of racially inferior peoples
Thousands of women were systematically raped, often taken as “wives” by settlers.
Surviving Herero forced onto reservations
December 1937 Nanjing had fallen to the Japanese
residents of Nanjing became victims of Japanese troops inflamed by war passion and a sense of racial superiority
Over the course of two months, Japanese soldiers raped seven thousand women
murdered hundreds of thousands of unarmed soldiers and civilians
burned one-third of the homes in Nanjing
Four hundred thousand Chinese lost their lives as Japanese soldiers used them for bayonet practice and machine-gunned them into open pits
estimated 800,000 deaths in Croatian death camps
1929: Pavelic formed Croatian nationalist Ustasha Party to destroy Yugoslavia and form independent Croatia: “Realm of God”—only Catholics had right to exist; 1934: Yugoslav King Alexander assassinated by Ustasha
April 6, 1941: Kingdom of Yugoslavia dismembered between Germany, Italy, Hungary and Bulgaria
April 10, 1941: Axis Powers (Germany/Italy) and Vatican created Independent State of Croatia (NDH) led by Pavelic/Cardinal Stepinac with 2 million Serbs living in that territory; within days NDH outlawed Serbian language and Cyrillic alphabet, began persecutions of Serbs, Jews, Roma
Mass murders began immediately and continued for next four years
Policy of Racial Purity: Triple Genocide--Serbs to be eliminated by:
killing 1/3,
expelling 1/3,
converting to Catholicism 1/3
Croatian genocide against Serbs committed by Ustasha, Catholic priests and Bosnian Muslims of ~700,000 mostly Serbs, Jews, Roma and dissident Croats; ~240,000 forced to convert
Jasenovac complex: killing methods: revolver, machine guns, bombs, knives, axes, hatchets, wooden hammers, iron bars, iron hammers, hoes, trampling, hanging, burning, etc
Leading role played by Catholic Church
Post-war communist regime of Tito immured knowledge of Croatian Death camps; brotherhood and unity policy
Artukovic, “Himler of the Balkans,” not extradited from California until 1986; Cardinal Manning: “a great and good man;” “I was guided by the Moral Principles of the Catholic Church”
1995: Elimination of Serbs from Croatia started by Pavelic/Stepinac was completed by Tudjman/Kuharic
Operation Storm--During and after the offensive, 150,000–200,000 Serbs—or nearly the entire Serb Population of the area formerly held by the ARSK—fled and a variety of crimes were committed against the remaining civilians there
Croatia’s chief backer was NATO
Activity
Patterns of Continuity and Change over Time
What in Zlata’s account reminds you of other accounts of living through a war?
A Child’s Account of the Shelling of Sarajevo
Context: When Bosnia declared its independence in March 1992, Serbian army units and groups of Bosnian Serbs went on the offensive and began to shell the capital city of Sarajevo. One of its residents was Zlata Filipovic´ (ZLAH-tuh fil-ih-POH-vich), the ten-year-old daughter of a middle-class lawyer. Zlata was a fan of MTV and pizza, but when the Serbs began to shell Sarajevo from the hills above the city, her life changed dramatically, as is apparent in this excerpt from her diary
Source: From Zlata’s Diary by Zlata Filipovic´, copyright ª 1994 by Fixot et editions Robert Laffont
Zlata Filipovic´, Zlata’s Diary, A Child’s Life in Sarajevo
April 3, 1992. Daddy came back . . . all upset. He says there are terrible crowds at the train and bus stations. People are leaving Sarajevo.
April 4, 1992. There aren’t many people in the streets. I guess it’s fear of the stories about Sarajevo being bombed. But there’s no bombing. . .
April 5, 1992. I’m trying hard to concentrate so I can do my homework (reading), but I simply can’t. Something is going on in town. You can hear gunfire from the hills.
April 6, 1992. Now they’re shooting from the Holiday Inn, killing people in front of the parliament. . . . Maybe we’ll go to the cellar. . . .
April 9, 1992. I’m not going to school. All the schools in Sarajevo are closed. . . .
April 14, 1992. People are leaving Sarajevo. The airport, train and bus stations are packed. . . .
April 18, 1992. There’s shooting, shells are falling. This really is WAR. Mommy and Daddy are worried, they sit up late at night, talking. They’re wondering what to do, but it’s hard to know. . . . Mommy can’t make up her mind—she’s constantly in tears. She tries to hide it from me, but I see everything.
April 21, 1992. It’s horrible in Sarajevo today. Shells falling, people and children getting killed, shooting. We will probably spend the night in the cellar.
April 26, 1992. We spent Thursday night with the Bobars again. The next day we had no electricity. We had no bread, so for the first time in her life Mommy baked some.
April 28, 1992. SNIFFLE! Everybody has gone. I’m left with no friends.
April 29, 1992. I’d write to you much more about the war if only I could. But I simply don’t want to remember all these horrible things.
Activity
When examining mass atrocities, one will often see the death toll expressed in two ways:
1.) total number of dead
2.) percentage of the population impacted by the mass atrocity
Is there a purpose for historians or governments to express the impact of such events in one way over the other?
Why is some of the information incomplete in this data set?
Examples:
USA in the Philippines (counter insurgency campaign, (1899-1902) = 2.8% of the population of the Philippines
Bosnia (1990’s) = 2.8% (“ethnic cleansing;” Serbs targeting Muslims and Croats)
Rwanda = 13% (800,000 killed; Hutu majority targeting Tutsi) of the population of Rwanda
Cambodia = 20-25% of population killed (Khmer Rouge under Pol Pot from 1975-1979; 1.5-3 million killed)
Indonesia = 1965 massacres of suspected communist = (0.5-0.7%--Similar to the Soviet Union under Stalin)
February 1947 (Nationalist Army massacre under Chiang) = 10,000-20,000 people
China's Cultural Revolution = 1966-1976 -- 1.6-1.7 Million are the generally accepted (750-million people in China, thus 1.3% of population)
some estimates go as high as 8-Million killed
Key Takeaways
A) Mass atrocities require cooperation from many interests (cooperation can be active or passive)
B.) Structures to combat mass atrocities arose following WWII
Nuremberg Trials -- 1945-1949
a series of 13 trials included Nazi Party officials and high-ranking military officers along with German industrialists, lawyers and doctors, were indicted on such charges as crimes against peace and crimes against humanity.
set the precedent for an international trial of war criminals
December 10, 1948 -- The United Nations adopted the Universal Declaration of Human Rights
December 14, 1950 -- The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees established
mandate to protect refugees, forcibly displaced communities and stateless people, and assist in their voluntary repatriation, local integration or resettlement to a third country
July 1, 2002 -- International Criminal Court
international tribunal in The Hague, Netherlands
Day 1
day 2
(Some scenes may be difficult to watch for some viewers--viewer discretion is advised. This is NOT a required video)