The development of ideas, beliefs, and religions illustrates how groups in society view themselves, and the interactions of societies and their beliefs often have political, social, and cultural implications.
LEARNING OBJECTIVE
Explain the causes and effects of the ideological struggle of the Cold War.
HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENTS
KC-6.2.IV.C.ii The global balance of economic and political power shifted during and after World War II and rapidly evolved into the Cold War. The democracy of the United States and the authoritarian communist Soviet Union emerged as superpowers, which led to ideological conflict and a power struggle between capitalism and communism across the globe.
KC-6.2.V.B Groups and individuals, including the Non-Aligned Movement, opposed and promoted alternatives to the existing economic, political, and social orders.
ILLUSTRATIVE EXAMPLES
Non-Aligned Movement:
§ Sukarno in Indonesia
§ Kwame Nkrumah in Ghana
democracy of the United States and the authoritarian communist Soviet Union /capitalism and communism across the globe
Post-WWII View from Washington
Did not want devastated nations to fall to Soviet-backed communism
Post WWII Goals:
Economic reconstruction of Europe
Military superiority
Containment
The Post-WWII View from Moscow
9-14 million Soviet soldiers killed in WWII
8+ million civilians killed
Invaded by Germany twice in the past 30 years
Fearful of an invasion by the USA and England (like after WWI)
Across the globe
Fight over human rights, Enlightenment ideas
Fight over resources and markets for goods
Competition over allies (military & economic)
Not all countries allied themselves with the USA or USSR. Many tried to stay neutral as part of the Non-Aligned Movement
Cold War manifested itself in a variety of ways
Nuclear Arms race
Olympics
1956 Olympics-Blood in the Water match (Hungary vs USSR)
1980 Olympic hockey
Space Race
Sputnik
Moon landing
Proxy Wars
Hostility without direct military confrontation between the two Superpowers
Proxy wars in Korea, Vietnam & Afghanistan
The founding fathers of the Non-Aligned Movement were Sukarno of Indonesia, Jawaharlal Nehru of India, Josip Broz Tito of Yugoslavia, Gamal Abdul Nasser of Egypt, [and] Kwame Nkrumah of Ghana.
1955 Bandung Conference
a conference of Asian and African states hosted by the Indonesian President Sukarno who gave a significant contribution to promote this movement
it's underlying principles, the Dasa Sila Bandung, or Ten Principles of Bandung were introduced.
The attending Nations declared the desired not to become involved in the Cold War and adopted a declaration on promotion of world peace and cooperation.
Conference of Asian and African (29 nations) nations (NOT Australia, Israel, South Africa)
American Richard Wright' attends and writes The Color Curtain
The real split in the globe isn’t the Iron Curtain, but the curtain between black and brown on one side, and white on the other.
September 1961 in Belgrade
the first conference and heads of state or government of non-aligned countries
Tito needed this as a means to resist Soviet influence.
They meet throughout the ‘60’s, but The notion of Non-Alignment unravels
cohesion of Bandung erodes
Once the colonial powers are removed from Asia and Africa, the cohesion of Bandung erodes. Religion, ethnicity, and race prove to be a divisive force:
Sino-Indian War (1962 )
Sino-Vietnamese War (1979)
Cambodian-Vietnamese War (1977-1991)
Indo-Pakistan War of 1965; Indo-Pakistan War of 1971
1971 Bangladesh genocide
Background of Indonesia
200 major language groups.
200 major ethnic groups
Largest population of Islamic country in the world
Christian, Buddhist, Hindu minorities
Became a Dutch colony in 1800 when the V.O.C. dissolved due to
Bankruptcy
1942-Japanese conquer and throw the Dutch out. Est. 3-Military districts
The elites who worked for the Dutch were absorbed by the Japanese
These elites flee in 1945
August 17, 1945-Sukarno proclaims independence (same as in IndoChina)
The Dutch decide (like the French) that they will reclaim their colony
The Dutch do well militarily against the insurgents, but lose politically
Not able to establish a stable political order, and fail to get US support
Independence
1949-the Dutch leave (most of) Indonesia and it becomes an independent state.
Problems:
Same issues the Dutch had: diversity, decentralized islands, etc.
SuKarno takes aid from:
First the USA
Then the Soviets
Then the Communist Chinese Sukarno
The USA worries about the Communist financial ties
1965-military coup
Sukarno survives
Fear of communist may take over
1965-2nd military coup
Muhammad Suharto
Suharto is backed by the USA
Muhammad Suharto (ruled 1965-1998)
anti-communist purge to est. “New Order”
500,000 + killed in a few weeks
1.5 Million imprisoned
Ethnic Chinese minority targeted
Regarded as one of the most corrupt ruler in 20th Cent.
Suharto and his family are alleged to have embezzled between $15 billion – $35 billion
Maintained a stable regime
Kept Communist out of Indonesia
Green Revolution enabled population to grow
Reliable regime for the USA
Returned to the Gold Coast (Ghana) in 1949
believed that India's independence had set in motion a process of gradual transfer of power in Britain's other colonies
with several associates he set up a new party, the Convention People's Party (CPP)
1951 -- won limited self-rule elections
Nkrumah became "Leader of Government Business" -- a de facto prime minister
Self-Rule (1960)
Kwame Nkrumah made Ghana a republic and proclaimed himself its president
April 1961, he delivered a "Dawn Broadcast"
force the resignation of potential rivals
Soon there were political arrests
threw out the British officers assigned to train his army
"scientific socialism"
1961 -- The United States (Kennedy) signed on to the Volta River Project to prevent the Soviet Union from becoming the backer of Ghana
1961 -- Nkrumah visited the Soviet Union and returned much impressed at the pace of industrialization there
He came back with a rigid Seven-Year Plan
January 22, 1966 -- Volta Dam completed
"We must try and establish factories in large numbers at great speed"
State-owned companies and public authorities mushroomed in all fields
So did mismanagement and graft
The price was most painfully felt in the countryside as Nkrumah used cocoa revenues, controlled by the official marketing board, to cover the growing losses of public companies
Results:
Many farmers switched crops altogether due to unrealistically low cocoa prices
combined with the bloated organization of the marketing board
others found ways to smuggle their cocoa through neighboring countries, where better prices were offered
Ghana lost its mantle as the world's largest cocoa producer
Its currency reserves depleted, it fell back on barter trade and loans from the Soviet bloc
"the Redeemer"
1964 -- turned the country into a one-party state
took to indulging in a sordid cult of personality
dubbing himself Osagyefo, "the Redeemer."
Overthrown in a coup d'etat
Feb. 1966-Nkrumah, while traveling to China, was overthrown in a coup
He ended up taking up exile in Guinea, where another experiment in "African socialism" was in progress.
Guinea's president, Sekou Toure, his own rule increasingly repressive and arbitrary, endowed Nkrumah with the title of "co-president" until his death in 1972.
Activity
1.) Use the documents below to write a claim / category of analysis using the following prompt:
Prompt: Analyze the causes and effects of the Cold War.
2.) Source the documents in one way using H.I.P.P. relevant to your argument
H-Historical Context
I-Intended Audience
P-Purpose
P-Point Of View (limitations of using the document)
Source: A speech of President Sukarno of Indonesia to the Bandung Conference, a gathering of leaders from newly independent countries in Asia and Africa, in 1955.
War...may mean the end of civilization and even of human life. There is a force loose in the world whose potentiality for evil no man truly knows...What can we do? We can do much! We can inject the voice of reason into world affairs. We can mobilise all the spiritual, all the moral, all the political strength of Asia and Africa on the side of peace. Yes, we! We, the peoples of Asia and Africa, 1,400,000,000 strong, far more than half the human population of the world, we can mobilise what I have called the Moral Violence of Nations in favour of peace. We can demonstrate to the minority of the world which lives on the other continents that we, the majority, are for peace, not for war, and that whatever strength we have will always be thrown on to the side of peace.
Source: A speech of President Jawaharlal Nehru of India to the Bandung Conference, a gathering of leaders from newly independent countries in Asia and Africa, in 1955.
The preservation of peace forms the central aim of India’s policy. It is in the pursuit of this policy that we have chosen the path of nonalinement [nonalignment] in any military or like pact of alliance. Nonalinement does not mean passivity of mind or action, lack of faith or conviction. It does not mean submission to what we consider evil. It is a positive and dynamic approach to such problems that confront us. We believe that each country has not only the right to freedom but also to decide its own policy and way of life. Only thus can true freedom flourish and a people grow according to their own genius.
Key Takeaways
A.) The nonalignment strategy proved instrumental in fashioning a compelling position for newly independent nations caught in the cold war and in the superpower tug-of-war contests for the loyalties of new nations.
an attempt to find a “third path,” an alternative to choosing either the United States or the Soviet Union
stressed the struggle against colonialism and racism
primary goal was to maintain formal neutrality
B.) Shortcomings of Nonaligned Movement:
suffered from a chronic lack of unity among its members
ultimately failed to present a genuinely united front
theoretically nonaligned with either cold war superpower, many member states had close ties to one or the other, and this situation caused dissension within the movement
Remember,
• Your claim should be more universal than just what is in the document
• It is not enough to identify the audience, purpose, historical situation, or audience. You need to give the “so what?” of it as well.
This short video is screened at the 50th anniversary of Non-Aligned Movement in Bali, May 2011.