Assignment 1
Visual Research Infographic
Visual Research Infographic
Assignment Brief:
An embedded system is a specialized computing system that is dedicated to performing specific functions within a larger system or device. Unlike general-purpose computers, which can run a variety of applications, embedded systems are designed to execute a predetermined set of tasks or functions. They are often integrated into devices, products, or systems to control specific functions or features.
Key characteristics of embedded systems include:
Dedication to Specific Tasks: Embedded systems are tailored to perform specific functions or tasks, and they are not intended for general-purpose computing.
Real-Time Operation: Many embedded systems require real-time processing capabilities, meaning they must respond to inputs or events within a specific timeframe.
Integration: Embedded systems are integrated into larger systems or products, such as household appliances, automotive systems, medical devices, industrial machinery, or consumer electronics.
Optimized Hardware and Software: Hardware and software in embedded systems are often optimized for the specific task they are designed to perform. This can result in efficient use of resources and reduced power consumption.
Reliability: Embedded systems are engineered for reliability, as they are commonly used in critical applications where system failures can have significant consequences.
Examples of embedded systems include microcontrollers in home appliances, automotive control systems, industrial automation devices, medical equipment, smart thermostats, and many others. They play a crucial role in various industries, contributing to the functionality and automation of numerous devices and systems in our daily lives.
Topic: "Embedded Systems in Automated Doors - Train vs. Mall"
Embedded systems are the brains behind the automated doors we encounter in trains and malls, seamlessly integrating technology into our everyday environments. These sophisticated systems combine sensors, controllers, and actuators to make doors smart—opening when needed and ensuring safety and efficiency. In trains, they adapt to high-speed demands, while in malls, they cater to high traffic and accessibility. This comparison highlights the essential role embedded systems play in modern infrastructure, emphasizing their impact on convenience and security.
Train automated doors are designed for transportation vehicles and must adhere to the safety and operational requirements of a moving train. They need to function reliably at high speeds, accommodate frequent openings and closings at stations, and ensure passenger safety during transit.
Mall automated doors are typically installed in static environments, such as shopping malls. They are designed to provide convenient and controlled access for pedestrians, with a focus on user comfort, energy efficiency, and aesthetics.
Usage Patterns: how frequently the doors operate in each setting?
Train Doors: the doors operate almost every 3 to 5 minutes during peak hours, and less frequently during off-peak hours.
Mall Doors: the doors have a constant flow of users, with occasional surges during lunch hours and evening times.
User Interaction: how individuals interact with the doors?
Train Doors: Users expect train doors to open and close quickly; there's minimal interaction, often dictated by the train schedule.
Mall Doors: Shoppers approach mall doors at varying speeds and with different levels of attention, potentially causing erratic door responses.
Responsiveness: what is the response time of the doors from when a user approaches to when the doors actually open?
Train Doors: often within a second after the train has stopped, to facilitate quick boarding and disembarking.
Mall Doors: might be slightly delayed to manage energy efficiency, opening only when a person comes within a certain range.
Train Automated Doors:
Sensors:
Proximity sensors: Detect the presence of passengers and obstacles to ensure safe boarding and alighting.
Speed sensors: Monitor the train's speed to coordinate door operations during stops.
Control Unit (Microcontroller):
Microcontroller: Acts as the brain of the embedded system, processing sensor inputs and sending signals to control door opening and closing.
Actuators:
Door actuator: Mechanism responsible for physically opening and closing the doors in response to control signals.
Safety Features:
Emergency stop mechanisms: Enable immediate halting of door movement in case of emergencies or irregularities.
Redundant systems: Provide backup mechanisms to enhance reliability and safety.
Communication Systems:
Communication interfaces: Facilitate real-time communication with the train's central control system and other doors for coordinated operations.
Mall Automated Doors:
Sensors:
Motion sensors: Detect the movement of individuals approaching the door to initiate opening.
Infrared sensors: Monitor the presence of people to prevent door closure when someone is in the doorway.
Control Unit (Microcontroller):
Microcontroller: Processes sensor inputs and controls the motorized opening and closing of the doors.
Actuators:
Motorized door actuator: Powers the automatic movement of the doors in response to control signals.
User-Friendly Features:
Presence detection: Ensures doors remain open as long as someone is in the detection zone for user convenience.
Slow opening/closing: Enhances user safety and comfort during door operation.
Energy Efficiency Features:
Power management systems: Optimize energy consumption by controlling when doors open and close based on traffic patterns.
Used by Train doors
Edge Sensors:
Function: Placed along the edges of the door, these sensors detect any pressure or obstruction.
Application: Quickly respond to obstructions during the closing process, preventing accidents.
Used by Mall doors
Motion Sensors:
Function: Detect movement within a specified range.
Application: Activate the door to open when motion is detected, facilitating hands-free entry.
Infrared Sensors:
Function: Emit and detect infrared light to determine the presence of objects or individuals.
Application: Commonly used for motion detection and object recognition.
Pressure Sensors:
Function: Measure pressure changes, often triggered by physical contact.
Application: Ensure safety by detecting obstacles, preventing the door from closing on people or objects.
Reliability
Strengths:
Engineered for high reliability due to the critical safety nature of train transportation.
Redundant systems and rigorous testing contribute to reliability.
Challenges:
Must operate reliably under dynamic environmental conditions, including high speeds and varying temperatures.
Validity
Strengths:
Validity is closely tied to safety compliance, meeting rigorous standards and regulations.
Challenges:
Ensuring accurate response to real-time conditions, such as passenger presence and train movements.
Feasibility
Strengths:
Feasibility is supported by the necessity of efficient passenger boarding and alighting during train stops.
Challenges:
Balancing design for safety, speed, and reliability in the context of high-speed rail travel.
Ethics
Strengths:
Prioritizing passenger safety and efficient transit contributes to ethical considerations.
Challenges:
Ensuring accessibility for all passengers, addressing potential technical failures promptly, and minimizing the risk of accidents.
Reliability
Strengths:
Designed for frequent use in a controlled environment, emphasizing reliability in smooth and predictable operation.
Challenges:
Maintenance is critical to avoid malfunctions, as failure to open or close properly may impact user experience.
Validity
Strengths:
Validity is linked to providing an inviting and functional entrance, meeting user expectations.
Challenges:
Ensuring doors respond accurately to various user scenarios, such as individuals with mobility aids.
Feasibility
Strengths:
Feasibility is supported by the need for convenient and energy-efficient entry and exit in commercial spaces.
Challenges:
Balancing design elements for aesthetics while ensuring doors are feasible for all users.
Ethics
Strengths:
Prioritizing user experience, accessibility, and energy efficiency align with ethical considerations.
Challenges:
Ensuring doors do not pose safety hazards, addressing potential privacy concerns with sensor technologies, and providing clear indications of door behavior.
Automated doors, in trains and malls, conserve energy by:
Opening only when necessary.
Minimizing heat loss/gain.
Reducing HVAC load.
Advanced systems optimize energy use with:
Adjustable opening/closing speeds based on traffic flow.
Materials with better insulation.
Integration of solar panels for enhanced sustainability.
The future of automated doors includes:
Integration of smart technology like IoT for real-time monitoring and predictive maintenance.
Biometric authentication for access control.
AI for crowd management and personalized experiences.
Touchless activation technologies are standard for health considerations.
As urban spaces become more connected, automated doors integrate into smart city frameworks, contributing to efficient urban management and enhanced public safety.
Agarwal, T. (2019a) Automatic door opening system using PIR sensor, ElProCus. Available at: https://www.elprocus.com/automatic-door-opening-system-project-circuit/ (Accessed: 24 February 2024).
Agarwal, T. (2019b) Automatic door opening system using PIR sensor, ElProCus. Available at: https://www.elprocus.com/automatic-door-opening-system-project-circuit/
Dvorak, L. et al. (2019) ‘TEST OF DOORS OBSTRUCTION DETECTION SENSOR’, MM Science Journal, 2019(2), pp. 2897–2901. doi:10.17973/mmsj.2019_06_201881.
Granger, J. (2022) Automatic doors for buildings: How they work & why they matter, ButterflyMX® - Official Site | Video Intercoms & Access Control. Available at: https://butterflymx.com/blog/automatic-doors-for-buildings/#:~:text=enable%20touchless%20entry%3F-,How%20do%20automatic%20doors%20work%3F,the%20mechanism%20opens%20the%20door.
Nabco (no date) Mechanism - About Automatic Door, Mechanism | About Automatic Door | NABCO Automatic Door. Available at: https://nabco.nabtesco.com/en/automatic-door/structure/#:~:text=Automatic%20door%20opens%20when%20the,a%20designated%20period%20of%20time
Nexus (2022) New trains: Doors and automatic sliding step, YouTube. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GAhf9W2MhMQ
Noonan, S. (2023) Passenger train doors, Passenger Train Doors. Available at: https://www.robsonforensic.com/articles/passenger-train-door-expert#:~:text=Operational%20controls%20are%20either%20pushbutton,train’s%20positioning%20in%20a%20station.
Pass, S. (2021) Automatic door opening sensor systems, Contactless Door Access Control System. Available at: https://thesecurepass.com/blog/automatic-door-opening-technology
Solidworks Fun (2020) How metro train door works | automatic sliding door mechanism animation, How Metro Train Door Works | Automatic Sliding Door Mechanism Animation. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ykv5dUomd8E
Visual Infographic
For Assignment 1 of the Embedded Systems module, we are tasked with creating a visual research infographic on embedded systems in spatial design fields that interest us. I spent considerable time determining which topic intrigued me most for research. Among various possibilities, smart homes did not appeal to me, and I leaned more toward traffic systems. Initially, I considered embedded systems in traffic lights, inspired by a friend studying computer science who had worked on a related project. I thought I could seek his help and advice. However, after some contemplation, my interest gravitated toward railway systems like MRTs and LRTs. ChatGPT informed me that these are not classified as road traffic systems, as they operate on separate infrastructure and often have their own dedicated control and management systems.
Thus, I decided to delve deeper into researching the automatic doors of railways, feeling that Malaysia's transit system had significant room for improvement in safety features and door systems. Non-functional doors are a common sight and can negatively impact passengers' experiences and safety. During a conversation with my elder sister, where I used automated doors to illustrate my current challenges, and tried pointing out the notable differences between mall doors and train doors. She suggested that a comparison of the two could be an insightful angle for my assignment, an idea that resonated with me, this could be a good approach!
Having chosen the topic "Embedded Systems in Automated Doors - Train vs. Mall," my next step was to understand how automated doors function and how those in trains and malls differ. My findings revealed substantial differences in their usage and functions. Mall doors must manage constant heavy traffic, incessantly opening and closing upon detecting someone's approach. In contrast, train doors are programmed to open only at stations and close before departure, not responding to passengers' immediate needs but incorporating safety features to prevent injury from closing doors.
As I was initially uncertain about my direction, I began creating my visual infographic concurrently with my research. The introduction and comparison sections, focusing on reliability, validity, feasibility, and ethics, were my starting points. Then I found it challenging to find directly related references on the Internet, especially comparisons between the two types of doors. Fortunately, as my research progressed, more relevant information emerged. I discovered that although train and mall doors serve similar purposes, they are fundamentally different. The Internet and some AI tools broadened my understanding of the embedded systems in both, revealing that they use different sensors for different situations. This prompted me to add more sections to my infographic to showcase my findings. My observations, becoming a key part of my research methodology, were also added into it.
For the compilation of my visual research, I initially used Adobe Illustrator, but technical issues with my laptop hindered my progress. Out of frustration, I switched to Canva and started from scratch, as no suitable templates were available. I experimented with various paper sizes, settling on the one that best suited the growing amount of research information. As a result, the font size became progressively smaller. Finding appropriate illustrations was challenging, so I turned to AI tools for assistance. The arrangement of the infographic components took several attempts to refine, resulting in the final presentation as it stands now.
In conclusion, the journey of creating this infographic for my Embedded Systems module assignment was as much about personal growth as it was about academic achievement. Navigating through the initial uncertainty to a topic that sparked genuine interest was a lesson in itself, showing the value of perseverance and exploration. The research and design process, with its challenges and triumphs, not only resulted in a comprehensive visual document but also provided a deeper understanding of the subject matter. This experience has left me with a greater appreciation for the meticulous nature of research and the power of visual communication in translating complex data into accessible knowledge. It also gives me better insights of what this module, Embedded Systems, is all about.