Brooklyn, Cleveland End 20-Year Pennant Droughts
Superbas at the Wire
Brooklyn Edges Manhattan on Penultimate Day
The Brooklyn Superbas completed one of the epic comebacks in UL pennant race history, narrowing a 10-game margin in the final five weeks to eclipse their crosstown rivals at the finish line.
Brooklyn had made the World Series just last year, but a 29-36 start had GM Tim Widholm's side mired in 7th place and written off by the pundits. A July rally eventually got the club over .500, but at 65-60 on Aug. 18, Brooklyn sat 10 games out of 1st with 35 to play, entertaining no illusions of a division pennant. Instead, their focus was on 3rd place, which was within their grasp amidst a four-way scrum with Boston, Keystone, and Toronto. What followed in the next 40 days was one of the biggest comebacks for a pennant in league history.
The first surge came Aug. 19-21, when Brooklyn won four straight, while Manhattan dropped three of four, slicing the lead from 10 to 7. When the Gray Sox lost five in a row Aug. 27-Sep. 1, Brooklyn took advantage, winning five straight to take sole possession of 2nd place just four games back. The next surge came Sep. 11-17, when Manhattan went 2-5 and Brooklyn went 4-1, pulling within a half-game.
The next game, on Sep. 18, was the biggest of the year, with Brooklyn visiting Manhattan with first place on the line. Fitting the occasion, the Sox rallied from 5-0 behind with 5-spot in the eighth, which featured a pair of two-run homers by Damion Easley and Ed Sprague, sending the game into extra frames. Then Mark Whiten send the Hudson Yards crowd into hysterics with a walk-off three-run dinger off Hector Fajardo, pushing the Dingy Hoses' lead to 1.5 games. Manhattan won their next two, expanding their lead to two games on Sep. 21. But another 2-4 dip Sep. 22-28, while Brooklyn went 3-2 set up a crucial battle for the pennant on Sep. 29.
Manhattan came into what was their final game of the season 89-70. Brooklyn was 88-70 and still had a game at Keystone on the 30th. The two clubs split their prior 10 meetings, setting up a one-game contest for the pennant. If Manhattan won, they would win the East outright with 90 wins; if Brooklyn won, they would at least tie Manhattan for first but take the pennant on the better head-to-head record.
Pat Hentgen (13-10) started for the visiting Gray Sox, while rookie righthander Brian Moehler (4-5) started for the home team. Joe Nunnally homered twice and Manhattan collected 14 hits, but it wasn't enough, as Brooklyn touched Hentgen for five runs and scored three more on Xavier Hernandez. Moehler left after two innings with an injury, and a committee of six relievers finished the game. Ivan Calderon homered twice, Ken Griffey Jr. added another, and each drove in three runs in a 9-8 win.
The win capped a 10-game comeback in just over 40 days and delivered the Superbas' first division pennant in exactly 20 years. Speaking of 1976, that was the year that Brooklyn and Manhattan met in the first, and only, Subway Series. In that instance, it was the World Series and Manhattan won 4-2—the first of four consecutive Gray Sox titles. However, if Manhattan gets by Boston in the Hex Series, we could see another Subway Series for the East Division crown.
Cleveland Tops West
Barons Claim First Pennant Since 1973
Unlike the East Division, the West race lacked drama, at least in terms of which teams would qualify for the playoffs. Atlanta, Chicago, and Cleveland occupied the top three spots uninterrupted from June 18, with a gap of six games separating them from the rest of the pack on Sept. 18.
The real drama was in the three-way race for the division pennant, and the all-important first round bye. In late August, the three clubs were tightly intertwined, rarely more than a game apart from each other. Then Atlanta took the lead, building a narrow two-game gap that they maintained until Sept. 21. Then the Toppers lost four straight, sending the division race into a three-way scrum in the final days. After the games of Sep. 26, Chicago and Cleveland shared first with 92-64 records, with Atlanta a half-game behind at 92-65. The Toppers destroyed Cleveland 12-1 on the 27th, sending the Barons to 3rd, but GM Charlie Qualls' club then rattled off three straight wins, including a 12-9 win over Chicago to win the division by a game over Atlanta.
The Toppers lost the pennant on the season's last day, in Detroit. Having won 7 of 11 against the Barons, Atlanta just needed a win over the Griffins to tie Cleveland at 95-65 and claim the pennant by head-to-head record. Instead, reliever Tom Henke barfed up four late runs, and the Flyin' Lions rolled to an 8-3 win.
Cleveland ended a 21-year playoff drought last year, and now wins its fourth division pennant in club history, and first since 1973. As for the Toppers, it was a bitter ending for a club that had led the division for much of August and September. However, in the big picture, the season represented a restoration of one of league's most dominant pitching teams. Pedro Martinez and Fernando Valenzuela are likely to finish 1-2 in Cy Young voting, and with Dwight Gooden and Darryl Kile, the Toppers rotation figures to give them a distinct advantage in short-series October baseball.
More Parity, Yet More Offense
This year's pennant races were the closest and most intense in several seasons. Both divisions were decided by one game or less (the East was a tie), and nine teams finished within six games of first place (the average since 1984 was five), and five teams finished within two games of first, equalled only by 1990 in the two-division eras. In recent years, only the 1980 and 1990 seasons compare.
In 1980, Denver and San Francisco tied for first, with Los Angeles just two back, while Boston edged Brooklyn by two games. In 1990, Toronto, Boston, and Washington all finished one game apart, while Los Angeles edged Chicago by two. Cleveland claimed its first President's Trophy with the lowest win total (95) in 15 years. Since 1984, the average wins for the best team in the league was 102.
This season also saw a continuation of the smashball era. Runs per game were up another 3 percent to 5.08, the third highest average in league history, as the third pitchers' park in two years was taken offline with the move of the Chicago Colts from Comiskey Park to Wrigley Field. Home runs (174/team), SLG (.428), and OPS (.768) were at all-time highs. The league ERA of 4.70 was the highest since the inaugural year of 1951 and only six qualifying pitchers had ERAs under 3.50.
Last years, runs per game exploded by 30 percent. With this year's further increase in offense, the owners may take up the issue during the winter meetings to consider rule changes or adjustments to bring scoring back down to historical norms.
Ups and Downs
The 1996 season saw the decline of some traditional league juggernaughts. The Los Angeles Outlaws declined by 19 wins, missing the postseason for the first time in 16 years, and the Detroit Griffins led the league with a precipitous 32-game decline, ending a four-year playoff run. And last year's East Division pennant-winners, Keystone, dropped by 12 games to finish under .500 and out of the playoffs.
On the positive side of the ledger, the Denver 14ers were the circuit's most improved club, advancing by 14 wins to their first winning season in seven years. Meanwhile, Atlanta recovered from its 1995 dip. The Hilltoppers had an historic 110-win campaign in 1994, only to decline by 28 games last year. In '96, the Toppers bounced back, improving to 94-66 (+12) to make a playoff return.
IMPROVED DECLINED
DEN +14 DET -32
ATL +12 LA -19
MON +9 FLO -14
BOS +8 KEY -12
HAV +7 MPS -10
MAN +7
WAS +4 (note: two fewer games this season)
BRO +3
SEA +3
STL +2
CHI +1
TOR +1
CLE -2
East W L GB 2ndH R RA
Brooklyn 89 71 - 47-29 4 7
Manhattan 89 71 - 39-37 9 5
Boston 86 74 3 42-34 6 12
Toronto 85 75 4 38-38 2 11
Havana 84 76 5 46-32 8 6
Keystone 77 83 12 33-44 7 14
Montreal 74 86 15 41-35 14 16
Washington 70 90 19 39-47 16 13
Florida 65 95 24 35-42 18 8
West W L GB 2ndH R RA
Cleveland 95 65 - 45-31 5 9
Atlanta 94 66 1 45-31 3 1
Chicago 93 67 2 42-34 1 10
St. Louis 89 71 6 43-33 13 3
Denver 83 77 12 39-37 10 4
Los Angeles 82 78 13 36-40 11 2
Minneapolis 63 97 32 28-48 12 18
Detroit 62 98 33 28-48 15 17
Seattle 60 100 35 30-46 17 15
PLAYOFF PREVIEW
GMs Eric Holthaus and Mark Waller will meet in the playoffs for the fifth time, with Holthaus looking for his first win after four straight Hex Series defeats from 1984-92. On the other hand, Manhattan has never lost to Boston in the playoffs, with one Semi Series and two World Series triumphs during the Gray Sox 1970s dynasty.
MANHATTAN 3-0 vs BOSTON
1977 Semi MAN 4-3
1978 WS MAN 4-2
1979 WS MAN 4-3
This season: BOS 6-5
WALLER 4-0 vs HOLTHAUS
1984 Hex WAS 4-3 MAN
1987 Hex WAS 4-0 MAN
1989 Hex WAS 4-3 MAN
1992 Hex WAS 4-2 MAN
Atlanta and Chicago have never met in the postseason, but GMs Peter Vays and Andy Chaney have met twice before, with Vays' Los Angeles Outlaws taking 4-2 Semi Series wins over the Toppers in 1986 and 1994.
ATLANTA vs CHICAGO
no prior meetings
This season: CHI 7-4
VAYS 2-0 vs CHANEY
1986 Semi LA 4-2 ATL
1994 Semi LA 4-2 ATL
TOP STORIES
The Brooklyn Superbas and Cleveland Barons won their first division pennants since the mid-70s, ending droughts of 20 and 23 years respectively. Brooklyn Superbas closed a 10-game gap with 35 to play to win their first division pennant since 1976, which Cleveland came out on top of a tight three-way race for the West title.
The Atlanta Hilltoppers, led by Cy Young favorites Pedro Martinez and Fernie Valenzuela, led the league in pitching and booked their second playoff appearance in three years.
New Chicago GM Peter Vays moved the Colts to Wrigley Field, where they posted the best home record (59-21) helping secure the Ponies fourth playoffs in seven years.
Manhattan led the East most of the season but settles for their first postseason in four years. Boston edged Toronto by a single game to book its second playoffs in three years.
Tony Gwynn (ATL) won his first batting title, Barry Bonds (STL) his fourth HR and WAR titles, Eric Karros (TOR) his first RBI title, and Carlos Delgado (CLE) led the league in OPS.
Pedro Martinez (ATL) won his fourth strikeout and third ERA title, Fernie Valenzuela (ATL) led the league with 22 wins, and Tim Scott (HAV) led the league with 42 saves.
May 18 - STL Vince Coleman
500 stolen bases (#22)
May 23 - ATL Tony Gwynn
3000 hits (#6)
May 31 - ATL Dwight Gooden
200 wins (#21)
Jun 15 - ATL Fernie Valenzuela
200 wins (#22)
Aug 8 - STL Barry Bonds
500 stolen bases (#23)
Aug 14 - SEA Otis Nixon
600 stolen bases (#11)
Aug 26 - LA Andy Van Slyke
2500 hits (#21)
Sep 8 - ATL Dwight Gooden
3000 strikeouts (#16)
Aug 14 - WAS Ryne Sandberg
700 stolen bases (#6)
Sep 29 - CHI Alan Trammell
1500 RBI (#11)
INJURIES
(playoff teams only)
BRO RP Mike Greenwell (3 wk)
BRO SP John Smiley (3 wk)
CHI RP Chris Holt (season)
MAN SS Tony Graffanino (1 wk)
After ending a 21-year playoff drought last year, the Barons ended a 23-year pennant drought. Cleveland's offense finished in the top five for the first time since 1965, as RF Carlos Delgado (.338-37-111) had a breakout year, leading the league in SLG and OPS, and CF Jim Edmonds (.312-31-89) was red-hot down the stretch. Cleveland's pitching dipped from 2nd to 9th, but Ismael Valdez was 15-9, 4.17 and former Seattle Rainier Doug Henry was 10-3, 2.46 with 18 saves.
After World Series appearances in 1993 and 1995, the Bas won their first division pennant since 1976 with a win over Manhattan on Sep. 29. Ken Griffey Jr. posted his lowest WAR in six years but still managed .303-32-101, .969; Matt Williams (.270-38-123) led the club in HR and RBI; and second-year RF Marty Cordova had a breakout year with .288-26-102, 5.6 WAR. The staff was led by Kevin Brown (16-7, 3.02), who was 2nd in ERA, and the 2nd-ranked bullpen was led by closer Greg McMichael (28 SV, 3.11).
For the third time in four years, Atlanta had the best pitching staff, led Pedro Martinez (16-3, 2.60), who led the league in ERA, strikeouts, WHIP, and WAR and is the clear favorite to earn his second Cy Young Award. The likely runner-up is #2 starter Fernie Valenzuela, who went 22-6 for the second time in three years and posted a 7.0+ WAR for the sixth time in his career. Tony Gwynn (.380) won his 5th batting title and Manny Ramirez surpassed 30/100 for the first time.
The surprise team of the year, the Gray Sox led the East most of the season and tied for first after being predicted to to land mid-table. The pitching staff finished in the top 5 for the first time in eight years, with six pitchers with 10 wins and sub-4.60 ERAs (the league ERA was 4.70 and Manhattan plays in a hitters' park). Ace Pat Hentgen (13-10, 4.31) led in most categories. At the plate Ed Sprague (.255-29-104) and sophomore RF Jon Nunnally (.291-22-89) had breakout years.
With a new GM and a new ballpark, the Colts made a playoff return after a two-year absence. The second-winningest team since 1991, the Colts have won at least 90 games in six of the last seven years. Chicago led the league with 5.6 runs per game, with four 100-RBI men, led by Gary Sheffield (.324-40-120) and Albert Belle (.323-37-102)
The Feds improved by eight wins to earn an second postseason in three years. 3-4-5 hitters Mike Piazza, Jim Thome, and Ellis Burks all hit over .290-30-100, and the fourth-year 1B Thome hit career high .300 and .947 OPS. Jon Lieber (15-9, 4.02) and Billy Taylor (39 SV, 3.60) both recovered from a sophomore slumps, and Kenny Rogers won a career-high 18 while leading the league with 0.5 HR/9.
GM Glen Reed ended his 16-year tenure in St. Louis as he started it: with two non-playoff years. The Maroons ranked 3rd in pitching, led by surprising 36-year-old starter Jim Gott (20-8, 3.29), but the offense sank to new lows, ranking just 13th in runs, despite another MVP-caliber season for Barry Bonds (.309-48-124), who won his fourth home run and WAR titles.
The P-Bears were in the thick of the race all year long, but fell one game short of their fourth straight playoff appearance. The offense bounced back to #2 with a league-leading 251 homers, led by Juan Gonzalez (45) and Eric Karros (43). But the 5th best bullpen and 10th best rotation was hampered by the league's worst defense (-57 ZR). Only 21 players had ZRs below -10, and four of them were P-Bears, including CF Raul Mondesi (-19) and 2B Jose Oquendo (-14).
Denver was the most improved club in the league, going 83-77 for just its sixth winning record in 23 seasons, first since 1989, and second best in franchise history. The story was the pitching—which ranked fourth, led by Charles Nagy's 3.68 ERA and the 3rd best bullpen—and defense, which was a net-positive in ZR for the first time in seven years. At the plate, veteran 1B Mark Grace (.337-17-100) had a career year and rookie CF Darin Erstad (.309-11-93) was a leading Rookie of the Year candidate.
Havana missed the playoffs by two games, marking the fourth time since 1990 they have missed by four games or less. Their 84 wins ties for the 2nd most in club history, and they posted their best run differential. Shane Reynolds won a career high 17, Sean Bergman was 15-8, 3.69, and Tim Scott led the league with 42 saves. Raffy Palmeiro posted his 8th 100-RBI season with .315-28-122 and newcomer Bip Roberts had a .365 OBP with 35 steals.
Under new GM Bear Jackson, Los Angeles' long playoff run came to an end. An aging lineup finally caught up with the Outlaws, who finished 11th in offense behind the declining bats of Eric Davis (34) and Tony Phillips (36), who had the worst years of their careers. The pitching managed to finish 2nd in runs allowed, despite two-time Cy Young winner Floyd Youmans' worst season in a decade. Greg Swindell (17-7, 3.34) led the staff and tossed in a no-hitter as a bonus.
What a difference a year makes. Twelve months ago, the Starlings were the league's Cinderella sweethearts, stealing a surprise pennant. They were widely expected to repeat that success this year, but instead flopped below .500 as their high-octane offense misfired. 1995 MVP Wil Cordero hit 45 fewer RBIs, Jeff Bagwell was -27, and Tim Salmon had a career low .824 OPS. Meanwhile, ace William Van Landingham's ERA ballooned a point and a half, and Bill Swift (8-14, 5.82) had one of his worst years.
In their second year in Fridley, the Foxes again finished 7th in the West and again had the league's worst pitching staff. Northpaw Jason Isringhausen (8-10, 3.91, 3.3 WAR) had a solid sophomore year, CF Garret Anderson (.328-18-85) emerged as a star and rookie RF Bobby Abreu (.338, .962 OPS) was a Rookie of the Year candidate.
The V's improved by nine wins for the second straight year and climbed two spots to 7th, led by a pair of rookies. The offense was led by Rookie of the Year favorite (and MVP candidate) Vladi Guerrero. The second overall pick batted .334-38-109 for a 7.6 WAR. The pitching staff was led by 8th overall pick Livan Hernandez (13-10, 4.76), who was 2nd among rookies in wins and strikeouts. Oddly, the Canoeists were 9-1 in extra innings, the 2nd best record in league history (1975 BRO).
After four straight playoff appearances, the Flyin' Lions suffered their worst collapse in club history (32 games) suffering just their second losing season in 18 years. The pitching fell from 8th the 17th and the offense nose-dived from 2nd to 15th. Oddly, the team had minimal roster changes and almost no injuries. Alex Fernandez went from 16-7, 3.85 to 4-17, 6.64; Ryan Klesko, Dave Nilsson, and Larry Walker, and Dwight Smith's OPS dropped 100 points. Despite his decline, Klesko still put up monster numbers (.289-33-90, .953)
In the fourth year of the Jason Gudim regime, the Mons took another baby-step forward, winning 70 games for the first time with an aging roster. Ace Tom Glavine (8-14, 4.14) had the worst season of his career. LF Gregg Jefferies led the club in batting (.313) and RBI (93), but the star attraction was rookie CF Andruw Jones (.236-22-71), who was 4th in bWAR (4.2).
Seattle lost 3/4th of its rotation to injury: Ace Joey Hamilton (5 mo), Wilson Alvarez (career), and Jaime Navarro (3 mo). Only Jack Armstrong avoid the injury bug, and he finished 6-19, 6.20, leading the league in losses. On the bright side, emergency callup Dave Telgheder was 14-14, 4.75, including a 6-0, 2.82 September that earned Pitcher and Rookie of the Month. A pair of rookies flashed glimpses of Seattle's future: SS Nomar Garciaparra (.288-23-93) and closer Mariano Rivera (18 SV, 3.44 ERA).
After three top-5 finishes, the Pink Birds took a step back this season, winning 14 fewer games, the third biggest decline. Ace Mike Mussina had a forgettable season (8-13, 4.64), slicing his WAR by two-thirds, but rookie Francisco Cordova (10-12, 3.41) picked up the slack and Florida still ranked 8th in pitching. At the plate, LF Glenallen Hill had a breakout year (.310-25-88, 5.4 WAR).
Batting Average
Tony Gwynn ATL .380
Juan Gonzalez TOR .347
Carlos Delgado CLE .338
Mark Grace DEN .337
Vladi Guerrero MON .334
Dion James CLE .329
Garret Anderson MPS .328
John Olerud CHI .328
Gary Sheffield CHI .324
Albert Belle CHI .323
RBIs
Eric Karros TOR 133
Barry Bonds STL 124
Frank E Thomas LA 123
Matt Williams BRO 123
Rafael Palmeiro HAV 122
Ellis Burks BOS 121
Juan Gonzalez TOR 121
Tim Salmon KEY 120
Gary Sheffield CHI 120
Jim Thome BOS 115
Infield Zone Rating
Tony Batista STL 26.5
Rey Sanchez STL 26.1
Benji Gil SEA 25.3
Rey Ordonez BOS 25.2
Craig Grebeck CLE 17.2
Home Runs
Barry Bonds STL 48 Juan Gonzalez TOR 45
Eric Karros TOR 43
Gary Sheffield CHI 40
Vladi Guerrero MON 38
Matt Williams BRO 38
Albert Belle CHI 37
Carlos Delgado CLE 37
Cory Snyder TOR 37
Frank E Thomas LA 37
bWAR
Barry Bonds STL 8.0
Vladi Guerrero MON 7.6
Ken Griffey Jr BRO 7.6
Gary Sheffield CHI 7.2
Juan Gonzalez TOR 6.7
Jim Thome BOS 6.3
Jeff Cirillo LA 6.1
Mike Piazza BOS 6.1
John Olerud CHI 6.0
Tony Gwynn ATL 5.7
Outfield Zone Rating
F.P. Santangelo MAN 26.1
Darin Erstad DEN 25.2
Stan Javier LA 23.7
Andruw Jones WAS 23.3
Ken Griffey Jr BRO 17.3
Earned Run Average
Pedro Martinez ATL 2.60
Kevin Brown BRO 3.02
F. Valenzuela ATL 3.26
Jim Gott STL 3.29
Greg Swindell LA 3.34
Franc. Cordova FLO 3.41
Mike Grace TOR 3.66
Charles Nagy DEN 3.68
Sean Bergman HAV 3.69
Floyd Youmans LA 3.72
Strikeouts
Pedro Martinez ATL 265
Steve Cooke CHI 231
Fern Valenzuela ATL 213
Mike Mussina FLO 191
Floyd Youmans LA 175
Jon Lieber BOS 173
Sean Bergman HAV 171
Darryl Kile ATL 171
Roger Clemens MAN 169
Greg Swindell LA 169
Wins
Fern Valenzuela ATL 22
Steve Cooke CHI 21
Jim Gott STL 20
Kenny Rogers BOS 18
Shane Reynolds HAV 17
Greg Swindell LA 17
Kevin Brown BRO 16
Britt Burns STL 16
Pedro Martinez ATL 16
John Mitchell CHI 16
Floyd Youmans LA 16
pWAR
Pedro Martinez ATL 8.0
Fern Valenzuela ATL 7.0
Sean Bergman HAV 5.7
Steve Cooke CHI 5.6
Greg Swindell LA 5.3
Shane Reynolds HAV 4.8
Jon Lieber BOS 4.8
Erik Hanson BOS 4.8
Jim Gott STL 4.7
Britt Burns STL 4.5
Batter of the Month
APR Carlos Delgado CLE
MAY Juan Gonzalez TOR
JUN Barry Bonds STL
JUL Bernie Williams FLO
AUG Glenallen Hill FLO
SEP Ken Griffey Jr BRO
Pitcher of the Month
APR Pedro Martinez ATL
MAY JM Robinson CHI
JUN Shane Reynolds HAV
JUL Sean Bergman HAV
AUG Steve Cooke CHI
SEP Dave Telgheder SEA
Rookie of the Month
APR N. Garciaparra ATL
MAY J. Allensworth CHI
JUN Brant Brown TOR
JUL Bobby Abreu MPS
AUG Vladi Guerrero MON
SEP Dave Telgheder SEA
Player of the Week
4/8 Carlos Delgado CLE
4/15 Frank Thomas LA
4/22 Jon Nunnally MAN
4/29 Mike Piazza BOS
5/6 Junior Felix CHI
5/13 Tim Raines DEN
5/20 Eric Karros TOR
5/27 Ryan Klesko DET
6/3 Barry Bonds STL
6/10 Jim Thome BOS
6/17 Carlos Baerga KEY
6/24 Mark Grace DEN
7/1 Marty Cordova BRO
7/8 Tim Salmon KEY
7/15 Albert Belle CHI
7/22 John Olerud CHI
7/29 Gary Sheffield CHI
8/5 Vladi Guerrero MON
8/12 Tony Gwynn ATL
8/19 Mike Piazza BOS
8/26 Carlos Delgado CLE
9/2 Juan Gonzalez TOR
9/9 Barry Bonds STL
9/16 Juan Gonzalez TOR
9/23 Shane Mack HAV
9/30 Rick Wilkins DEN