What is Critical Place Based Education?
"Place-based education (PBE) immerses students in local heritage, cultures, landscapes, opportunities and experiences, using these as a foundation for the study of language arts, mathematics, social studies, science and other subjects across the curriculum. PBE emphasizes learning through participation in service projects for the local school and/or community." (promiseofplace.org)
Summary: This article in particular emphasizes on the importance of a place- based education and why it is so needed in our classroom. The article main focus is on the importance of Ecological Place- Based learning. Gruenewald explains how children must have the opportunity to "bond with the natural world" to truly be a well rounded and educated individual. Within the text it explains how the exposure of the natural world helps students to become more knowledgable of the world around them, while they also then gain respect to the outdoors and nature in their adult years. While this article also expresses how this idea challenges educators, as it forces them to explore other teaching locations other than the classroom. The article also mentions the five main components of place- based education practices which entail, "1) local- cultural studies, 2) local nature studies, 3) community issue- investigation and problem- solving, 4) local internships and entrepreneurial opportunities, & 5) induction into community decision making." (Gruenewald). Overall this articles main goal was to be able to capture and argue the idea how allowing children to learn outside of the classroom, in particular in nature, will expand their knowledge of the places around them and overall improve their education experience as a whole.
Teaching Strategies from the Article:
educators should be open minded to teaching outside of the classroom
find activities that involve being in nature
allow students to explore the areas/place around them
How I would Adapt the Strategies in my Future Classes:
considering I am going into English Education I would take any opportunity to read with my students outside
create field trips that are related to the novels/ texts that are currently being read and discussed in class, to further students connection and image of the stories
By, Tom Vandar Ark
"With repeated place-based experiences, young people are co-creating the future. In a world that is becoming more individualistic, place-based learning invites young people into the community. Learning in a variety of places with a wide range of people builds agency, equity, and community." (Ark)
Summary: This article begins by the author Tom Vandar Ark, reminiscing on his 11- year old self and how his field trip to Washington D.C. led him to find his love for design and architecture. He also mentions how it wasn't the classes itself in which he took in college that he remembered but it was the "work in strange an wonderful places" that lead to his success in his education and career. Further on in the article it explains the potential beneficial factors of place- based education if done so correctly. The article mentions these as " Embedded learning everywhere and views the community as an classroom, "Is centered on individual learners, "Is inquiry-based to help studnets develop an understanding of their place in the world, "Incorporates local and global thinking and investigations", "Requires design thinking to find solutions to authentic problems, and "Is interdisciplinary" (Ark). While the article also mention the three main practices which are essential to place based education which include Agency, Equity, and Community. In regards to agency, the article explains how classroom settings can sometimes take away from a child own "self- knowledge" "social awareness" and "sense and place of time." By allowing studnets to feel like they have power in the classroom and their education will improve their overall learning experience. Equity is explained as the ability to ensure all studnets are getting a fair and equal opportunity to eduction, especially those who are not from high income communities. While also making sure that every child's learns in different ways and is unique and ensuring their educational needs are met. While Community in the article mentions how community based- education brings people together as teye gain knowledge of the places around them. Overall the articles main goal is to show the importance of learning outside of the classroom while making sure to ensure community, agency, and equity in the education system.
Teaching Strategies from the Article:
importance of filed trips
agency- each child feels power in their self in the classroom
equity- each child's individual needs are being met
community- students are engaged with the places around them
How I would Adapt the Strategies in my Future Classes:
monthly field trips to the local library allow children to pick a reading book for free time to read what they want to read!!
make sure that all students individual needs are being met by following IEPs, granting extra time on assignments if needed, being available for extra help, ect.
assigning a poster project activity where the students can draw, take photos, write, ect. about their favorite local places to feel more connected/educated on their community
By, Johann Calhoun
“We feel passionately about reaching kids that are sort of turned off from the traditional classroom environment,” Faustman says. “We think a different, more culturally responsive approach would get them more involved and more invested in their learning,” (Calhoun)
Summary: The main argument discussed in the text is how students from urban school districts should still receive the chance to experience learning outside of the classroom. While the article also touches upon how "students of privilege" should not be the only ones to get this unique learning experience. The article begins by discussing Belmont Charter School in Philly, CEO, Jennifer Fuatsman, and her program she created to let city students expierence place- based education in their lifetime. Although her program is still "too new to judge" it has so far been successful! The article moves on to explain how suburban neighborhoods get so much more expose to place- based education which results in higher attendance, graduation rate, and "career standards", compared to urban school districts. The article then goes on to explain why Belmont created this plan and responded as, "They believe the concept can enhance the education of Philadelphia students from struggling neighborhoods — and get them involved in the sustainability of their community." (Calhoun). They entitled their plan for place-based learning STRIPES, which stands for STudying, Real, Issues, Places, and Expierences. The article goes on to discuss the future of STRIPES in attempt to get it implemented to all Philadelphia school districts.
Teaching Strategies from the Article:
implement place-based learning in urban areas, despite it being more difficult then suburban areas
make sure all studnets are getting an equal educational opportunity despite income/area
create something like STRIPES to ensure equity for students in all school disricts
How I would Adapt the Strategies in my Future Classes:
attempt something like STRIPES if there is an lack of placement-based education in my future school district
Make sure my studnets are receiving placement- based learning and if not, becoming an voice of advocacy for them
By, Amy Vinlove
"Given this approach to emphasizing transferable knowledge, what is it that new teachers need to know and be able to do to incorporate place-based strategies in their classrooms? What dispositions are necessary to create a place-based pedagogy that identifies and values local information and resources and demonstrates a commitment to connecting academic curriculum with the nested contexts of children’s lives?" (Vinlove)
Summary: The article begins with the author reflecting on her own school districts from Alaska, Denver, New York, and eventually University of Alaska Fairbanks. Vinlove opens the article with how she made changedsto the teaching program, in her own college to ensure future teachers were properly trained in place- based education. The article moves on to discuss the importance of Knowledge, as states, "An understanding of community context, however, should not stop at the level of human-based histories, challenges, resources, and spaces. These elements do not exist outside of the natural environment or place in which the community is located." (Vinlove). By educating students on the community around them allows them to be a more well rounded individual. The article then discusses the concept of Skills, and how teacher must be equipped with proper skills to take students on field trips, as they are meant to be educational. While it also touches upon Disposition and how to work respectfully with the community. While lastly, the article discusses the importance of Experience that teachers are exposed to to properly execute place- based education. The more teachers apply this style of teaching the more beneficial it will come to their students. Overall the articles main focuses is to articulate the importance of field trips being properly given by the teachers themselves, and to ensure they are trained adequately in place-based teaching.
Teaching Strategies from the Article:
make sure teacher's are well trained in the execution of field trips
proper education on place-based education is receive in teacher's teaching program
knowledge on the community in which a teacher is teaching in
How I would Adapt the Strategies in my Future Classes:
make sure I am well-educted on the topic of the field trip I may be given to my future students
choose field trips I will feel is most beneficial in my future students education
properly educate myself in the community in which I am teaching on
By, Amy Azano
"Given these unique complexities in rural communities, this study investigated whether place-based instruction can promote the relevance of an education while also affirming the value of the local community." (Azano)
Summary: The article opens up by addressing the important issue of rural school districts and their educational experiences compared to others. Explained in the article studnets of rural districts benefit from place-based education because, "Place-based advocates contend that rural students are deeply tied to locality by their “sense of place,” which Hutchinson (2004) describes as a constructed reality 'informed by the unique experiences, histories, motives, and goals that each of us brings to the spaces with which we identify' " (Azano) By having place- based education in learning environments allows studnets to better their sense of identity. The article mainly discusses an middle school English teacher Mr. Shaffer, who challenged the rural school district common way of teaching, and implemented place-based education in his cirriculum. He used Blue Valley the community in which the school is in, to relate to his lesson plan and took students to local places around the town and explained there relevance, to the story they were reading in class. The article explains, "The purpose of such inquiry would be to empower students with critical literacy skills for understanding the relationship between rural communities and larger issues that seem otherwise remote. In other words, place in the English curriculum could offer students not only the opportunity to construct their own understandings of place and its meaning in their lives but, if expanded, the conditions for cultivating an evaluative stance toward place and the world beyond it." (Azano). Based on Mr. Shaffer's ambitious change he was able to motivate students more, as he saw first hand their better understating and interest in which they were learning. Overall the article's goal is prove how rural school districts can truly benefit from place- based education.
Teaching Strategies from the Article:
rural school district TOO should allow studnets to experience place- based education
Field Trips are vital to a studnets overall educational experience
Connect lessons to the community in which the school is in
How I would Adapt the Strategies in my Future Classes:
As also being an future English teacher like Mr. Shaffer currently is, I would love to implement a field trip to local places in the community in which I will be teaching in , and connect the stories we are reading in class, to these places.