"Adding Up" the Social, Educational, and Racial Injustices to Obtain the "Sum" for Pedagogical Strategies in Mathematics Classrooms
"Adding Up" the Social, Educational, and Racial Injustices to Obtain the "Sum" for Pedagogical Strategies in Mathematics Classrooms
Hi everyone! My name is Gabriella Gigante. I am a Secondary Special Education- Mathematics major with a Deaf Studies minor here at The College of New Jersey. Mathematics has always been an interest of mine. Going into the education field, I feel that it is incredibly important to evaluate the social, educational, and racial injustices that come with mathematics education and how I as a future educator can have strategies to avoid these injustices.
How will social, educational, and racial injustice strategies be defined throughout this research?
When looking into pedagogical strategies for social justice, we will be looking into ways to rewrite mathematics problems to eliminate social injustices.
Looking into pedagogical strategies for educational justice, we will look into the realm of adjusting test and homework to accomodate for all students.
Diving into pedagogical strategies for racial justice, we will see ways that racial injustice can be eliminated within mathematics education.
"High School Mathematics Lessons to Explore, Understand, and Respond to Social Injustice" by Basil Manley Conway IV, Robert Q. Berry III, John W. Staley, Brian R. Lawler
Summary: As educators, we need to empower our students to be the change, as well as be the change FOR our students. All students have lived through so many experiences with their own social injustices. BUT when thinking about changing these injustices, mathematics is definitely not the first thing that comes to mind. In teaching mathematics through a social justice lens, mathematics teachers will be connecting the content that is being taught to the everyday lives of their students. In these problems, students can be exposed to different issues within the world that can prepare them to be leaders in their futures.
"The Power to Change the Equation" by Greg Benoit, Justin Reich, and the INSPIRE-Math team
Summary: Between the pandemic and the brutal killings of many, which proved that we are closer to the Jim Crow Era then we thought we were. Obviously, there were so many issues during these times, but mathematics teachers took it upon themselves to make crucial connections to what was going on around the world and in mathematics instruction. Social justice mathematics is just one of the ways that eliminating social injustice was presented. It is believed that social justice mathematics should not be done superficially. With this, educators should not just be adding more diverse names into their problems or solely concentrate on math content. One example of social justice mathematics would be doing a lesson to demonstrate disparities of the school to prison pipeline. Therefore, at the end of the lesson, students have the opportunity to ask questions to further their knowledge. Not all of these lessons have to be of high-importance events, but do need to be culturally responsive.
HOW WILL THESE SOCIAL INJUSTICES BE ELIMINATED WITHIN MY CLASSROOM?
In my classroom, I will be sure to incorporate these culturally relevant problems into my mathematics work. Before I began to research this topic deeper, I really did think that changing names would be a difference that would be considered social justice mathematics. I am glad to know that there is more that I can do than just change a name in a word problem to ensure that I am eliminating social injustice within mathematics.
"Measuring What Counts: Chapter 2: A Vision of Mathematics Assessment" by the Mathematical Sciences Education Board
Summary: Students are given assessments, which are used to prove what the students know and what they can do. Supposedly, it also tells educators what the students have learned- the concepts, the mathematical thinking and terms, and the problems that they can solve. It is important that assessment changes to support students in mathematics education. Textbook exams, as well as standardized exams have shown to have low level thinking skills. These assessments should not be easy to measure, but that should consist further in value, rather than for ways to prove that they "can solve a problem". The main principle of this: "assessment should reflect the mathematics that is most important for students to learn." These assessments should reflect real world applications in which are critical to future life and today's world. Assessment should be used to enhance learning and good instructional practice. In addition, these assessments should support each student and their way of learning mathematics.
"Rethinking Mathematics through Social Justice by the Numbers" by Eric Gutstein and Bob Peterson
Summary: It is not uncommon for a student to prefer almost anything else to a mathematics class. When bringing a social justice approach into a mathematics classroom, it is important that students will be able to understand the power in mathematics as a tool that can change the world through real-world connections. In addition, issues relating to racism, sexism, social class, and environmental class can be proposed within these assessments and homeworks to deepen students understandings on these issues. In the topic of examinations, students had the ability to create their own reviews and their own tests. There are so many students that learn in different ways, so having a variety of methods that allow students to be their strongest in an examination is so incredibly important. There are so many other ways besides one standardized exam to show off a students strengths.
HOW WILL THESE EDUCATIONAL INJUSTICES BE ELIMINATED WITHIN MY CLASSROOM?
Ever since starting as a Secondary Special Education- Mathematics major, the topic of assessment and homework has been one that has been in my head frequently. I was so stuck in between giving homework vs. not giving homework, giving tests, or not giving tests, etc. There are so many hard decisions that go with this. What if a student has a hard life at home and is unable to complete the homework or study for an exam? When reading through these articles, I realized that there are so many other ways to examine what the students have learned in my class. I think that it is important to allow students to succeed in the best way possible. If that means that they don't take a test that I give them, but show me their understanding in another way, such as a project or self- written problems, I feel that this is a way to show that students still understand without the stress of a formal examination.
"How does Race Affect a Student's Math Education?" by Melinda D. Anderson
Summary: This article discusses how "whiteness" reproduced racial disadvantages. Race in mathematics education has often centered around the underperformance of students are of different races- which include Black, Latino, and indigenous youth. Whiteness is impacting how and where mathematics ability is seen. There is a concept of racial hierarchy of mathematical ability which is completely unacceptable. School systems have to support math educators in ensuring that white frames are deconstructed.
"Twelve Ways to Make Math More Culturally Responsive" by Larry Ferlazzo
Summary: There are just so many ways that we as educators can be more culturally responsive, especially when it comes to mathematics education. First off, building real-world connections that relate to the students' language and culture is so important. Another way to improve is with student collaboration. Taking time to learn your students who are culturally and linguistically diverse is so important to increase responsiveness to culture within the classroom. In addition, embed the local community into the instruction. For example, using places around the community that the students know well. Not only will this increase culture responsiveness, but also increase the interest in student learning.
HOW WILL THESE RACIAL INJUSTICES BE ELIMINATED WITHIN MY CLASSROOM?
I will work hard to ensure that racial injustices are eliminated in my classroom. For starters, I will ensure that no student, especially based on their race, feels excluded from education. I will ensure that my lessons and the topics that I teach have relevance for all students who are in my classroom. I will make sure that no White or Asian student has an advantage over any other race, as stated in the above articles. In addition to this, I will ensure that my lessons are culturally relevant to the students that I am working with.
First-Year Teacher in an Elementary School Math Setting
Question: As a first year educator, what are strategies in mathematics education that you have used to eliminate social, educational, and racial injustices within your classroom?
Answer: Social justice is an important concept to be aware of and ensure that you appropriately address/respond/and integrate it into your classroom. A way I incorporate social Justice into math is by making sure my student's beautiful, and uniqueness is represented and reflected in the concept. First, I do this by getting to know my students not just as learners but as human beings. Doing this first, allows me to build a level of connection and trust between myself and my learners. Next, I ensure they are valued and represented in my classroom and within their learning environment. I do this by incorporating their personality and identities into the curriculum or activities. For example, I will use student's names, cultures, or personal identities (that they are comfortable expressing) in word problems or activities. This not only engages students because math problems are about “them” but it also allows them to feel like a vital part of their learning experience. Additionally, bringing their identities into math problems, lets them see that you care about them and want them to be their true selves. Essentially, it is key to show cultural responsiveness in all classroom settings
29-Year Teacher in a High School Setting
Question: As an educator for 29 years in the high school setting, what are strategies in mathematics education that you have used to eliminate social, educational, and racial injustices within your classroom especially since you have taught in New York City, Elmont, and Massapequa?
Answer: I try to maintain a safe and inclusive learning environment providing opportunities for student voice and choice. When possible, I try and differentiate student instruction and incorporate examples that relate to student cultures and experiences. With group and partner work/discussion, groups are diverse and change throughout the year. For struggling students, I try to find out where they would like to sit and if there is anyone in particular they would like to work with.
22 Year Mathematics Professor at The College of New Jersey
Question: As an educator in a university setting for 22 years, what are strategies in mathematics education that you have used to eliminate social, educational, and racial injustices within your classroom?
Answer: Whenever I had students missing study skills, content knowledge or cognitive skills, I offered to work with them individually. I built a personal relationship with them, and I worked on changing their mindset about learning math. I provided a lot of positive feedback and helped them build a growth mindset about math.
CHECK OUT THESE TED TALKS FOR MORE WAYS TO REFORM MATHEMATICS EDUCATION!!!