The video week #2. I learned further about video creation and editing with various tools, For video accessibility, the synchronized closed caption is becoming standard practice as listed in WCAG 2.1 and is also part of the ADA compliance in the U.S. As for the activity, after writing a script, I recorded a voice-over, produced an animation video with Creative Commons licenses, and recorded it by screencasting.
Learning goal: In module #3, learners will apply their mid-term goals in their career for the coming 3 years. By module #3 they identified their success and vision in module #1 and clarified their strengths and values in module #2.
Enabling objective: With this video and the following assignment, the learners will be able to validate their SMART goals.
Instructional model: Gagne's 9 events of instruction
The tool used: Audacity, Biteable, Screencastify, YouTube
Animation:
Give learners the ability to pause, stop, or hide any content that starts automatically and moves, scrolls, or blinks for longer than five seconds. WCAG 2.2.2 Pause, Stop, Hide - Level A
No page content flashes more than 3 times per second. Some people with seizure disorders can have a seizure triggered by flashing visual content. WCAG 2.3.1 Three Flashes or Below Threshold - Level A
Captions: A text version of the dialogue and non-dialogue audio information to understand the content, for people who are deaf, hard of hearing, and others. “Closed Captions (CC)” are hidden or activated by the viewer. "Open-Captions" are burned-in and always visible (3WC WAI, 2022). Generally, it's shown in one or two lines, and best to keep them under 32 characters per line (Mohaney, 2021). Similar, but the different term “subtitles” translates spoken dialogue.
Challenge #1: Ways to add captions
Editing captions on YouTube
It seems there are ways to add options. I initially edited the auto-synced captions on YouTube, but because of the number of errors from the automated captions, I found it easier to directly add them from the existing script. YouTube also auto-produces an SBV file that can contain a series of start and end timestamps paired with captions using the H:MM:SS.000 format (FileInfo.com, n.d.). Note that this SBV file doesn't meet accessibility requirements.
Formatting caption file
An alternative option is to format the basic script into captions before uploading the video to YouTube. Among many options, a plain text format (.sbv or .txt) and SRT format (.srt) are basic and I'm learning how to DIY this and upload it on YouTube/Google Drive to combine with the video mp4 file.
Challenge #2: Colors
Color Contrast: The colors of the characters of the Biteable template didn't go along with the brand colors. To prioritize passing the color contrast test at least WCAG2.1 A level, I chose to use most of the template colors that have high contrast.
Designing accessible e-learning resources:
I found a couple of additional resources to learn more about accessibility in the industry.
6 Best Practices for Designing Accessible E-learning from E-Learning Heros
Create accessible screencasts from Indiana University, IT Services
How to make your content accessible for all students from Screencast-O-Matic
☑️ WCAG A - Closed caption and basic transcript
WCAG AA - Integrated audio description of the visual information
☑️ WCAG AAA - Descriptive transcript
If the resource provides only visuals, how do the alternative aids help the learner understand?
WCAG A - Closed caption
WCAG AA - Audio description
WCAG AAA - Descriptive transcript
If the resource provides only audio, how do the alternative aids help the learner understand?
WCAG A Transcript or audio description
WCAG AA - Audio description
WCAG AAA - Descriptive Transcript
Determine which part of the course to develop into a video
Outline the concept or process
Write scripts (plan ahead to add descriptions of visual information)
Record voice-over
Edit the voice-over
Find an appropriate animation template
Draw a rough storyboard
Edit the template to fit scripts
Produce the animation video with the voice-over
Screencast the video
Edit the screencast video
Upload the video and edit captions on YouTube
Update the storyboard
The animation was created in Biteable, which allowed only a link to play within the site and required purchasing their Pro plan to download. The alternative solution was to take a screencast of the link.
I tried both Screencastify and Screencast-O-Matic to record the browser tab and the audio. It turned out Screencast-O-Matic requires purchasing their plan to add the voice-over, so the option was left with Screencastify. Because of this workaround, the animation is less crisp compared to the original. At the stage of course building, it's recommended to embed the video directly from the site link to obtain clearer lines.
Putting the voice-over, screencast video, and background music together in a video editor is worth trying. It's important to know the limitations of a free version of the tool and determine which tool is worth upgrading.
I updated the video and added an audio description. The video with 508 compliance has three main elements (Ditital.gov, n.d.).
Captions: The video has open or closed captions in which the video narration appears as text at the appropriate time and gives access to people regardless of abilities and conditions.
An audio description: A description of a video’s visual elements gives access to people who are blind or visually impaired.
A 508-compliant video player: Ensures a person who requires keyboard navigation or an assistive device can navigate the window where the video plays (that is, the video player).
☑️ WCAG A - Caption and basic transcript
☑️ WCAG AA - Audio description of the visual information
☑️ WCAG AAA - Descriptive transcript
The video has open captions in which the video narration appears as text at the appropriate time and gives access to people regardless of abilities and conditions.
The audio description (AD) follows the main narration to describe visual elements, providing access to people who are blind or visually impaired. In this video, I differentiated with a female voice as the main narrator and a male voice as the AD.
Sources & References
FileInfo.com. (n.d.). SBV File Extension—What is an .sbv file and how do I open it? https://fileinfo.com/extension/sbv
Mahoney, K. (2021, May 25). Your Complete Guide on How to Create an SRT File. 3Play Media. https://www.3playmedia.com/blog/create-srt-file/
W3C WAI. (2022, September 22). Video Captions. Web Accessibility Initiative (WAI). https://www.w3.org/WAI/perspective-videos/captions/
Digital.gov (2023, November 1). 508 Accessible Videos- why (and How) to make them. https://digital.gov/2014/06/30/508-accessible-videos-why-and-how-to-make-them/