A Massive Debt and a National Bank
A Massive Debt and a National Bank
Colonial America and the Rise of Banks
In colonial America, there were no banks. During the American Revolution, the Continental Congress printed a lot of paper money. This caused prices to rise quickly, leading to high inflation. By the end of the war, the paper money, known as Continentals, was almost worthless. However, after gaining independence, banks began to be established, and Alexander Hamilton suggested creating a National Bank.
Functions of a Modern Central Bank
A modern central bank does many important things. It issues a common currency, controls the amount of money in circulation, regulates banks, and can lend money to banks that need help during tough times. It can also act as a bank for the government.
Debate Over the National Bank
Alexander Hamilton, the first Secretary of the Treasury, and his supporters thought the new country needed a National Bank. However, not everyone agreed. Some people wanted a strong bank, believing it would help the country become a center of trade and business. Others, like Thomas Jefferson, who later became President, disagreed.
Hamilton's Reasons for Supporting a National Bank
Financial Stability
Hamilton believed that a National Bank would provide financial stability to the new nation. It would help manage the country’s debts and create a reliable system for handling finances.
Paying Revolutionary War Debts
One of Hamilton’s key goals was to help the federal government pay off its debts from the Revolutionary War. A National Bank would provide a means to finance these debts effectively.
Uniform Currency
Hamilton argued that the bank would create a uniform currency, making trade easier and helping to stabilize the economy. A common currency would reduce confusion and increase confidence in transactions.
Encouraging Economic Growth
Hamilton believed that a National Bank would promote economic growth by making credit available to businesses and individuals. This would encourage investment and development across the country.
Support for Federal Government
Hamilton thought that a strong National Bank would support the federal government’s ability to manage the economy. He believed it would help the government raise revenue and control the money supply, which was essential for a growing nation.
International Credibility
Establishing a National Bank would enhance the nation’s credibility with foreign investors and governments. Hamilton believed it would show that the U.S. was serious about managing its finances and debts.
Looser Interpretation of the Constitution
Hamilton had a more flexible view of the Constitution. He believed that the government could take actions not explicitly mentioned in the Constitution if they were necessary to achieve its goals, which included creating a National Bank.
Jefferson's Reasons Against the National Bank
Constitutionality
Jefferson argued that since the Constitution did not clearly allow Congress to create a National Bank, it would be unconstitutional. He believed that the federal government should only have the powers explicitly granted to it by the Constitution.
Fear of Centralized Power
Jefferson was concerned that a National Bank would give too much power to the federal government. He feared it could lead to a concentration of economic power that might overshadow the rights of individual states and citizens.
Support for Agrarian Interests
Jefferson believed that the United States should remain an agrarian society (focused on farming) rather than becoming too commercialized. He thought that a National Bank would favor merchants and industrialists over farmers, which he believed would be detrimental to the country's rural economy.
Potential for Corruption
Jefferson worried that a National Bank could lead to corruption and favoritism. He believed that wealthy individuals and businesses could manipulate the bank for their own gain, leading to inequality and unfair advantages.
State Sovereignty
Jefferson felt that allowing a National Bank would undermine the rights and powers of individual states. He believed that states should have the authority to manage their own finances without interference from a central banking system.
Ongoing Debates About the National Bank
Even after the first Bank of the United States had been in operation for 20 years, there were still arguments about whether a National Bank was necessary. Congress was divided on whether such a bank was needed and whether it was constitutional. In 1811, the bank's charter was not renewed, leading to the temporary end of the National Bank.
Image Citations
Page Header
Krimmel, John Lewis & Svinyin, Pavel. "Winter Scene in Philadelphia—The Bank of the United States in the Background." 1811–ca. 1813. Watercolor, black ink, and gum arabic on white wove paper. Metropolitan Museum of Art. Accession number: 42.95.14. Credit line: Rogers Fund, 1942. Retrieved from The Metropolitan Museum of Art Collection: https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/12759