Unknown artist. 1856. "Southern Chivalry – Argument versus Clubs." Lithograph depicting the caning of Charles Sumner by Preston Brooks. This image is based on a lithograph by John L. Magee. The scene shows Sumner as the victim and Brooks as the assailant. The medium is lithograph on wove paper. Part of the collection at the Boston Athenæum with the accession number C UMS Po.us.1856. It is a reproduction by an anonymous artist after Magee's original lithograph, with some minor stylistic differences. The image source is from an upload in December 2005 by Neutrality.