In this writing, I responded to three questions asked in my Theatre Appreciation Course in February 2025:
What was the world of the play? What was the world of the playwright? What is the world of the audience today?
Additionally, I shared my opinion on whether the play succeeded and whether it followed
Aristotle's Elements of Drama.
Three Worlds
The World of the Play
In the world of the play of Shakespeare’s Hamlet, it is unlikely that we mortals today will ever know the actual condition of the world and what it really meant to live there during the time that we may imagine Hamlet lived. It was perhaps the Renaissance period in the 14th or 15th century; however, some sources claim similar references that Shakespeare may have relied upon for his writing came from a medieval century, possibly the 12th, as described by Actors’ Shakespeare project, “Hamlet is based on a Norse legend composed by Saxo Grammaticus in Latin around 1200 AD. The sixteen books that comprise Saxo Grammaticus’ Gesta Danorum, or History of the Danes, tell of the rise and fall of the great rulers of Denmark, and the tale of Amleth, Saxo’s Hamlet, is recounted in books three and four.” Or even as early as the 9th century. “Scholars can trace a similar story to a 9th-century Scandinavian folktale of Amleth, a prince who feigned madness to exact revenge on his uncle for killing his father” (Weeks).
The world in those years was filled with wars and kings and queens conquering one country after another. Today, many imagine that in the world Shakespeare refers to as being Hamlet’s world, Denmark and Norway were bitter rivals, and Hamlet’s father, the king of Denmark, killed the king of Norway. Of course, this led to a blood feud with the king of Norway’s son, who was obliged to seek revenge for his father’s murder. We learn from Shakespeare’s writing about the life of luxury for royalty, but little about ordinary folk. Compared to castle life, we can be confident that life was not pleasant for most people living in rural areas or villages. Literacy was reserved primarily for nobles. Plays were standard entertainment.
We may never precisely know the source or sources that influenced Shakespeare to write his play about the tragedy of Hamlet. The only thing we can be sure of about the world at that time is the way Shakespeare describes it to us. He tells us little about the geopolitical nature of the world but rather about Hamlet’s inner world in Elsinore's castle, a world of family conflicts, mystery, intrigue, suspicions, spies, jealousy, revenge, love, incest, insanity, ghosts, and much more. I see a major cultural message: being royalty has its privileges, and it’s a club we are not invited to.
The World of the Playwright
We can know much more about the world that Shakespeare lived in during the time he wrote about the tragedy of Hamlet because there is much more history of the places and people from others who wrote about Shakespeare’s work. His play Hamlet was not only a single play about Hamlet but as many as four, and he wrote many more similar plays. Shakespeare was born around 1564 in England. He lived until 1616. Fifty-two years old was a long lifetime for people in those years when the average was forty years.
Life in Shakespeare’s world was a time of Protestant Christian and Puritan movements growing to displace the Catholic Church's control of society. With the coming of the Renaissance, more people were embracing humanism, and there was less reliance on religion. People, in general, were better educated in Shakespeare’s world than in previous centuries. There was a great deal of superstition and belief in ghosts, although not sanctioned by the Church or the Queen. Ordinary people were not wholly free to do or say as they pleased. The Queen was the dominant law of the land. Shakespeare’s father was a prosperous businessman, and Shakespeare was well-educated. He married young and had three children. He became a well-known actor and playwright, and he was actually a partner in a company called the Lord Chamberlain’s Men (renamed the King's Men in 1603) when he wrote Hamlet.
The World of the Audience
There is a universe of reasons why Shakespeare’s play, Hamlet, remains compelling to audiences from the time that it was written, throughout centuries, and up to today. Did Shakespeare imagine his work would remain vital so long after he wrote it? We cannot know the answer, yet we can reflect on many of the essential subjects he wrote about that remain part of human consciousness in our lifetime. Some of the enduring themes are murder, revenge, jealousy, love, family conflicts, insanity, anger, trust, loyalty, and many more intertwined throughout Shakespeare’s writing of Hamlet’s life and death at Elsinore Castle in Denmark, all those many years ago. These themes are very much in our lives today. Until recently, there was a queen in England whose son married a commoner and made her a princess. The prince had an affair, which led to his divorce from the princess, who later died in a car crash. The queen had another son accused of being involved with underage women and was disgraced from the royal family. These kinds of themes, like persons of royalty can be just as naughty or worse than regular folks, existed long before Shakespeare wrote about them and how we as individuals and as a society could learn from their ultimate disasters, yet we continue to involve ourselves in similar plots and twists and turns century after century.
Most of our soap operas on TV today, not only in the United States but also in many other countries, no matter what they are called, contain plots and themes similar to those brought up in Hamlet. Questions of life and death, morality, vengeance, and deceit are everywhere in TV, movies, and plays. We still strive to learn the lessons Shakespeare may have hoped we would have understood by now. Some people see a strong resemblance to biblical ideals referenced in Shakespeare’s writing. This could be because of the Church’s substantial control over what could be published in plays in Shakespeare’s time, which continue to resonate with audiences today, such as good versus evil, do unto others as you would have them do unto you, and who may pass to heaven or not. One of the most significant reasons for the lessons in Shakespeare’s Hamlet to endure for hundreds of years and countless performances in many languages around the world is the interpretation of the messages and the importance that each individual assigns to them.
Did Shakespeare succeed in what he attempted with Hamlet? Based on the play’s continued productions, I believe he did. Of course, I don’t know exactly what was on his mind. The fact that I and so many others are still reading his work says that it was well worth his effort to write it. Shakespeare’s Hamlet checks all the boxes of Aristotle’s Elements of Drama:
Plots are found in murder, revenge, secrecy, morality, love, and so much more that everyone can relate to in some part of the play. The tragedy of the highborn being brought down is presented.
Characters are vivid and authentic in their portrayals. There are family members, friends, guards, and even a ghost.
Thought is plentiful in Hamlet’s planning to avenge his father’s murder, and whether he will save his uncle’s soul by murdering him in revenge for his father, but condemn his own. Was Hamlet insane or only pretending? His feelings for his mother, for Ophelia, and much more.
Diction is shown in the language that Shakespeare used to write Hamlet, which is not only clearly poetic and metered, but he also incorporates words to elicit pictures and scenery in our minds, and makes us think about what we hear. Music is presented not only in the songs of Ophelia but also in the melody of the transitioning scenes.
Spectacle is brought out in the drama of suicides, murders, and deaths, as well as props like Yorick's skull, a ghost, and elaborate costumes.
Works Cited
Actors’ Shakespeare Project, www.actorsshakespeareproject.org/hamlets-origins/. Accessed 21 Feb. 2025.
Weeks, Emma. “A Brief History of Hamlet.” ArtsEmerson, 9 Feb. 2018, artsemerson.org/2018/02/09/a-brief-history-of hamlet/.
Jack Keefer, February 2025