This opinion post is from my Political Science course in 2019. The question asked was:
What are the merits and drawbacks of American federalism?
The good, the bad, and the uncertain.
For me, as a new college student, trying to write about the merits and drawbacks of federalism that we have been exposed to in this course so far would be like trying to write an entire lesson on this subject. I am learning so many new ideas. Maybe things that I once learned, but I have not thought of for many years. It is so easy to take everything our governments (Federal and State) do for us for granted. They’re our Rights! Right? Today, I feel quite happy no one asks me to talk about my government beyond complaining about it. These past weeks, we have read, watched, and listened to many great and perhaps not-so-great ideas, but certainly no easy solutions, about how our government came to be the way it is today. Although I cannot possibly convey all my ideas about the merits and drawbacks of federalism in this post, I will attempt to highlight some that are relevant to me.
I believe that one merit of federalism we can all agree on is the separation of powers of national (federal) and subnational (state) governments. From the beginning of the formation of our nation, it was decided that neither the states nor a central government should have too much power. Every partnership since the beginning of time has accepted a basic truth: 50/50 will not work. At some point, someone must have the final decision. A powerful merit of our federalist government system, largely due to cooperative federalism, is that the National Government must have complete control and responsibility over some areas. For example, the protection of our country and citizens from foreign or internal attack. Our early history proved that being united and under one military (although many forms of military exist today) was our greatest strength and protection.
A drawback was and is that the National Government could not and cannot be the police for every crime in every city of every state. States would not accept that kind of central police only. (I am reminded of George Orwell’s 1984 “Thought Police.”) Federalism grants States almost total control of policing, judging, punishing, and rewarding their citizens. States also have a military at their disposal that is not a part of the Federal Government’s military: their National Guard. We can see in crime shows daily on TV, and movies, how State and local police are normally very highly less than enthusiastic when Federal police of any kind enter their law enforcement territory.
Our federalism allows that only a centralized government be able to coin or print fiat currency, which has the exact same value in any state in the United States and any other country as well, relative to their currency exchange rates. I find no drawback for states not being able to print their own currency. I regret the loss of purchasing power our currency has suffered over the past 100-plus years, especially since it has had no backing from precious metals since 1964 and 1971. (Silver/Gold, respectively). However, the early colonies of the Confederation of States, having their own individual currencies, was not viable for our new united nation.
I find federalism provides merit and comfort that our roads, infrastructure, work safety standards, environmental protection, wages, education, health, and so much more have minimum National (federal) government standards. I appreciate the merit that each state may expand upon those mandates, and also that they find it difficult to limit them beyond the minimum. Imagine a federal minimum wage of $7.50 an hour, and one state only wants to pay $5.00 per hour. Not possible! A $15.00 per hour minimum wage is ok if the state wishes, but the Federal Government cannot force one state to pay more than another beyond the federal minimum. Merit or drawback, I guess it depends on the state you live in.
Higher wages plus a higher cost of living are better than lower wages and fewer state taxes? What benefit is there when a multinational company raises wages to $15.00 per hour for all employees, and in your state, that’s already the minimum wage?
Federalism allows many states to fight for what they feel is best for their populace, whether the Federal Government agrees or not. Currently, Immigration, Sanctuary cities, and Marijuana use, to name just a few, are rapidly dividing our nation. Many believe that these are largely State’s Rights granted by federalism. Merit or drawback?
I believe there is merit in the National government being able to collect taxes from citizens of all states to provide federal assistance to all states. A drawback is that not all states are equally funded for all their needs. Also, states are not always able to spend the money they receive from the Federal Government as they wish but must follow Federal Government guidelines. A merit and a drawback.
A merit of federalism for the states is that they are allowed to determine taxation in their individual states. Not all states have income tax. Some states tax income at a higher rate than others. States have different levels of sales taxes, property taxes, school taxes, and more, including additional city and county taxes in some states. This can be another merit or drawback, depending on where you live.
I believe, without going into great lists of merits and drawbacks, the federalist government system of the United States has proven to be the most responsible and protective form of government we could hope for. Perfect in every way? Of course not. Where in the world does such a government exist? We rely on the Federal law of our Constitution and Bill of Rights to protect every citizen of every state, no matter which state they were born in, currently reside in, or are passing through. We also have confidence in our individual State laws that they may protect us from overzealous federal law enforcement where we live and where we travel, everywhere in our great nation.
Don’t forget to be awesome!
Jack Keefer, 2019