Robots are more prevalent today than they were just a few years ago, tackling tasks that range in importance from cleaning floors to teaching students to diagnosing illnesses. With this progress comes the possibility of job loss for janitorial personnel, educators, doctors, and others. Discuss some areas where you find this technology helpful, as well as areas where you feel more confident in human decision-making. List some pros and cons of robotic technology and provide real-life examples. For instance, many people would relish the thought of owning a robotic sweeper but would cringe if their children were being taught by a robot sporting a face and using personalized conversation.
Robots for All
I can express without reservation that I do not appreciate the way that automation is displacing humans in the workforce. I do see the efficiency and cost control aspect from a managerial and corporate point of view. No workers taking extended bathroom breaks, no disability claims, no vacations to cover, no human production errors, no payroll. This list could go on and on.
In my current profession, I work as a truck driver. Although self-driving trucks may not fit the general conception of smart robots, they may eventually take away truck driver jobs. Can we then expect to see robots (automated forklifts) loading and unloading trucks?
I’ve only seen production robots on TV, in movies, and on YouTube videos. Some are highly admirable, even if they are, in my opinion, a foreshadowing of the demise of mankind. At this point, I am only aware of human controlled or preprogramed robots, those that are not mobile, but only complete repetitive tasks and those that are somewhat mobile following specific programmed routes for cleaning, or product delivery, or perhaps the small floor cleaners in homes that are to a degree self-learning but not allowed to leave the premises.
Other robots may be out in the yard, cutting the grass or doing other yard work, but they are not allowed to come inside. (Tracking dirt in from outside creates more work for the indoor robots. Indoor robots don’t like that.) I have seen examples of home butler/maid type mobile smart robots, but only on TV. Robots that can enter hostile areas and clear danger (human, animal, mechanical, or explosive), I am completely on board with, but again, those are generally remotely controlled. I am not comfortable with the idea of autonomous or semi-autonomous robots serving in that capacity. I am also not at all in favor of weaponized (drones, anyone?) autonomous smart robots.
I know that more human-like robots are being designed, tested, and working with continuously increasing artificial intelligence daily, for commercial, industrial, and military use, but I do not know of any yet for sale to the general public. I have seen that Amazon incorporates many robots in their newer distribution facilities and that they greatly improve speed and efficiency in delivering products to locations on predetermined routes around the work stations, but again, they are replacing a multitude of workers who used to have that work opportunity. How long before robots do the picking, packing, and shipping at places like Amazon, and they will need only a skeleton crew instead of the thousands employed today?
How about the mobile robots at some Walmart stores scanning products on the shelves and ordering products? It’s bad enough that so many cashiers are being replaced by Scan and bag your own stuff, so we can make greater profits from your free labor. Self-checkouts have been added for your convenience and are soon to replace most human interaction. Will we soon expect to see robots stocking the store shelves?
I think that robot-assisted surgeries may be more common in the future. I am comforted by the exact precision that a robot might perform on vital organs and sensitive areas of my body with minimal intrusion. I am not so sure I trust that more than the touch of a skilled and experienced human surgeon and nursing staff. What if I say ouch? Would a robot know? Or care?
I am quite sure that I do not want a robot babysitting my grandchildren, and I am not comfortable thinking that a robot may at some point be guiding any child’s education. I first picture this as some type of walking talking robot interacting with my grandchildren (the idea of which I do not like) and I must then think: how far is that away from children watching educational programs on a monitor at school or at home on a computer, or watching cartoons, movies, videos on TV, or on a variety of other devices. Plus, we should consider the video games, etc., that occupy children’s lives much more than most working parents can possibly find the time for.
I believe we are all aware of the amount of violence children are exposed to on a daily basis. Would it be better to have some kind of robot monitoring and preventing children from being exposed to violence? Maybe.
Would children find it difficult to accept learning from a robot talking head on a video monitor more than seeing a teacher’s head talking to them on a video monitor? (Anyone remember Max Headroom?) I think very young children would quickly adjust and accept those robotic teachers.
Imagine the talking head on the monitor praising and admonishing students via two-way audio and video. “Great answer, Ashley, gold star for you.” “Sarah, sit down and stop kicking Evan’s chair.”
Worse, I fear, is that in the not-so-far-away future it may be quite difficult for the children, or us, to tell what is real and what is animated on a monitor. Teachers, news announcers, and politicians? Here at EGCC, we adults are taking online classes with no physical teacher present.
We have not even a video of a warm-blooded professor guiding us, and we readily accept that we are being instructed, monitored, and graded by a human being. Hmmmm, [author pauses to reflect] works for me: I saw a picture of our teacher (Karen) when the class started. From a convenience standpoint, smart robots are adding value to many of our lives. At what future cost? As humans become less needed, how will we live our lives in relaxed, carefree, robots do everything for us comfort, when we have no jobs to give us money to pay for that lifestyle?
It’s not science fiction anymore.
Jack Keefer, 2018
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
“Resistance is futile. You will be assimilated!”
Sincerely yours,
The Borg
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
PS
I asked my new robot to type this post for me because I was worn out from trying to think what to write about. All errors in typing, spelling, punctuation, grammar, or others should be credited to it/him/her.
All compliments related to the brilliance and thoughtfulness found in this post should be addressed to the author.
Be seeing you,
Jack