This highly controversial subject was assigned for an argumentative essay in my English Composition course in October 2023. We were given five printed opinion essays to use as source material (Fensterman, Golden, Henden, Huttmann, and Siegel), and encouraged to seek other opinions as well. This essay does not convey my personal opinion, just the facts that were exposed in discovery. I hope you find this information interesting.
It’s My Party and I’ll Die If I Want To
In the great state of Texas and in lesser-known locations all around the globe, people continue to debate the merits of legal euthanasia, sometimes referred to as mercy killing. Assisted suicide is often spoken of as being the same as euthanasia; however, there are important legal differences. For euthanasia, a physician may administer a lethal dose of medicine. In contrast, for assisted suicide (physician-assisted suicide), a physician may provide a lethal dose of medicine for a patient to use but not personally administer it. Opponents of legalizing euthanasia would not likely quibble over the difference and condemn both equally. For that reason, this paper will use the two terms interchangeably. It is difficult for most to come to a clear, sensible, right or wrong, for or against position because there are so many variables to consider.
Is it morally correct or okay to voluntarily give up one’s life for any reason? Opponents of euthanasia will adamantly say that no one should ever forfeit the opportunity to remain on this planet until death occurs by any means (accident, illness, war, etc.) other than by choice. Most likely, opponents fighting passionately to ban the possibility of legal euthanasia, for individuals who have no wish to endure more, have not faced the conceivably agonizing existence of those who would choose their time to die. Opponents believe legalizing euthanasia in Texas could lead to unwarranted, premature end-of-life scenarios; on the other hand, the legalization of euthanasia can reduce suffering, end insurmountable healthcare expenses, and allow patients to make dignified decisions about their time and manner of dying.
Opponents of legalizing euthanasia argue that doing so may lead to increased premature end-of-life scenarios. Marilyn Golden conveys, “Again and again, health maintenance organizations (HMOs) and managed care bureaucracies have overruled physicians’ treatment decisions, sometimes hastening patients’ deaths” (9-11). Golden’s opinion of questionable bureaucratic behavior likely comes from personal observations. Golden shows her valid concern about other than natural deaths. In Texas, family members are sometimes not fully advised, or their concerns are overridden. David Zientek, in opposition to legalizing euthanasia, advises, “The Texas Advance Directives Act of 1999 is unique among the various statutes by providing a process wherein conflicts between a patient or surrogate decision-maker and the caregivers about the perceived futility of a particular therapeutic approach can be decided by an institutional committee. If, after following a defined protocol, the committee concurs with the caregivers that a particular level of care is “inappropriate,” they may override a patient’s or family’s wishes for continued aggressive therapy and withhold or withdraw potentially life-saving treatments with legal protection” (246). Zientek’s concerns about bureaucratic decision-making practices lend support to critics like Golden. Occasionally, a non-reversible decision is made without even having the patient's consent.
Herbert Hendin reports in opposition to euthanasia that he feels some doctors go too far without legal authority, saying, “Practicing assisted suicide and euthanasia appears to encourage physicians to think they know best who should live and who should die, an attitude that leads them to make decisions without consulting patients, a practice that has no legal sanction in the Netherlands or anywhere else” (12-13). Hendin could readily agree that anywhere else would certainly include Texas.
Proponents of euthanasia and assisted suicide do not dispute those opposition statements. They do not say that legalization will not lead to unwarranted, hastened deaths. In fact, they feel that those statements could indicate that instances of involuntary euthanasia may increase if legalized. However, proponents of legalizing euthanasia and assisted suicide argue that those options should be legal when they can be a blessing, which is the only remaining option to allow relief from long-term suffering. There are many kinds of suffering that human beings can be tortured with. The agony that comes with a chronic or terminal illness can drive an individual to wish to be released from living another single day. Some may have a higher tolerance than others, but everyone has a limit.
Sometimes there are no medicines strong enough to quiet the interminable torment without stopping life-giving body activities, such as breathing and keeping one’s heart beating.
Barbara Huttmann, a hospital nurse, relates the comments of a patient in long-term, extreme pain as he moaned, “’Pain… no more… Barbara… do something… God, let me go’” (qtd. in Huttmann). Mac asked for help because he had more excruciating pain than he could handle. Huttmann, in a moment of overwhelming compassion, let him have his release by not subjecting him to further resuscitations.
Herbert Hendin articulates his opposition to compassion as a reason to support legalizing euthanasia when he expresses, “Compassion for suffering and respect for patient autonomy serve as the basis for the strongest arguments in favor of legalizing physician-assisted suicide. Compassion, however, is no guarantee against doing harm” (12-13). Nevertheless, had legally assisted suicide or euthanasia been available for compassionate reasons, Mac’s suffering could have ended sooner, and Huttmann would not be at risk of being charged with murder. There are other types of suffering that may make a person wish not to live any longer; for example, being bedridden, unable to walk, or perhaps unable to breathe without mechanical assistance. One may no longer want to suffer the embarrassment of not being able to perform basic activities like eating or going to the bathroom without help. Perhaps a person was horribly disfigured or lost limbs in an accident and just doesn’t want to suffer what they consider a hopeless future living in that condition. Many people feel immensely guilty about the suffering brought to friends, family, and others who interact with them because those people suffer seeing the losses and the aching that the beleaguered one endures.
Opponents of euthanasia condemn people in those situations to struggle with little recourse every day of their lives. Doctors and other healthcare professionals should be allowed to counsel these patients and, if possible, their family members to see if an end-of-life plan is in the best interest of all involved with the suffering. Even though other emotional heartaches for the living who agreed to a dignified death decision may go on, euthanasia and assisted suicide should be allowed to ensure there will be no more distress or suffering for the directly afflicted.
Furthermore, medical expenditures can be a major deciding factor for someone contemplating assisted suicide. Patients may be under pressure from caretakers or property managers to consider ending their lives if they are unable to make payments for medicine, food, and housing, or they may be putting their families in an extreme financial crisis. An article in the American Journal of Epidemiology references suicide and the unavailability of money, stating, “Studies suggest that financial debt/crises …, unemployment …, homelessness …, and lower-income … elevate suicide risk” (Elbogen et al. 1266-1274). Elevated suicide risk may or may not lead to requests for physician-assisted dying; nevertheless, the option should be available.
Guidance from physicians or maybe even clergy could make euthanasia or assisted suicide appear even more compelling if patients are already facing insufferable, terminal illnesses or if they have developed a loss of interest in continuing life for other reasons and must keep on making substantial medically related payments. For many patients, occasions arise where medical expenses are insurmountable because their insurance coverage has been exhausted, and there is no government support available for them. Maybe their families have sacrificed all that they can, and the expenses keep climbing. In situations like those, if patients and caregivers agree that it is best to stop treatment, the option of euthanasia or assisted suicide should be available for them and their families to discuss. There may be cases where the family feels the time is best for a loved one to let go or to let a loved one go because the expense of prolonging a pain-ridden, less-than-full life is questioned.
Marilyn Goldman, in opposition to legalizing euthanasia, persists, “The cost of lethal medication generally used for assisted suicide is about $35 to $50, far cheaper than the cost of treatment for most long-term medical conditions. The incentive to save money by denying treatment already poses a significant danger” (9-11). Golden points out how the low cost of some medicine versus expensive care could possibly influence caregivers to encourage patients to accept otherwise undesired euthanasia; however, at the same time, low-cost euthanasia medicine could become a positive, beneficial, and influencing factor for some. If all are agreed, there should be a legal way to proceed with assisted suicide. The option of legal euthanasia should also be available for the family in cases where the patient is incapable of voicing an opinion.
Additionally, dying with dignity is a right that should be afforded to everyone who is in a position to make the decision to end their life under their agreed-upon conditions. Legal euthanasia or assisted suicide are ways that individuals can be sure that their time expires on their terms without fear of legal implications for anyone aiding them in the finality of their lives. Kaitlyn Smith pens in opposition to Texas law, “Texas has not left the question of physician-assisted suicide open—the Texas ADA explicitly forbids a physician from assisting an individual who wants to end their life. There is a clear contradiction in the treatment of dying patients in Texas that needs to be addressed. The best solution to the problem is for the legislature to amend the Texas ADA to include a provision that allows physicians to help terminally ill individuals end their lives on their own terms.” Smith feels that everyone should have the option of deciding when and how they desire to depart their human existence.
An individual with a terminal illness or in extreme misery should not be forced to endure that anguish when euthanasia or assisted suicide will allow him to make the decision to end that affliction. A person who is homeless, hopeless, and helpless, with no relief in sight and no desire to live with those conditions, should be allowed to make the decision to employ physician-assisted suicide or request a lethal injection similar to accepted practice in the Netherlands, where active euthanasia is legal. Any human being who has made peace with himself, his family, friends, acquaintances, and possibly his religion, and is prepared to end his life, should not be forced to use extreme or inhumane methods to ease his way when euthanasia and assisted suicide can be made legally available.
Jerry Fensterman, a young man being treated for terminal cancer, shares, “If you oppose physician-assisted suicide, first try to walk a mile in the shoes of those to whom you would deny this choice” (7-8). Fensterman may soon choose to decide his own fate. He has accepted that there is no cure for his cancer. Even though he has not yet opted for early release from life, he is aware of the pain and suffering his illness is bringing to his family and friends who continue to support him. He would like to believe a legal window for physician-assisted dying may be open for him in the future.
Opponents steadfastly claim that legalizing euthanasia could bring about unnecessary hastening of death instances; however, they do not address the basic right to die with dignity at a time decided by the individual. Also not represented are those enduring any number of insurmountable conflicts, from pain and suffering to financial insolvency to just being tired of living, destroying their quality of life. All deserve the privilege to decide how, where, and when, to the best of their abilities, they wish to die. Everyone should have the right to have legal assisted suicide.
Jack Keefer
5 October 2023
Works Cited
Elbogen, Eric B., Megan Lanier, Ann Elizabeth Montgomery, Susan Strickland, H Ryan Wagner, Jack Tsai, Financial Strain and Suicide Attempts in a Nationally Representative Sample of US Adults, American Journal of Epidemiology, Volume 189, Issue 11, November 2020, Pages 1266–1274, https://doi.org/10.1093/aje/kwaa146
Fensterman, Jerry. “I See Why Others Choose to Die.” Real Essays with Readings, edited by Susan Anker, St. Martin’s Press, 2012, pp. 7-8.
Golden, Marilyn. “Why Progressives Should Oppose the Legalization of Assisted Suicide.” Real Essays with Readings, edited by Susan Anker, St. Martin’s Press, 2012, pp. 9-11.
Hendin, Herbert. “The Case against Physician-Assisted Suicide.” Real Essays with Readings, edited by Susan Anker, St. Martin’s Press, 2012, pp. 12-13.
Huttmann, Barbara. “A Crime of Compassion.” Real Essays with Readings, edited by Susan Anker, St. Martin’s Press, 2012, pp.2-4.
Smith, Kaitlyn, The 10-Day Law and Physician-Assisted Suicide: The Need for More Consistency for End-of-Life Decisions in Texas (February 9, 2023). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4353009
Zientek, David M., “The Texas Advance Directives Act of 1999: An Exercise in Futility?” HEC Forum, vol. 17, no. 4, Dec. 2005, p. 245. EBSCOhost, https://doi.org/10.1007/s10730-005-5151-1