In my 2nd History course in 2024, for our Signature Assignment, we were tasked to read excerpts from Andrew Carnegie’s “Wealth” (1889) and “The Slow Progress of the Boy who Starts in a Breaker, And Ends, an Old Man in the Breaker—As Told by a man who was once a Miner” by Rev. John McDowell (1902). After reading, we were to respond to the following instructions and questions:
1. Compare and contrast Andrew Carnegie’s views about wealth and inequality with the life of the average coal miner.
2. What impact does Carnegie’s background have on his views, and how have his views influenced the United States in both the Gilded Age and the present? A. How did his background impact the USA during the Gilded Age? B. How does his background impact the USA today?
3. Based on your reading of the life of the average coal miner, are Carnegie’s views ethical? Why or why not?
4. Suppose you were a congressperson during this period in American history. Based on the two readings, would you have pushed for laws protecting coal miners? Why or why not?
Carnegie and the Gilded Age
Although Andrew Carnegie’s steel factories were heavily dependent on coal for fuel for their furnaces, his views about wealth and inequality did not, in all likelihood, even consider the lives of coal miners as a separate class of workers. From a 1902 story by Rev. John McDowel about the hard life of coal mine workers, we are advised, “During the last thirty years over 10,000 men and boys have been killed and 25,000 have been injured in this industry. Not many old men are found in the mines. The average age of those killed is 32.13” (McDowel). A boy as young as 12 may start working in a coal mine in an unpleasant but not too demanding job. As the years go by, he gains higher wages but advances to more and more body-and mind-devastating labor. He all too soon finds himself an old man, only able to work once again in less demanding work, perhaps until the end of his days. Laborers in Carnegie's steel factories did not enjoy the most pleasant environments at work or home either. His views toward workers espouse the idea that those with a combination of skills, ambition, and luck, as well as being in the right place at the right time to meet with the right people and with perhaps a certain laxity toward legalities, could reach unimaginable levels of wealth. Whereas some people, for example, the average coal miners, were, by and large, destined to remain in lower levels of income and societal position.
Andrew Carnegie was born in Scotland and came to America with his family in 1848. His parents were not rich, and the family quickly became a part of the struggling masses of immigrants. Carnegie’s hard work ethic started in his younger years as a bobbin boy at a Pittsburgh clothing manufacturer (Corbett). Andrew Carnegie was not the best moral compass of the Gilded Age. His knowledge, gained from operating telegraphs and a management position in a railroad company in his early adult years, gave him opportunities to make investments few others could have access to (Sandiford). His later leadership roles in steel factories and steel production led him, along with other inventors and investors of his time, to the idea of not only transforming the nation but also making huge personal profits. Carnegie and other tycoons of industry in the Gilded Age changed how businesses in the country operated. Building bigger, producing faster, using cheaper labor, and controlling the competition were the rules of the day. No need to be concerned about the health and welfare of the workers because there were thousands of unemployed waiting to replace them.
As a result of their efforts, the United States became a world leader in industry. Massive increases in steel production advanced westward migration. Populations expanded, and employment opportunities abounded. What were previously luxuries for the well-off became convenience items for the masses. Colossal riches were made from the less than highly moral treatment of workers for many during the Gilded Age, and the practice continues today. One difference between Carnegie’s wealth and inequality ethics and those of other leaders was that in the second half of his life, he felt strongly about sharing his financial windfalls with society in the form of hospitals, libraries, parks, schools, music centers, and more, but not so much for general charity. Regrettably, many workers in all types of industries didn’t live long enough to enjoy them. Carnegie's incorporation of the idea of social Darwinism into his work ethic resonated with many employers, especially the Mine and Factory owners, because it justified that they should become rich and the workers remain poor.
An average coal miner would probably not relate Andrew Carnegie to their lot in life. He was not the mine owner. However, if they knew of Carnegie’s views on wealth and inequality, they would be unlikely to think of them as being ethical, as they would be low on the receiving end. They would be highly unlikely to be able to partake in the generous social benefits Carnegie provided for those living in larger cities. Based on Carnegie's views on wealth and inequality in the later years of his life, it is safe to say that they were and are ethical, following the idea of social Darwinism. Laborers, no matter if they are coal miners, steel factory workers, or any other labor-based employment opportunist, are going to be at the lower end of income.
If I had been a congressman during the time of Carnegie’s rise to power, I would have done my best for my constituents to push for laws ensuring safe working conditions in the coal mines. Sadly, during the time of the great Gilded Age, when so many industries were booming, many lives were being lost because of unsafe practices at mines, mills, job sites, and factories, because business owners were surrendering to the power of the desire for ever more profit. Some employers, including Carnegie during much of his life, turned a blind eye and a deaf ear to the downtrodden. The government, in search of a position of global power and recognition and an interest in Manifest Destiny, held little sway over the industrialists.
Andrew Carnegie was not the best moral compass of the Gilded Age. He was a powerful influence on the growth and prosperity of the United States in the time of the Gilded Age after the Civil War and the early years of the twentieth century. What may not be well known is that not all of his wealth came by completely honest means (Sandiford). Perhaps he could have treated his employees to much better lifestyles than he demanded of their twelve-hour workdays seven days a week with little regard for their safety. Carnegie explains, “Under the law of competition, the employer of thousands is forced into the strictest economies, among which rates paid to labor figure prominently…” (Carnegie). In the Gilded Age, Carnegie was one of many tycoons and industrialists that were amassing their fortunes largely by paying their workers deplorable wages in what today would be intolerable working conditions.
In their defense, Carnegie blames competition and the need to restrict operating costs to the highest degree to ensure profits in astronomical measures. This practice is still largely a common denominator in businesses all over the world. We may imagine Carnegie’s employees having difficulty understanding his reasoning for their low wages as we wonder today about our wealthy employers (perhaps a store whose name sounds like “golf cart”?) moaning that labor costs are so high. However, Andrew Carnegie is regarded as one of the greatest industrialists our country has ever known. His altruistic contributions to this nation and the betterment of society during his lifetime and now are a testament to his great leadership, and his views on wealth and inequality will be studied throughout time.
Jack Keefer, February 2024
Works Cited
Carnegie, Andrew. “Wealth”. 1889
Corbett, P. Scott, et al. US History. OpenStax, 2014.
McDowell, Rev. John. “Life of a Coal Miner.” The World’s Work 4, 1902.
Standiford, Les. Meet you in Hell: Andrew Carnegei, Henry Clay Frick, and the Bitter Partnership That Transformed America. Crown Publishing Group, 2005.