This literary analysis essay is from my American Literature course in September 2024. The essay is based on Nathaniel Hawthorne's short story "The Birthmark," published in 1843.
This literary analysis essay is from my American Literature course in September 2024. The essay is based on Nathaniel Hawthorne's short story "The Birthmark," published in 1843.
Not all the harmful things men do are done with evil intent.
Obsession
The truth in the dark symbolism found in Nathaniel Hawthorne’s writings, such as an old man’s walking stick in “Young Goodman Brown” or a flowering bush in “Rappaccini’s Daughter,” forces us to examine what others may plainly see and what we possibly do not want to see in our lives. In his tale “The Birthmark,” Hawthorne shares how his main character's obsession and perfectionism, unlike passion or enthusiasm, are seldom desirable qualities. Scientists of alchemy and philosophy, like Aylmer, are often permitted a certain degree of eccentric or even obsessive behavior, along with failures being normal in their work, as long as their eventual successes benefit the world. When their less-than-positive traits carry over to experimenting on people, the detrimental results can be irreversible. If science and love become intertwined, obsession must be tempered. One must accept that endeavors to correct what many consider nature's perfection should not be attempted because there are no second chances. This essay shows that one man's desire to selfishly impose his obsessive ideas of perfection on others, although symbolically dark, does not make him evil because he thinks he can improve upon the beauty that nature has provided; his bride, a symbol of love and compliance, is not evil for being self-sacrificial in the name of love, and the man’s assistant, who displays no evil, symbolizes innocence and balance.
Nathaniel Hawthorne was born in 1804 in Salem, Massachusetts, a place rich in the history of strict religion, witchcraft, and tales of evil. In the early and mid-1800s, Hawthorne mainly wrote stories and novels with dark themes, secrets, and symbolism; many of his short stories were published in magazines of the time and continue to be analyzed today. Some classic Hawthorne stories are Young Goodman Brown, published in 1835; The Birthmark, in 1843; and Rappaccini’s Daughter, in 1844. (“Nathaniel Hawthorne”)
The primary character in Hawthorne’s “The Birthmark,” Aylmer, is typically cold, unemotional, and immersed in science, adhering to principles of obsessive perfectionism in his search for discoveries to bring him understanding, recognition, and spiritual reward. Although he wishes to find and experience love, and indeed finds and marries a beautiful woman, he cannot relinquish his desire for perfection in everything, including his wife. She is jealously considered attractive by most women and is desired by almost every man she encounters. However, there is an issue with her that Aylmer does not want to accept: his lovely wife has a tiny yet distinct birthmark on her cheek, a small red hand. In time, that minuscule mark begins to wear on Aylmer’s psyche, and he labors to find a way to convince his wife to part with it, assuring her that with his knowledge and expertise as a scientist, he can safely return her countenance to perfection as nature should have initially presented her. According to a report by Psychology Today staff, Aylmer likely suffered from a certain type of perfectionism: “Other-oriented perfectionism means imposing unrealistic standards of perfection on others” (Psychology). Aylmer wants to impose his unrealistic measure of beauty on his wife, letting her know in no uncertain terms how he feels about her particular facial feature that others feel is acceptable, and enhancing her natural beauty. To that end, he explains to her, “No, dearest Georgiana, you came so nearly perfect from the hand of nature that this slightest possible defect, which we hesitate whether to term a defect or a beauty, shocks me as being the visible mark of earthly imperfection” (Hawthorne). His degree of obsession for perfection in his bride over her almost imperceptible birthmark and its elimination blinds him from seeing that if this experiment fails, it cannot be repeated and will only bring him an eternity of sadness. Hawthorne shows that no matter how perfect they view themselves and their ideals, men cannot always correct what nature presents as complete.
Early in the story, Hawthorne directs our attention to Aylmer's wife, Georgiana, a woman beautiful not only in her countenance but also in her spirit, as love emits from her as gently as a soft summer morning breeze flowing over a field of fragrant flowers. She marries Aylmer unconditionally, and as much as she admires him and his work as a scientist, she is aware that he is not perfect in all his endeavors. Reading some books in his library to pass the time, she finds, in one, a great surprise: “Much as he had accomplished, she could not but observe that his most splendid successes were almost invariably failures if compared with the ideal at which he aimed” (Hawthorne). This discovery does not dissuade her love for him. Georgiana gushes to Aylmer,
“It has made me worship you more than ever” (Hawthorne). She admires him even more because she understands it is a trait of perfectionists to rarely achieve the level of faultlessness they desire, so they resolve to try and try again. Georgiana appreciates that Aylmer is working tirelessly to find an answer to the dispute his perfectionism is presenting to them both; still, she begins to feel insecure about her appearance after continual unappreciative comments and demeanor from Aylmer; she feels it best to have him remove what he considers a defect on her face. At a certain point, she cries out to him, “Remove it, remove it, whatever the cost, or we shall both go mad!” (Hawthorne). Her love for her husband is so profound that she is willing to risk her beauty for his happiness. Eugenia Mandel writes about women making relationship sacrifices, “Women named the motive of love more frequently, while men tended to point to the willingness to improve on the quality of the relationship, their personal benefits and sense of obligation” (Mandel 318). Georgiana is willing to jeopardize her bewitching visage in the name of the love her character represents. She remains a symbol of amity and admiration throughout the story.
At length, Hawthorne adds balance, simplicity, and innocence to this story with Aylmer’s assistant, Aminadab. Aylmer sometimes commands his quiet assistant as a slave and treats him rudely and coldly, which seems to be his way with all in his domain. Aminadab dutifully complies with his master's wishes, oblivious to the maltreatment, perhaps after years of servitude. He is not, however, some blundering clod as he assists in Aylmer’s experiments, maintains the cleanliness and order of the laboratory and living areas, and shows a keen sense of what is going on around him. He does not agree with the steps Aylmer is taking to make changes to his wife’s visage. To himself, he mutters, “If she were my wife, I’d never part with that birthmark” (Hawthorne). Aminadab agrees with most men (who have seen Georgiana) that any mark on her body perceived by others as a defect is an enhancement. Aminadab, in Hawthorne’s story, is far from any vision of perfection as he is described by Aylmer, yet there is no desire in Aylmer to change him. Perhaps a reason for this is that Hawthorne’s inclusion of Aminadab in this story may have biblical ties. W.R. Thompson elaborates in Modern Language Notes,
The tension underlying the external relations of Aylmer and Aminadab remains for the most part hidden. Aylmer is perhaps too serenely confident of himself and scornful of his servant to be aware of it, and Aminadab is in no position to assault the bastion of science which Aylmer represents. And this from the standpoint of sheer artistry, is as it should be; the conflict between science and authoritarian religion is not the motif of the tale even though it does reflect what we know to have been Hawthorne's apprehensions concerning the budding brave new world of the nineteenth century. (Thompson)
Thompson shows balance in Aminadab’s denial to engage Aylmer and keep calm between them. Hawthorne depicts in Aminadab’s stoic behavior and his patient acceptance of Aylmer's abusive treatment of him that he is also a kind of steadying dynamic between the cold and calculating scientist Aylmer and the easy-loving and accepting Georgiana, willing to sacrifice for love. Aminadab’s simple nature reinforces the idea that Aylmer’s needs and deeds are not evil; they are egotistical and obsessive.
In the final analysis, we find that obsession, perfection, beauty, love, innocence, and balance are found throughout Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “The Birthmark.” There is no indication of evil intent from any of the characters. Aylmer is not evil but is blinded to love by his obsession with perfection. Selfish personal satisfaction with an idea of absolute beauty from Aylmer being unjustly imposed on Georgiana until she feels she must agree because of her love for him, and to safeguard their relationship, does not make her evil for wishing to comply. The servant/assistant Aminadab is not immoral for failing to intrude into the lives of his employer and wife. As much as he disagrees with the manipulations he witnesses being imposed on her and watching her submit, he is not evil; he is obedient. Hawthorne shows that men of science, with all the knowledge they may accumulate, are not meant to toy with God’s creations, or they will suffer eternal loss.
Jack Keefer, September 2024
Works Cited
Hawthorne, Nathaniel. “The Birthmark” (various sources)
Mandal, Eugenia. "Sacrifices of Women and Men in Close Relationships: The Types and Structure of Sacrifices. The Approach and Avoidance Motives for Making Sacrifices." Current Issues in Personality Psychology, vol. 8, no. 4, 2020, pp. 317-328. doi:10.5114/cipp.2020.101952.
"Nathaniel Hawthorne." Encyclopedia Britannica, 16 Aug. 2024, https://www.britannica.com/biography/Nathaniel-Hawthorne.
Psychology Today. “Perfectionism | Psychology Today.” Psychology Today, 2019, www.psychologytoday.com/us/basics/perfectionism.
Thompson, W. R. “Aminadab in Hawthorne’s ‘The Birthmark.’” Modern Language Notes, vol. 70, no. 6, 1955, pp. 413–15. JSTOR, https://doi.org/10.2307/3039585
The full short story PDF of “The Birthmark” by Nathaniel Hawthorne, 1843, may be found at:
https://www.online-literature.com/hawthorne/125/