This opinion post is from my Intro to Business course in 2020. The question for discussion was:
Based on the readings, do you think minimum wage laws affect overall poverty?
This opinion post is from my Intro to Business course in 2020. The question for discussion was:
Based on the readings, do you think minimum wage laws affect overall poverty?
Fight for $15
Hmmm, what am I to interpret by “affect” and “overall”? Affect poverty, of course, more money usually equals less poverty. It is possible that a higher wage could raise someone financially above what the government classifies as the poverty level, but probably not by much and not for long. Could raising the minimum wage reduce someone to real-life poverty by placing them into an income bracket that disallows them to receive government benefits, thereby diminishing their standard of living? I believe that could happen quite readily. Affect overall poverty? I have to think about that question. My initial answer is yes. A positive or negative overall affect demands further consideration. Nationwide poverty, statewide poverty, localized poverty?
I don’t believe a higher government-mandated minimum wage (“Fight for Fifteen”) is likely to dramatically impact the reduction of nationwide poverty.
When I think about who is most affected by minimum wage, I tend to think of young people just starting to work, most of whom still live at home with minimal expenses. (Not all of course) Others may be entering or reentering the workforce later in life for various reasons, essentially starting anew with well-established expenses. Still more may desire or be required to work and earn a certain amount to qualify for government benefits. A much higher minimum wage may seem like a great bonus income for those who don’t have to cover their minimum costs of living, an absolute minimum increase in entitlement for others, and perhaps a penalty for some. At any income level, a salary increase is generally welcome. However, at many State and Local levels, there is a greater risk that having a higher minimum wage, while statistically showing reduced levels of families or individuals below the poverty line, realistically being just above the poverty line has very little impact on quality of life versus being just below the poverty line. In many cases, being just above the poverty limit may be substantially worse because entire families can be cut off from previously available government subsidies and healthcare.
There are many small business employers who may be driven out of the market if forced to pay employees a higher minimum wage than the sales of their products and overhead allow. Walmart-type stores would not be the ones driving those businesses out of the market; the government would be responsible. More employees out of work or working fewer hours, and businesses passing the higher minimum wage costs on to consumers by raising prices, would contribute to an overall increase in poverty for those already suffering from the high cost of living. States and cities that increase their minimum wage rates generally see substantial cost-of-living increases before, during, and after minimum wage increases. Poverty doesn’t really change for the impoverished.
I don’t believe my wages have kept up with rising costs for many years. Another downside may be that, for example, after working at my job for the past 15 years, increasing my knowledge and skill level, and demonstrating company loyalty, I have earned the right to be paid $15.00 per hour. If my company is forced to pay each new, inexperienced employee $15.00 as a minimum wage starting salary, then I feel that I deserve to make at least $25.00 per hour. How fair is that to me or to the company that can only afford to pay a maximum $15.00 per hour salary?
How does the increase in minimum wages affect the unemployed? I believe, at best, it makes finding jobs even more difficult. Few employers want to increase their workforce at higher wages unless they can hire contract labor workers who are responsible for all their own taxes, insurance, and other expenses.
This question for discussion (thankfully) did not ask me to elaborate on all the reasons I may feel that a $15.00 per hour minimum wage is a good or bad idea. Sticking to the reading as my guide, I would say a higher minimum wage does affect overall poverty in a generally less than positive way.
Considering the concept of minimum wage vs a living wage, although we were not asked to do that, I don’t feel that any minimum wage is going to eliminate poverty. Some will benefit in the short term until higher prices eat away at the illusion of increased wealth. $15.00 per hour? Why not $20.00 or $25.00, and along with that, $18.00 hamburgers. “Would you like $10.00 fries with that?”
Find the Truth. Be the Change!
Jack Keefer, 2020