Picture Pending
Too Hot, Too Cold
In Texas, extreme heat and freezing cold temperatures kill not only plants and trees but people, too. Although freezing winter temperatures are not the norm for most Texas counties, they can extend all the way to Laredo at the Texas-Mexico border. Excessive heat permeates the majority of the state in the summer months. In Texas state prisons, unbearable conditions in the summer heat and winter cold are too often common. Incarcerated persons, as well as the corrections officers and other people who work in prisons, are suffering more than they need to, and relief is possible if legislators decide that spending money to improve prison conditions is ultimately better than spending money to fight against improvements. I believe that Texas must invest funds to improve climate control in prisons because not only prisoners but also prison guards and staff are suffering from excessively hot or cold temperature environments up to the point of death, taxpayers bear the cost of increased medical treatments and often wrongful death lawsuits, and prisoners have constitutional rights that protect against cruel and unusual punishment and inhuman treatment.
A lack of centralized universal air conditioning in prisons is harmful to more than the prisoners. One study by a group of authors reports:
13% of mortality (or 271 deaths) may be attributed to extreme heat during warm months in Texas prisons without universal air conditioning between 2001 and 2019. Our findings have important health implications for the approximately 160,000 individuals held in Texas prison facilities annually, as well as the thousands of correction officers, nurses, and other staff that work in these settings. (Skarha 2022)
Simply saying important health implications does little to disguise the deplorable climate inmates survive under in some Texas prisons, nor does it define the severity of conditions leading to, in too many cases, death. It is important to remember that not only inmates suffer in these extreme weather conditions. There are prison guards, medical personnel, and administrative workers who most likely work in better conditions than the inmates they protect; nevertheless, some suffer in extreme weather conditions more than they should.
When there is a death in a prison that may be attributed to uncontrolled, excessive heat-related conditions in the prison, many people forget or are unaware of where the money comes from to pay the legal expenses when lawsuits are fought and eventually settled. Taxpayers are the ones who, in the end, foot the bill for the costs the state pays for wrongful death lawsuits. One writer reports, “While many Texas taxpayers may choose to look the other way or hold the opinion that ‘you do the crime, you do the time,’ advocates argue that the amount of money the state will ultimately spend on wrongful death lawsuits outweighs the cost of providing air conditioning in prisons for inmates, staff, and guards” (Bradshaw 2024). The idea that funding better climate control in Texas prisons could save lives, improve health, and relieve the financial burden on Texas citizens who pay for the care of inmates and staff alike is something many are simply not aware of. Too many people close their eyes and want to forget about someone once they have been found guilty and sentenced to prison.
Texas legislators spend millions of dollars on legal fees to fight against paying for excessive heat relief in prisons. That same money could be spent on improving conditions in prisons so there is less extreme heat-related or freezing cold suffering. Failing to provide better climate control in Texas prisons will lead to more protests of violations of human rights and constitutional protections against cruel and unusual punishments. A reporter with The Texas Tribune informs, “With another sweltering summer likely ahead, prison rights advocates on Monday filed a complaint against Texas Department of Criminal Justice executive director Bryan Collier, arguing that the lack of air conditioning in the majority of Texas prisons amounts to cruel and unusual punishment” (Salhotra 2022). Texas cannot control its extreme weather conditions any more than other states with similar weather conditions can. We can better control indoor climates to at least bearable, non-life-threatening levels. If we do not, people will bring lawsuits, and the taxpayers will be responsible for the legal expenses.
Ultimately, we must accept that even though Texas prisons could and should maintain temperatures at not less than 65 degrees and not more than 85 degrees, according to House Bill 1708, the Texas Department of Criminal Justice was not required to comply before September 1, 2024 (88(R) HB 1708 - introduced version - bill text). Texas can and needs to fund improved climate control systems in its prisons. All citizens should be informed of intolerable conditions at many incarceration facilities, and keep in mind that curtailing illness and dying due to extreme temperatures is taking less tax dollars from them. They must also remember that not only prisoners suffer from uncontrolled extreme weather conditions that could be mitigated. Medical expenses and wrongful death lawsuits can be and must be reduced and eliminated. Texans must stop thinking that violating human rights and inflicting cruel and unusual punishment is justified just because people incarcerated in prisons are there because they committed crimes against society. People in Texas prisons are not the only ones suffering.
Jack Keefer, October 2024
References
Bradshaw, Robin. 2024. “Texas prisons face deadly heat as lawmakers continue to stall.” Beaumont Enterprise, June 26. https://www.beaumontenterprise.com/news/article/texas-prisons-heat-19507494.php
88(R) HB 1708 - introduced version - bill text. https://capitol.texas.gov/tlodocs/88R/billtext/html/HB01708I.htm.
Salhotra, Pooja and William Melhado. 2022. “Texas inmates are being ‘cooked to death’ in extreme heat, complaint alleges.” The Texas Tribune, April 22. https://www.texastribune.org/2024/04/22/texas-prisons-heat-deaths/
Skarha, Julieanne, Dominick, Amite, Keith, Spangler, et al. “Provision of Air Conditioning and Heat-Related Mortality in Texas Prisons.” JAMA Netw Open. 2022;5(11):e2239849. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2022.39849