This opinion essay is from my Texas Government course in November 2024. The question to answer was is the Death Penalty an effective deterrent to violent crime?
The Death Penalty as a Deterrent to Violent Crime
Abolishing the death penalty in the United States will save prisoners from what many call cruel and unusual punishment. It is one thing to be imprisoned for life without the possibility of parole; many would say that is an evil punishment already. Keeping someone in solitary confinement day after day and year after year of their lives, knowing that their only chance of leaving prison is on the day they are put to death, could be thought of as a barbaric punishment. Consider inmate Arturo Aranda. He is known as a Habitual Criminal with many arrests and prior prison terms. He has been on death row (solitary confinement) since being sentenced to death in 1979. According to his arrest report, he “Shot to death a Law Officer during a drug bust in Laredo, TX. Aranda and his brother were driving a station wagon containing 500 pounds of marijuana. When they were stopped by undercover agents” (Blanco, 2024). There was little possibility of any conviction other than execution in a Texas state penitentiary for Arturo, yet he remains on death row. His high cost of death row confinement is not the only cost to taxpayers.
The high cost of death penalty trials is yet another cost that taxpayers bear, even before the cost of sometimes decades-long periods of imprisonment after sentencing. According to Alexander Lundberg, in a story edited by Jeffrey Miron in the Cato Institute’s Research Briefs in Economic Policy, October 11, 2023:
Past research suggests that counties meet the cost of trials with higher taxes and lower police expenditure (and perhaps lower capital expenditure). Jasper County, Texas, for example, raised property taxes by 8 percent to fund a joint trial for suspects in the 1998 murder of James Byrd. Another Texas county reduced public safety expenditure after voters rejected a property tax increase (Lundberg, 2023).
The same story tells us, “In 1992, capital trials in Texas cost an average of $2.3 million, and trial costs have risen steadily over time” (Lundberg, 2023). If the federal or state government pays for the prison housing and care for the convicted felon, the money eventually comes from the taxpayers. If private investors or corporations pay for the prison and all expenses incurred, the money to pay them ultimately comes from the state or federal governments, which, once again, eventually comes from the citizens paying taxes.
From the time of the Code of Hammurabi and before, there has been an accepted practice that taking a life means sacrificing your life. People in the past could be sentenced to death for even less severe offenses, such as robbery. I do not have an answer better than prison for how to stop violent crimes and murder in particular. It seems that paying for a life with a life is not a powerful deterrent. According to Scientific American magazine in April 2024, “Using rigorous statistical and experimental control methods, both economics and criminal justice studies have consistently found in states that allow capital punishment, that violent crime is not diminished” (The Editors, 2024). I feel that keeping a person who took a life in solitary confinement for decades versus keeping him in the general prison population is cruel. The Death Penalty Information Center shares, “While on death row, those serving capital sentences are generally isolated from other prisoners, excluded from prison educational and employment programs, and sharply restricted in terms of visitation and exercise, spending as many as 23 hours a day alone in their cells” (Death Penalty Information Center, 2023). Imagine inmate Arturo Aranda, mentioned earlier, on death row in solitary confinement for 45 years so far.
Not only is the cruel isolation for death row prisoners alarming, but the expense to taxpayers is also alarming. A story from the Cato Institute reports, “One argument for the death penalty is that the usual alternative—life in prison without possibility of parole—imposes a financial burden on taxpayers (about $60,000-$70,000 per death row inmate per year, according to a recent study…” (Miron, 2023). The story further reports the expense of keeping a prisoner on death row: “Each death penalty inmate costs approximately $1.12 million (2015 USD) more than a general population inmate” (Miron, 2023). That money comes from taxes. In Texas, the county that sends the convict to prison pays the costs of the trial and imprisonment. Prisoners on death row took away someone’s life. A debt must be paid, but how can anyone repay a life taken?
References
Blanco, J. I. (2024). Arturo Daniel Aranda | Murderpedia, the encyclopedia of murderers. Murderpedia.org. https://murderpedia.org/male.A/a/aranda-arturo-daniel.htm
Death Penalty Information Center. (2023). Time on Death Row. Death Penalty Information Center. https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/death-row/death-row-time-on-death-row
Lundberg, A. (2023). On the Public Finance of Capital Punishment (J. MIRON, Ed.). Cato Institute. http://www.jstor.org/stable/resrep53441
Miron, J. (2023, July 20). The Financial Implications of the Death Penalty. Cato.org; Cato Institute. https://www.cato.org/blog/financial-implications-death-penalty
The Editors. (2024, April 1). Evidence Does Not Support the Use of the Death Penalty. Scientific American. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/evidence-does-not-support-the-use-of-the-death-penalty/
Jack Keefer
2 December 2024