Life in Massachusetts in the late 1600s was arduous, perhaps much more challenging if you lived in Salem Village and belonged to a strictly religious Puritan community where transgressions of biblical law could result in harsh punishment or even death. Suspicions and accusations of witchcraft and all manner of consorting with the Devil were ever present, as were the watchful eyes of church leaders and judges eager to root out evil in any form they perceived. Even facing that scrutiny and risk, some residents were curious, or perhaps tempted by Satan, to explore the unknown. One individual who could perhaps reliably comment on the goings-on in that dark historical time is Nathaniel Hawthorne. He was born in Salem, Massachusetts, in 1804, and he had the unique advantage of claiming direct ancestral lineage to a Salem witchcraft trial judge. In a short story Hawthorne wrote and published in 1835 titled “Young Goodman Brown,” Hawthorne invites us to share the conflicts the main character endures when exposed to a possible reality of evil in people in his world, and fighting to not lose faith in his religion.
Young Goodman Brown, the son and grandson of prior Goodman Browns, grew up in Salem, Massachusetts, following his family tradition to become a devoutly religious young man. He is recently married to a young, Puritan woman named Faith, someone he believes to be as pious as himself. Brown, like most young men and women at certain points in their lives, questions authority around him and begins to wonder what may be so bad about things only mentioned in whispers—things that go on in the dark forest where only the very brave, or perhaps the wicked, venture after the light of day has gone. The characters in Hawthorne’s “Young Goodman Brown,” who entertain a walk with the Devil, remain tainted for life. For some, like Goodman Brown, with minor transgressions, a small stain of evil could be diminished by prayer and a return to faith. Others, more severely Satan-influenced, like Goody Cloyse, become witches, warlocks, or other devil’s pawns, hiding in plain sight, walking among us, pretending to be pious residents and respected society leaders for the Devil to use as he wishes. Those most adulterated become part of a veritable army totally committed to Satan's unholy community and vigilantly working to add more souls to their world.
Dusk, the witching hour, approaches. Faith does not want her husband to leave her. She beseeches him to not go, whispering to him, “Dearest heart, pr’y thee put off your journey until sunrise and sleep in your own bed tonight” (Hawthorne 1). Dreams give Faith reason to believe that her husband is going to do something he will regret. Brown performs what may be his first small, deceitful step toward evil. He won’t tell her what he is doing, who he is meeting, or where he plans to go. He leaves his worried wife behind with her prayers and the assurance that he will return the following morning, and he enters the forest. A fellow he sees there shows indications that he is the Devil; he cunningly looks like Brown’s own father, and he possesses a wickedly evil-looking walking stick.
Brown quickly regrets his decision to meet with this man and wants to return home. He tells the stranger, “Having kept covenant by meeting thee here, it is my purpose now to return whence I came” (Hawthorne 2). Brown is already having doubts about his decision to perhaps learn what the elders whisper about. Even though he wishes to return to Faith, the man persuades him to go a little farther into the forest, discussing his decision to turn back as they go. Brown explains that he really doesn’t want to go any further because he doesn’t want to betray the good name of his father and grandfather by taking a walk that they would never do.
As they walk, Brown is horrified to learn that past family members had been the Devil’s pawns. The stranger, with his special walking stick carved in the shape of a snake, explains that in fact Brown’s father and grandfather were much more than simply devil’s assistants, saying, “They were my good friends, both; and many a pleasant walk have we had along this path and returned merrily after midnight” (Hawthorne 2). Here is Hawthorne's first instance of the Devil possibly, indirectly, admitting who he is; he brags about his relationship with the Browns and that he has many friends in high church and government positions. He invites Brown to be his friend as well. Brown is dismayed to be informed of the possible extent of people participating in the evil that he could never have anticipated, and again wishes he could go back to the safety of his faith.
They continue to travel and talk, and Brown encounters more unfathomable situations; his good and pious catechism teacher is in the dark forest, walking because she lost her witch’s broomstick. When she sees the Devil, she cries out, “The Devil!” (Hawthorne 4). Goody says this because she recognizes someone she has had many dealings with. The Devil responds by saying, “Then Goody Cloyse knows her old friend?” (Hawthorne 4). Hawthorne does not so easily confirm our suspicions that the strange traveler is indeed the Devil, as he answers craftily, using plausible deniability, by not directly admitting that he is the Devil but only asking if he is recognized. Soon after, Brown hears the voices of the village minister and deacon talking as they travel on horseback, hurrying toward the same destination he himself is being drawn to.
This reality that respected, high-ranking clergymen are in league with evil is almost more than Brown can handle, and he wrathfully declares, “With Heaven above, and Faith below, I will yet stand firm against the devil” (Hawthorne 6). Even though Brown cannot deny what he has seen and heard, he still claims his right to reject evil and adhere to his faith.
A short time later, Brown hears the sound of a multitude of mingled voices in the wind; he believes he hears his sweet, young, pious wife’s voice in the forest. With doubt in his heart, he continues down the dark forest path, drawn to a destination he fears is evil that he clearly wants no more to be a part of. Suddenly, he is stunned to see a pink ribbon floating in the air, a ribbon like the one that was in his wife’s hat when he left her in the village. Brown believes the ribbon can only mean that Faith is in the forest. Not knowing if she was there by force or by choice, Brown fears the worst for her and wails, “My Faith is gone!” “There is no good on earth, and sin is but a name” (Hawthorne 6). He agonizes that she may be there voluntarily, and as hard as that is to believe, it is almost reason for him to give in to Satan’s temptation as well because of his love for her.
He goes mad with despair and races to reach her. The evil he encounters at his destination would surely drive most men mad. Brown finds himself facing a huge group of Devil worshipers, from all walks of life, gathered in honor of him and Faith to welcome them and to baptize them into their unholy community. In the mass of bodies, unless his eyes deceive him further, are his deceased father and his mother. The narrator conveys, “He could have well-nigh sworn, that the shape of his own dead father beckoned him to advance, looking downward from a smoke wreath while a woman, with dim features of despair, threw out her hand to warn him back. Was it his mother?” (Hawthorne 8). The author again employs toying with our imaginations, not directly stating that Brown saw his parents but enticing us to think that he did.
Hawthorne implies that Goodman Brown has to accept that some of the most trusted people in Salem village and the surrounding area, pretending to be so devout in their religious practices, are in fact part of a massive population of Satan worshipers walking daily among them. Seeing his wife, not despondent, Brown cannot understand how she came to be in that place; surely his pious wife has not given in to Satanic temptation. He calls out to her again to fight the evil in their midst, “Look up to heaven and resist the Wicked One” (Hawthorne 9). Brown believes that he can fight off evil and keep his faith, and he feels that Faith can do the same. Hawthorne permits us to believe that Brown did not succumb to evil, but Faith’s fate is unknown. Once more, Hawthorne leaves their futures to our imaginations.
Young Goodman Brown thought he could entertain a walk with the Devil and remain untainted for life. He was wrong. Hawthorne allows us to imagine that Brown refused to abandon his faith and allow evil to win, to believe that good can overcome bad, but still, the walk left him tainted. Brown’s minimal voluntary acceptance of evil, combined with his prayers and his strong desire to fight and regain his faith, may diminish his evil stain. Goody Cloyse, along with other witches and pawns, have made their pacts with the Devil and must continue to walk with him. The ones who willingly gave their souls to the Devil and joined his community in hell are lost. Perchance Brown’s walk is naught but a dream; nevertheless, he cannot for the rest of his life see or trust the good in his wife or anyone else the way he had before his eyes were opened to the possibility of evil permeating every area of his world. He can no longer be sure of the faith he once knew.
Jack Keefer, September 2023
[The page numbers in the parenthetical citations in this essay may not match with another text you read,
they are from the pages of the handout for the class.]
The whole story may be found in the Work Cited below.
Hawthorne, Nathaniel. “Young Goodman Brown.”
www.columbia.edu/itc/english/f1124y-001/resources/Young_Goodman_Brown.pdf.
Assessed 09 Mar. 2020.
Many of the words used in this story, which was written in 1835, are rarely heard today.
Click the button below to read a copy of the story where I have highlighted many of the uncommon words in bold and provided their meanings in blue.
Click below to reveal the entire story.