For a discussion in my Political Science class in 2019, a question was asked: What should be the most important considerations when filling Judge and Justice positions at the Federal Level?
This was my opinion.
Who Judges the Judges?
I was surprised to learn that neither our Constitution nor our Federal law requires that a Supreme Court Justice be a lawyer. (Although all appointed so far have been.) I consider being a lawyer the most important consideration, as I’m sure any President would, when vetting a potential Nominee for one of the most important judicial offices in our country. I highly doubt that the Senators, who, although all are college graduates, not all are attorneys, would validate a nominee without a law degree for a Supreme Court Justice position. I found, in my research, that having a law degree, while customary, is also not a requirement for many other Judge positions, both Federal and State.
Focusing my thoughts here to Federal level positions only, I will share what I feel are some important considerations. I know a lot of these have been mentioned by other classmates. It is difficult to not overlap when so many similar points are valid.
First, although the framers did not specify the need, I feel it is essential for someone judging the validity and merits of law to be well-versed and experienced in the practice of law. I feel that a Judge in any court should be able to place himself or herself away from personal feelings about the proceeding at hand and evaluate a case purely on the matter before them with no preconceived bias toward the subject, persons, or entities involved. (Is that possible?)
In my opinion, Judges and Justices must have above-average Moral Character, Intelligence, Honesty, Integrity, Impartiality, Fairness, Ethics, Consistency, Political Acceptability, be Team players, and have vast knowledge of our nation’s Constitution and amendments, to say the least. [Let he without sin cast the first stone?] Those considerations are for individual Judges and Justices; however, I do not want to fail to bring forth a highly important consideration for all Federal and State courts: Diversification of Judges and Justices so that more of society feels fairly represented.
I believe that experience in law practice and experience as judges in lower courts is a very important consideration for advancing to higher courts. Experience can lead to a discussion about the age of nominees. The framers did not specify a minimum or a maximum age for Supreme Court Justices, and I have not found that Congress has specified age limits for Judges for other Courts. A President may be advised that a younger nominee would hopefully carry on the same ideology as the president for generations into the future. That could be a major motivating consideration for a President who truly feels he or she has the future of the country, more than his or her legacy, as their priority. However, as past presidents have learned, opinions can change. President Eisenhower remarked with reference to nominating Justice Warren, “the biggest damn fool mistake” he ever made. A president may feel that a younger nominee may be more technologically savvy and more in touch with the current national and geopolitical leanings that our country’s citizens are concerned with.
I can not imagine anyone believing that a younger nominee can have the experience and wisdom of an older nominee. Simply by virtue of their time on the planet, the older nominee should win that debate.
However, that is not to say that an older nominee has spent all his time involved with the Law, is more experienced with knowledge of the constitution, or of precedent-establishing case histories. Consider our current President with lots of business experience and virtually no previous Political experience. Can you imagine a Supreme Court Justice with similar qualifications?
Former President Barack Obama in 2009 expressed the need for “experience” for Supreme Court Justices in this way:
“Experience being tested by obstacles and barriers, by hardship and misfortune, experience insisting, persisting, and ultimately, overcoming those barriers. It is experience that can give a person a common touch and a sense of compassion, an understanding of how the world works, and how ordinary people live. And that is why it is a necessary ingredient in the kind of Justice we need on the Supreme Court.”
An older Supreme Court Justice Nominee that has a fair amount of time involved with the Laws of our nation and is a person well versed in the interpretation of our Constitution with an above average level of practical experience may still not be the best nominee, if he or she is considered too set in his or her ways to be flexible and open to new ideas or possibly new interpretations of what our Constitutional guarantees were, or are now, meant to be.
Age may be an important consideration if a Judge (with an eight-year or four-year renewable term) or a Justice with a lifetime appointment is thought to have short-term retirement thoughts. I understand (now) that the Rule of 80 might allow a younger Justice to start at fifty years of age, work as a Supreme Court Justice for fifteen years, and retire with a very nice pension at age sixty-five. On the other hand, there is no push to obligate people to retire at the rule of 80. Some Justices reaching Senior status continue to advise other Justices. I don’t necessarily see possible retirement at age sixty-five as a reason to reject a nominee. Nor do I see a reason to reject a nominee who may be starting as a Supreme Court Justice at age sixty-five, who may retire before working for fifteen years as a Justice. Unless there is an obvious health issue? Maybe like a Presidential candidate with more than seventy years of age having a recent heart attack, should not be allowed to campaign? Fortunately, our world has not come to that point.
We could go back and forth for many pages debating the value of youthful nominees and all their current and potential assets versus the proven wisdom and experience of older nominees. Again, accepting that age does not automatically equal wisdom or experience.
I agree with the framers’ idea that, either younger or older, the Justices of the Supreme Court who have survived the scrutiny of the Senate, have been confirmed and have received their commissions from the President, have earned the right to serve for as long as they are willing and able to do so. The framers wished for them to have independence, to not be influenced by the political winds of time. I do not pretend to know exactly what the framers meant at that time, and the number of Justices has changed over time, but I do feel that Justices should not have to feel or endure any pressure from a political party, either of a President or a majority Congress. Even though they may be nominated, accepted, and appointed to their positions in the Supreme Court or other courts, they must be able to base decisions on their knowledge and experience and not be swayed by politics.
Supreme Court Appointment Process: President’s Selection of a Nominee
October 19, 2015 – June 27, 2018 R44235
Jack Keefer, 2019