A little discussion post from my Political Science course in 2019.
In which areas do you think people’s rights and liberties are at risk of government intrusion?
Why? Which solutions would you propose?
A little discussion post from my Political Science course in 2019.
In which areas do you think people’s rights and liberties are at risk of government intrusion?
Why? Which solutions would you propose?
Who’s Watching the Watchers?
I believe that we first must embrace the concept of intrusion into our rights and liberties by our governments, which is very much a matter of individual perception. What is thought of as government intrusion for some is thought of simply as government protection by others. We also must consider the definition and understanding of rights and liberties. We are granted certain rights by common law and others by government law, some of which are easily recognized by all, and others that are, fortunately or not, continually under scrutiny and interpretation.
From the beginning of civilizations, rules for living together have been made by leaders or committees who decided what rights and liberties people would have and how they would be enforced. As populations grew, territories expanded, and nations were established, the rights and liberties or restrictions of people increased as needed. Even in the time of the Old Testament, people had lived for thousands of years with various rights and liberties (often few) granted by their leaders. Then Moses came down the mountain with the famous TEN and rocked our world.
Our Constitution’s framers defined, for our nation, rights and liberties that were most relevant for their time. I doubt that everyone agreed with every written rule at that time any more than people throughout time. I am confident that many have felt the hand of government intrusion in their lives much stronger than we do today. How can we know?
I will not attempt to discuss the risk of government intrusion into all people’s rights and liberties, because it is a somewhat subjective topic, and adding Place, Time, Race, Religion, etc., the list would be far too extensive for this post. I will write just a little (I’ll try) about government intrusions into my right and liberty of privacy that I am aware of and not totally comfortable with, including the risk that the intrusions are growing.
Risk of government intrusion? I would say much more of a fact, with the risk of increasing invasive intrusion probable. Is this just a perception of mine, or should I and all of us be aware? What begins as government policies with my safety and protection at the forefront (I’m led to believe) becomes a means for the government to monitor my life with greater control. Social Security numbers (now issued at birth) are required to make sure I pay my taxes. Passports to make sure I can reenter the country I was born in. Driver licenses? Those weren’t required items in the late 1700s.
I am not comfortable with Digital Chips in my Credit cards and Debit cards that track every single transaction: what I buy, where I shop, eat, play, how often… All for my safety to protect me from identity theft? Or getting me accustomed to the idea that it’s ok for the government to have more specific and exact information about my life? Seems like a great way for the IRS to be sure I’m reporting all my income. Of course, that only affects those of us who use Credit and Debit cards. Today! The chips are (so far) only on my cards. I guess I could just use cash and avoid that government intrusion into my privacy; however, the inconvenience is not worth the bother. What do I have to hide from the government? Does it ever feel to you like governments are pushing us closer and closer to cashless societies? Government cryptocurrency, anyone?
How long before the convenient chip in my hand or wrist becomes a required implant that I can simply pass over a scanner for any purpose? Gee, that sounds like great fun. Then, if I am not a good boy, the government can deactivate my chip at their whim?
Government-required digital records at every one of my health care providers? Oh, that’s just so the doctor’s office has easy access to my health records, and so does any doctor anywhere I travel, because it’s all electronically connected? I “Opted In” to give that information to anyone with computer access, including the governments and insurance providers, or only the doctors? Hmmm, I may have missed that in the fine print. Of course, it’s only for my convenience. How can that be intrusive? Now they say, “Opt in, or we can’t serve you. It’s for your Protection.” I can’t imagine the Constitutional framers seeing that coming. Solution: For now, and for as long as possible, I choose to not “Opt In.”
CCTV cameras at every traffic light are there for my protection, or is that another government intrusion into my privacy? With those ubiquitous cameras, different government agencies can monitor my car, and some can see my face at virtually every intersection I cross. What business does any government have to track all my driving movements? Intrusion alert! Then, there are, as well, CCTV tracking cameras on more and more streets, and almost every store has surveillance cameras for “Public Safety.” Are you buying that? Or is it just to help ordinary, honest people stay honest? Unfortunately, it’s not just TV and movies. Look around you! How about facial recognition coming to airports and cities near you soon? To keep you safe?
The government is monitoring every phone call, email, and text message I send? What? Would they do that? I believe we gave the government our OK to pass the PATRIOT Act. I’m positive I did not read the fine print on that one, but I’m sure I thought it was ok at the time.
TSA at the airport? Don’t get me started. I see the need for safety. I do. I used to fly twice a week. However, some of the less-than-pleasant experiences I have had were with individuals taking their TSA authority way too seriously. Consider a baggage search and the guy holding, turning, and staring at my screwdriver as if expecting it to magically transform. Or the guy who, after inspecting my body visibly, told me to hold my arms out to my sides so he could pat me down. Ok, I complied. He insisted I hold out my hands with the palms facing up. I refused! (I was tired; my arms hurt.) I lowered my arms, showed him both sides of my hands, and held my arms out again, palms down. He insisted again that I hold my hands palms up. Try it sometime. It puts your arms in a more vulnerable and uncomfortable position. At least for me. He threatened to call the police if I failed to cooperate. “Excuse me,” I asked, “What country, in what time, did I somehow pass into while going through what they told me was a simple X-ray machine?” He relented and set me free in time to board my flight. Have you noticed that the risk of government intrusion on rights and liberties is increasing? I believe paranoia is.
I don’t see, in my recent studies, that these intrusions (with more to come) are violating any specific Federal, State, or Local laws in violation of my rights or liberties. I don’t know what I would propose to deter the government from monitoring me. These are just a few things that concern me today. I don’t give them a lot of thought. I’m only going to be on this planet another 30 years or so. I do not like the direction our country is moving. Then again, we live in increasingly dangerous times.
I’m completely sure that Big Brother is only watching out for my (and their) safety. I have no reason to fear the “Thought Police” at this point in time, unless you tell me you’ve seen them.
Don’t forget to be awesome.
Jack Keefer
2019