Alan Miklofsky Consulting Website - Building a Line that Works

BUILDING A LINE THAT WORKS ON A 40-FOOT WALL, NOT JUST IN A CATALOG

By Alan Miklofsky – December 2, 2025

A lot of brands build lines for catalogs and trade shows. Independents don’t sell out of catalogs and trade shows. They sell from a 40-foot wall with real customers, limited open-to-buy, and staff trying to remember what makes each shoe special.

If your line doesn’t make sense on that wall, it won’t matter how pretty your lookbook is.

This is how to build a line that actually works where it counts.

THE LINE HAS TO TELL A STORY AT SIX FEET AWAY

Stand at the front of an independent comfort store and look at the wall. From six or eight feet away, the customer is trying to answer a few basic questions:

· Do these shoes look like “me,” or like somebody’s orthopedic punishment?

· Can I spot a few obvious choices to try on?

· Does this brand look coherent or random?

Your job is to make those answers easy. That means:

· Clear families and constructions – a walking family, a travel family, a work-all-day family, maybe a sport-inspired family. Shared soles and constructions keep the wall from looking like a flea market.

· Visible good–better–best – the customer should be able to see entry-level, core, and premium without anyone explaining it. Better finishes, details, and materials should be obvious to the eye, not buried in the spec sheet.

· A sensible color story – core neutrals that anchor the line, plus a few well-chosen fashion colors that look intentional, not like you spilled a paint fan deck.

If your line looks like a curated story instead of a random pile of SKUs, the retailer can actually merchandise it.

SKU COUNT: DISCIPLINE BEATS VOLUME

New or growing brands often think more SKUs equals more opportunity. In independents, more SKUs often equals more confusion and more broken size runs.

For a serious-but-manageable presence on a 40-foot wall, think in terms of:

· Hero styles – two to four constructions that can carry real volume. These are your everyday “reach for it” shoes.

· Supporting casts – a few variations on those heroes: a strap instead of a lace, a mary jane instead of a plain oxford, a casual slip-on using the same bottom.

· Strategic outliers – one or two “statement” styles that show personality but still fit the comfort mission. They should earn their keep in margin or marketing value, not just designer pride.

The test: could a buyer put together a strong, clear assortment in under thirty minutes without feeling like they need a spreadsheet and a therapist? If not, your line is doing too much.

SIZES, WIDTHS, AND FIT: BUILT FOR REAL FEET

Independent comfort retailers live or die on fit. Your line has to respect that reality or you will sit in back rooms forever.

Key points:

· Start where the store lives – if their core customer is a 55–75-year-old comfort shopper, that means half sizes, enough depth, and last shapes that don’t punish bunions. If the store does serious medical-referral business, removable insoles and depth matter more than whatever fashion blog you’re reading.

· Widths and core size runs – you don’t need every width under the sun in year one, but you do need to cover the heart of the bell curve. Think through men’s and women’s core runs: if you cut corners here, you simply can’t be a go-to brand.

· Fit consistency – if your 8 in one style fits like a 7½ and your 8 in another fits like a 9, staff will stop reaching for you. Decide what “true to size” means for your brand and stick to it relentlessly.

A brand that fits predictably is a brand staff will grab when the store is busy. A brand that fits randomly becomes “only when I have time to fight with it.”

HOW THE LINE SHOULD MERCHANDISE

On a 40-foot wall, the buyer and visual merchandiser are trying to create logic: rows or blocks that say “here’s the walking section,” “here’s dress-casual,” “here’s sporty,” “here’s sandals.”

Your line should be built to:

· Live together in blocks – shared soles and shared visual language so your product groups nicely instead of scattering like confetti. Inside each family, offer enough variety that a customer can try three shoes with slightly different looks and fits.

· Support vertical storytelling – think in vertical columns: top for statement or premium styles, middle for core volume drivers, bottom for price-entry or comfort-basics.

· Avoid pointless duplication – three nearly identical black walkers at the same price point is not “choice”; it’s indecision for both the buyer and the customer. Every style should either bring a new fit, a new occasion, or a clearly different aesthetic. If it doesn’t, it’s probably a designer’s vanity project.

THE COLOR STORY: INTENTIONAL, NOT RANDOM

Independent retailers need your colors to play nicely with their assortments, not fight them.

Think about:

· Anchor colors – black, key browns, navy, maybe a clean grey. These should look rich and modern, not dead and dusty.

· Core neutrals with a pulse – taupes, sands, off-whites that work with today’s clothing, not leftovers from a 1998 comfort catalog.

· Tasteful accents – one or two fashion colors or textures per family that give personality without scaring off the comfort shopper. Ideally, these are shades you can carry for more than one season if they sell.

Your goal is to help the wall look fresh but believable, not like you dumped a streetwear drop into a medical-referral environment.

PRICE LADDERING THAT MAKES SENSE INDEPENDENTLY

A good line works at three levels in an independent:

· Entry – clean, simple, reliable shoes at a price that doesn’t make people flinch. These should still be worthy of your name; if they feel cheap, you damage trust up the ladder.

· Core – where you want most of the volume. Strong materials, strong comfort story, strong value perception.

· Premium – distinct upgrades: better leathers, more sophisticated constructions, visible detailing. The customer should be able to tell “why it costs more” in under three seconds.

If the ladder is clear, staff can trade the customer up or down without feeling like they’re guessing.

HOW TO PRESSURE-TEST YOUR LINE BEFORE YOU SELL IT

Before you show the line to independents, do a brutal internal test. Ask:

· Could a retailer create a 12–18 style assortment that looks coherent on a wall?

· Are there obvious heroes, or does everything look like a co-star?

· Do we have clear use cases: work, walk, travel, light sport, recovery?

· Can a sales rep explain the structure of the line in under five minutes?

· Does each style earn its place by doing something different in fit, function, or look?

If you can’t pass that test internally, buyers will feel that fuzziness and write you like a novelty instead of a pillar.

THE PAYOFF OF A LINE BUILT FOR THE WALL

When your line is built for a 40-foot wall instead of a catalog page, several good things happen:

· Buyers can see immediately where you fit in their mix.

· Staff can learn your family structure quickly and remember it.

· Customers can scan the wall and find “their lane” without getting overwhelmed.

· Your winners emerge faster, and fill-in business becomes predictable instead of accidental.

That is how an independent moves you from “We’ll try a few styles” to “We’re going to build a category with these folks.”

You didn’t just design shoes. You designed a line that works where it lives: on the wall, under real light, in front of real customers, with real money on the line.