Alan Miklofsky Consulting Website - Cost of Goods Sold Issues

Cost of Goods Sold (COGS) Issues

Lessons from a Hypothetical Shoe Store

By Alan Miklofsky, November 17, 2024

Cost of Goods Sold (COGS) directly impacts your store’s profitability. Rising supplier costs, pricing mismanagement, or poor oversight can quickly erode margins, leaving a business struggling to stay afloat. Let’s dive into how XYZ Shoe Co., a fictional shoe retailer, faced—and overcame—COGS-related challenges to restore profitability and thrive in a competitive market.

The Problem: COGS-Related Challenges

At XYZ Shoe Co., the owner noticed profits shrinking despite consistent sales. A closer look at the financials revealed the root of the issue:

Rising Supplier Costs: Vendor price increases weren’t matched with adjustments in retail pricing, leading to shrinking margins.
Discount Overuse: Frequent sales and deep discounts eroded profitability while training customers to wait for markdowns.
Overreliance on Low-Margin Products: Too much inventory was tied up in items with slim profit margins, while high-margin products were often understocked.
Pricing Mismanagement: Inconsistent pricing strategies failed to reflect product value or market demand.
Failure to Negotiate Terms: Vendor agreements weren’t reviewed regularly, leaving the store locked into less-than-optimal pricing or terms.

These missteps combined to create a profitability crisis that put XYZ Shoe Co.’s long-term success at risk.

The Impact: Declining Margins and Operational Strain

The COGS issues at XYZ Shoe Co. created several ripple effects:

Shrinking Profits: Despite steady sales, the store struggled to cover operating expenses and reinvest in growth.
Customer Confusion: Inconsistent pricing strategies led to customer dissatisfaction and price sensitivity.
Inventory Challenges: A backlog of low-margin items limited cash flow, while high-margin products were frequently out of stock.
Vendor Strain: The lack of negotiation led to missed opportunities for better terms, such as volume discounts or promotional support.

The Solution: A COGS Optimization Strategy

XYZ Shoe Co. developed a comprehensive strategy to address their COGS issues and rebuild profitability. Here’s how they turned things around:

Analyzed Product Margins:
- Conducted a detailed margin analysis to identify high-margin and low-margin products.
- Prioritized stocking items with healthier profit margins.
Adjusted Pricing Strategically:
- Introduced tiered pricing strategies based on demand and perceived value.
- Implemented consistent markup policies to ensure profitability across categories.
Reevaluated Supplier Relationships:
- Renegotiated terms with key vendors, focusing on volume discounts and promotional support.
- Sought alternative suppliers for certain products to reduce costs without sacrificing quality.
Reduced Overuse of Discounts:
- Replaced blanket sales with targeted promotions tied to specific events or inventory goals.
- Focused on value-driven marketing instead of price-driven campaigns.
Invested in Training:
- Educated staff on upselling high-margin products and managing customer price objections.
- Trained managers to monitor and adjust pricing based on sales trends and market changes.

Key Takeaways

Know Your Margins: Regularly review product-level margins to ensure your pricing aligns with profitability goals.
Negotiate with Suppliers: Strong vendor relationships can lead to better terms and lower costs.
Strategize Discounts: Use promotions sparingly and purposefully to avoid eroding long-term profitability.
Focus on High-Margin Products: Make high-margin items a priority in your merchandising and inventory strategy.
Adapt Pricing: Stay proactive about adjusting pricing to reflect rising costs, market trends, and product value.

By addressing their COGS challenges head-on, XYZ Shoe Co. restored their profit margins and positioned the business for long-term success. Effective COGS management isn’t just about cutting costs—it’s about making smart decisions that drive sustainable growth.

Could your business benefit from a closer look at your COGS strategy? With the right approach, you can protect your margins and strengthen your bottom line.