Students must talk to one another, not just to the teacher.
Students must listen to one another.
To ensure this happens,they must either address the previous speaker or offer a reason for changing the subject.
Students must participate at least once during the seminar. If someone called upon has nothing to say, the appropriate response is "I’m not sure what I think about that, but please come back to me."
Hand-raising is not always necessary.Wait for natural pauses to offer comments.
Silence is part of a seminar, too. People are thinking.
If necessary, read aloud from the text to push the discussion forward.
Only one student speaks at a time.
Repeat: "I am a voice in the world; I deserve to be heard!"