The following members of Troop 504 have been awarded the rank of Eagle Scout, the highest rank attainable in Boy Scouts. The title of Eagle Scout is held for life, thus giving rise to the phrase "Once an Eagle, always an Eagle".
Requirements include earning at least 21 merit badges and demonstrating Scout Spirit through the Boy Scout Oath and Law, service, and leadership. This includes an extensive service project that the Scout plans, organizes, leads, and manages. Eagle Scouts are presented with a medal and a badge that visibly recognizes the accomplishments of the Scout. Additional recognition can be earned through Eagle Palms, awarded for completing additional tenure, leadership, and merit badge requirements.
1962 - David R. Stoll
1964 - Stephan M. Tabb
1967 - Alan P. Sweide
1968 - Richard A. Long
1969 - Rick A. Sahli
1970 - Edward J. Hojdar
1973 - John M. Weber
1982 - Richard A. Beaudoin
1982 - Daniel H. Blechshmidt
1990 - Joseph M. Ferencie
1992 - David M. Mansbach
1992 - Douglas R. Wahl
1994 - James A. McCuen
1995 - Andrew P. Ruggles
1995 - James D. Van Gompel
1997 - Trevor M. Cost
1998 - Michael M. Manion
1998 - Thomas D. Wilson
1998 - Richard F. Maskiell
1998 - Andrew C. Devore
1998 - Andrew T. Lumpkins
1999 - Thomas J (TJ) Manion
2000 - Brian Siano
2000 - Mike Leib
2000 - Brian Daugherty
2000 - Robert Snyder
2000 - James Larson
2000 - Joe Lumpkins
2000 - Danny Caine
2002 - Carl Snyder
2003 - Daniel E. Jira
2003 - John Strawn
2003 - Brian Cost
2003 - Matt Leib
2003 - Eric Lewis
2004 - David Akers
2004 - Stephen Cribb
2004 - Benjamin Kalayjian
2004 - Chris Sparks
2005 - Russel Goodwin
2005 - Justin Zabiegala
2005 - Matthew B. Holmes
2005 - Matthew Caine
2005 - Matthew T. Skonezny
2005 - William White
2005 - Thomas J. Atkinson
2005 - Neal J. Repko
2005 - Matthew Kalayjian
2005 - Nicholas Klein
2005 - Michael Fakler
2006 - Benjamin Levison
2006 - Brian C. Gulko
2006 - Ross M. Gulko
2007 - Matthew Dahar
2007 - Sean H. Heffernan
2007 - Alex M. Collister
2007 - Jason P. Boers
2007 - Andrew (Chicago) McKinnie
2007 - Michael Chelnick
2008 - William C. (Billy) Koenig
2008 - Jared M. Horwitz
2008 - James A. Lilie
2008 - Nathaniel L. (Nate) Freeman
2008 - Christian B. Gluvna
2008 - Collin Griffiths
2008 - Stephen Jira
2008 - Jeremy King
2008 - Gregory M. Lavins
2009 - Gregory D. Au
2009 - Charles Thomas
2009 - Steven Biel
2009 - Andre St. Amour
2009 - Herbert (Herbie) Wilson
2010 - Alec Singerman
2010 - Alex Yelin
2010 - Robert Breetz
2010 - Greg Koenig
2010 - Ben Wainblat
2010 - Kyle Boers
2010 - Jonathan Thornton
2010 - Brian Novitsky
2010 - Tyler Catrillo
2010 - Craig (CJ) Eyman Jr.
2010 - Joseph Kravetz
2011 - Andrew Gluvna
2011 - Thomas (Tommy) Koenig
2011 - Scott A. Simpson
2011 - Eric Pohle
2011 - Ethan Wainblat
2012 - David Chelnick
2012 - Jason Timotiwu
2012 - Jordan I. Timotiwu
2012 - Sagar Amrania
2013 - Thomas B. Imhoff
2013 - Douglas F. Naylor III
2013 - Kyle R. Eyman
2013 - Matthew K. Laubscher
2013 - Westley Waligora
2013 - Ian Bernard
2015 - James I. Timotiwu
2015 - Jonathan Wainblat
2016 - Peter J. Wilson
2016 - David J. Eder
2016 - Alexander M. Winkler
2017 - Jacob M. Levine
2017 - Ryan P. Williams
2017 - Jack Whitman
2018 - Matthew Marting
2019 - Timothy M. Fornadel
2019 - Ryan M. Bauza
2019 - Matthew P. Wilson
2020 - Nate Salata
2021 - Joseph T. Ferencie
2021 - Andrew Fornadel
2022 - David Levine
2023 - Daniel Sher