Outline #4
Newton and the Mechanical Philosophy
Newton and the Mechanical Philosophy
The context and consequence of Newton’s work:
- Influences and interests (1660s – )
- education at Cambridge & research (philosophical notebooks)
- practical technology, inventions, and mechanical philosophy
- alchemy and chemical experimentation
- mathematics — new Cartesian geometry, algebra, infinite series
- theology (secret Arianism)
- language
- historical chronology and prophecy (Book of Daniel)
- Newton’s place in the mechanical philosophy research program: mathematics and gravitation
- work of 1665-66:
- mathematics (influence of John Wallis) of binomial theorem, calculus
- color theory for optics
- gravitation and the planets’ orbits
- “delay” in publishing
- controversy with Hooke:
- disputes over priority of optics theory and mathematics of orbits
- personality clash
- disagreement over empiricism, models, method
- Halley’s encouraging role in Newton’s work
- Newton’s solution of universal gravitational attraction: force, inertia, point mass
- work of 1665-66:
- Newton’s Principia [Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy] (1687)
- Book One:
- general dynamics on a mathematical basis (starting with the motion of particles)
- laws of motion
- principles of mechanics
- Kepler’s Laws
- Book Two:
- motion in fluids
- motion of fluid media
- vortices
- Book Three:
- universal gravitation (moon & earth)
- particle attraction
- extension to problems of pendulum, tides, irregularities
- general principles for physics
- Book One:
- persuasiveness of Principia
- solutions to fit data
- unification of celestial and earthly physics under universal laws
- coverage of old facts and dilemmas within one system
- novel ideas and extension to new problems and solutions
- mathematical derivations, proofs, synthetic system
- principles or method of doing mechanical philosophy
- criticisms
- gravitation as an “occult force” [Huygens]
- difficulties with mathematics
- priority claims of Hooke
The Newtonian Synthesis:
- a consistent physics of solutions and innovations [Whewellian “consilience“]
- Newton’s “rules of philosophy”
- minimal sufficient causes
- universal laws, and deduction of causes from similar actions
- measurable, reductionist, non-occult, material properties
- experimental acceptance and rejection of hypotheses
- the Newtonian ideal method
- avoid first causes, occult causes, naive mechanisms
- the meanings of “hypotheses non fingo” for practicing physicists:
- dispute over the role of theory
- ensuing traditions of physics research:
- empirical (lab and models)
- theoretical (mathematical)
- Newtonian assumptions [‘Query 31’ in Opticks]:
- particulate, material world
- universal laws and relationships
- attraction (affinity)
© 2018 Dr. William Kimler