Romee

Hi, I'm Romee; meaning "daughter of Talmai" in Dutch or, according to the Urban Dictionary : "when one feels happy". Just like you, I am graduating this semester and my studies in language will be very helpful to my future career. I'm very passionate about writing and am hoping to become a journalist and a writer. I love learning about the art of language around the world, hence why I chose this program and I would love to travel the world and cover different topics as a journalist. I am also very interested in poetry and try my best to read and write some in the languages that I am learning at the moment (German & Norwegian). Culture is such an important facet of human life and we cannot explore it without exploring language first.

Children of God followers worship in 1980 Germany.

2. Topic Selection

In my essay, I will look at a few New Religious Movements (NRMs), past and present, and explore their use of language as their ultimate form of power. How can one practice coercion using language ? Are cult members manipulated by their leader through verbal or non-verbal acts of communication ? Can the techniques used in such settings be useful in others, such as advertisement ? By using my different sources (see below) and going deep into cults such as the Manson family, Children of God and Scientology, I hope I will be able to answer these questions and bring a critical approach to the linguistic side of cults.

Source 1.

Montell, Amanda. "Cultish: The Language of Fanaticism." Harper Wave Publishers, 2021, pp. 320.

Source 2.

Dawson, Lorne L. "Comprehending Cults: The Sociology of New Religious Movements." Oxford University Press, 2006, pp.266.

Cultish : The Language of Fanaticism

Montell analyzes the social linguistic science of cult influence. By looking at what she describes as various "cultish" groups from the 1970s to nowadays, she attempts to make connections in their linguistic approaches with potential members. She claims that NRMs are using language to incite people to join them but most importantly, stay. Finally, Montell looks at non-religious groups such as the popular SoulCycle and how their ways of advertising their services can overlap with cults' ones. Amanda Montelll is a linguist and journalist who has written for several magazines and journals as well as published another book previous to this one; making this source very reliable. I am planning on using her approach in my own essay since we share the same point of view on the question, although my selection of cult movements is different than hers.

Comprehending Cults : The Sociology of New Religious Movements

Dawson explores the universe of prejudices and misconceptions when it comes to cults. Here, different types of New Religious Movements are described and critically broken down so that the reader can have a good idea of how a cult can be born and how it can survive. Interviews with diverse psychologists and sociologists who are specialized in the behavioral science behind a cult and its followers and leader are included in the book as well, but Dawson advances that cult followers join from their own will and that most cults do not put pressure on their members to engage in certain activities in any way; linguistic or not. As a Canadian professor at University of Waterloo in Sociology and Religious Studies, he has written several books on religious movements and cults, making this source reliable as well. I will present his arguments to introduce mine as a way to counter-argue, since I believe this scholar is neglecting the years of therapy some ex-members had to undergo in order to "reset" their minds that were manipulated to unfathomable extents.

“That’s because language doesn’t work to manipulate people into believing things they don’t want to believe; instead, it gives them license to believe ideas they’re already open to. Language—both literal and figurative, well-intentioned and ill-intentioned, politically correct and politically incorrect—reshapes a person’s reality only if they are in an ideological place where that reshaping is welcome” (Montell, 149).

A 1979 image that shows disciples of Rajneesh lying on the ground, in meditation at the mystic’s headquarters in Poona, India.

3. Questions

What is coercion ? How do New Religious Movements use it ? Is there even such a thing as brainwashing ? Can anyone be manipulated by a cult leader ? What type of language is most effective to convince people ? What are loaded and co-opted terms and how do they work ? Is brainwashing dangerous ? How has language been used in the past to build cults ?

Source 3.

Rosen, Michael. "Word of Mouth : EP1. Cultish Language." BBC Sounds, 3 August 2021, https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m000ycwk

This podcast episode, hosted by Michael Rosen, a writer, welcomes Amanda Montell as its guest so she can talk about her experience growing up with a father who was a cult member himself. I am planning to use this testimony to back up some of my claims because I believe personal experiences need to be included not only to acknowledge survivors, but also validate their experience and bring examples of how language has been used maliciously in a cult before.

Source 4.

O'Reilly, Patrick. Psychotherapy With Former Cult Members. Psychotherapy.net : Great therapists never stop learning. 2022, https://www.psychotherapy.net/article/cult-members

This source is scientifically backed since the website was built by psychologists and psychotherapists. Since I want to describe the process of brainwashing in details and accurately, this source is one of my most important ones. It covers recruitment tactics and blackmail techniques to push people to join a cult and keep them from getting out.

4. What is a cult ?

\ˈkəlt\

According to the Merriam-Webster dictionary:

  • a small religious group that is not part of a larger and more accepted religion and that has beliefs regarded by many people as extreme or dangerous.

  • a small group of very devoted supporters or fans.

  • a religion regarded as unorthodox or spurious. also : its body of adherents.

  • great devotion to a person, idea, object, movement, or work.

Charles Manson on trial for the Tate-LaBianca murders.

The Overlap of Cults and Culture

"Cult, which shares an origin with culture and cultivate, comes from the Latin cultus, a noun with meanings ranging from "tilling, cultivation" to "training or education" to "adoration." In English, cult has evolved a number of meanings following a fairly logical path. The earliest known uses of the word, recorded in the 17th century, broadly denoted "worship." From here cult came to refer to a specific branch of a religion or the rites and practices of that branch, as in "the cult of Dionysus." By the early 18th century, cult could refer to a non-religious admiration or devotion, such as to a person, idea, or fad ("the cult of success"). Finally, by the 19th century, the word came to be used of "a religion regarded as unorthodox or spurious."

5. Tentative Thesis Statement & Tentative Topic Sentences

Follow the Lead : Linguistic coercion in New Religious Movements

Cults use language as their ultimate form of power to brainwash people into joining their movement. I will prove the veracity of this claim by exploring the concept of coercion in definition versus in application as well as the verbal and non-verbal sides of NRMs' communication with their follower.

P1 : Anyone can be coerced into joining an NRM. However, "brainwashing" cannot work if the ideas promoted by the cult were not already considered by the follower in the past.

P2 : The most powerful linguistic tools of NRMs are loaded terms, co-opted terms and inclusive code language.

P3 : Manipulation goes beyond words. It's also about non-verbal communication and peer pressure.

Midsommar (A24), 2019.

6. First Sentence : The Hook

From the Jonestown massacre in 1978 to Scientology's growing following since the mid 1980s, we have watched New Religious Movements gain popularity and probably convinced ourselves that we would never fall for it. But what if no one is safe from cults' coercion ?

Source 7

Peterson, Britt. "Scientology's enturbulating lingo." The Boston Globe, 19 March 2015. https://www.bostonglobe.com/ideas/2015/03/19/scientology-enturbulating-lingo/TvBESMQkV4RcxGnyrNSH1K/story.html

Source 8

Hristova, Simona. "Charles Manson : The Language of Cults." University of Aberdeen Press, May 2020. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/348807167_Charles_Manson_The_Language_of_Cults

Source 9

Stein, Alexandra. "Terror, Love and Brainwashing : Attachment in Cults and Totalitarian Systems." Routledge Taylor & Francis Group, 2016, pp. 264.

7. Brainwashing & Mind Control

Brainwashing might not be an actual concept, since it presents an "untestable hypothesis" according to scientists. Regardless, mind control techniques have been explored by new religious groups and even governments - with the famous project MK-ULTRA - to try to get people to do something against their will. For the first part of my paper, I want to prove that one can influence another but that, at the end of the day, we are the perpetrators of our own actions and joining a NRM is no exception.

8. The Profile of a Convert

Based on the Lofland-Stark model, presented by Lorne Dawson in Comprehending Cults: The Sociology of New Religious Movements.

  1. Tension : Unpleasant feeling felt by the individual that is mostly psychological such as strain, frustration or deprivation.

  2. Change in problem-solving perspectives : When psychiatric, economic or political solutions no longer or fail to ease the individual's tension.

  3. Seeker ship : Individual seeks religious or spiritual answers to their problems.

  4. Change in circumstances : A life changing event occurs such as a move, the loss of a job or a loved one, divorce or heartbreak, etc.

  5. Increase in cult affective bonds : Along a decrease in out-cult affective bonds.

  6. Cutting ties : The individual separates themselves from non cult members.

  7. Intensive interactions : Increase in participation in the cult's activities.

9. Scientology & The People's Temple

For the linguistic part of my paper, I want to provide concrete examples of the tools used by NRMs for coercion.

Loaded-terms : Jim Jones' "revolutionary suicide", which he described as a "political statement against the hidden rulers". This creates a sense of importance reinforced by the feeling of belonging to a group that can create big change.

Co-opted terms : Scientology borrowed many words from science to appeal to outsiders and be taken more seriously, although none of their beliefs are actually based on scientific evidence. The best examples would be "engrams" or "psychogenic".

Thought-terminating clichés : Vague language or phrases used to limit one's doubts and reach a greater number of converts. "Everything happens for a reason" or "this is what you were meant for" can be used to keep someone from questioning the cult's practices. Scientology makes use of this techniques a lot.

Scientolgy's Chairmaster David Miscavige.