China

The time has come, we are about to dive into the challenges of one of my favorite seasons. Survivor: China is truly the final season of Survivor which consistently attempts to infuse culture into its challenges, and I think we will see that it pays off beautifully. The timing of this entry is also interesting— recently, the Survivor subreddit, in their WSSYW 10.0 polling, concluded that Survivor: China has the best challenges out of any season. Now, I will say, I disagree with where most of the seasons ended up being ranked based on challenges, and there was a clear trend of "good season, good challenges, bad season, bad challenges," and I still am very confident that no season will ever top Survivor: Palau for me, but I still think this is a special occasion. This is the season the majority of people voted as having the best challenges, and I am incredibly excited to look back on them.

Originally published: November 26th, 2020

episode 1 reward/immunity challenge

Dragon Dance Physical Race / Mental

The season begins with a very colorful, culture-filled challenge. The tribe colors this season are red and yellow, and for some reason, I just love the way those colors go together in challenges. It's absolutely perfect to represent China, no doubt, but it's also just aesthetically very pleasing. Each tribe has a giant dragon, which is quite long, and in order to carry it, each person in the tribe needs to hold onto a separate pole connected to the body. A couple of notes here: First, the dragons really look amazing. That's something we will be seeing a lot of this season— the art department truly excels here, with consistency perhaps unmatched by any other season of the show. It's not just in challenges; just about every aspect of this season looks beautiful in one way or another. I also really like this idea for the first challenge. Similar to last season's "Chariots of Mire," it demands that every person in the tribe pull their weight, or else it will cost the tribe heavily. The first part of the challenge is a maze-like obstacle that the tribes need to move their dragon through, and the aerial shots look great here. After the maze, there are some minor inclines that need to be walked, until the tribe reaches a drawbridge and locked gate. This is where the challenge allows one person to be the hero, so to speak, and scale up and over the wall, lowering it so the rest of the tribe can cross. It is incredibly satisfying to watch James, the apparent athlete of the season, go head to head with Frosti, the master of parkour, in this section of the challenge. After this, there is a similar obstacle. The same representatives who climbed the wall must now use a rope to climb an even taller wall, and pull a lever, which lowers a staircase for the rest of the tribe to climb up. The representatives then grab a key, race back to unlock the gate, and the entire tribe, carrying their dragon, race to the next obstacle, which is a swamp that needs to be sloshed through. This is another example of Survivor incorporating the location's actual geography into its challenge design, which is always nice to see. The final section is a puzzle, and it puts a nice bow on the whole challenge. The poles which were used to carry the dragon need to be placed into the correct holders, allowing the dragon to stand up on its own. The tribes are pretty even throughout the challenge, but Fei Long ends up winning the first match of the season.

4/5

episode 2 reward challenge

Chinese Checkers Physical Race

It's in the title— in this challenge, both tribes engage in a round of chinese checkers. Just kidding, we've graduated from Survivor: Fiji and aren't playing board games in Survivor challenges anymore. Instead, this is the return of Boulder Smash from Survivor: Guatemala. This version is even better than the original. You may be wondering how that is possible, since I gave Guatemala's version a perfect score, but please keep in mind that challenges are graded on a relative scale that considers all challenges, and in that context, both versions deserve a perfect score, even if I think that one version is notably better than the other. With that out of the way, let us rejoice. Boulder Smash is back everyone! Make no mistake, there have been some pretty significant changes made, but the idea is still the same. In teams, playing in a court, the idea is to roll a large ball into the other team's goal, and the first tribe to score a certain amount of points wins. Let's get into the changes. First, the court has undergone a significant redesign. It has the same shape, but now it is a pit of mud. I really like this decision. I did really enjoy the novelty of Guatemala's court, which had trees scattered across it acting as natural obstacles, but there's something about mud that really tends to enhance Survivor challenges. It also really benefits the second major change, which is that instead of one giant ball, there are now two smaller, but still large, balls in the court at once. About the balls being smaller— I love this. This has always been a physical contact challenge, but we really didn't get a lot of physical contact in Guatemala's version, and that was largely because the ball was so big, most of the time you wouldn't even really be near the other team. The smaller balls, in combination with the muddy court, which slows down mobility significantly, allows this challenge to turn into one of the most physical ones in the show's history. And it is unbelievably entertaining. About there being two balls— it's an interesting choice. I guess I kind of like it because there's more action going on at once, and it allows the audience to track multiple stories at once. Adding another ball just makes things all the more chaotic. Things never really slow down. (That's not to say if things did slow down, the challenge wouldn't be as good, because it would still be incredible. Thank you Survivor: Philippines, I can't wait to talk about that!) There are a couple of other small changes as well. The balls aren't just smaller, their design is completely different. They now have a much more intricate look, and it just looks really cool. Speaking of really cool, the challenge team also went ahead and made this really awesome lever system that Jeff uses to release the balls. There was no reason for them to do this outside of it just making the challenge feel extra polished and high-effort, and if you know me, you'd know that I greatly appreciate things like that. The amount of points to win has also been reduced from 3 to 2, which... I mean, I would sit here all day watching a 100 point game, but it's okayyy. With all of that said, let's finally get into the actual challenge. It starts raining right when the challenge begins, which is actually perfect. It makes things even muddier and provides some really unique scenery. There are only two rounds, and the first one is the best. There is a lot of wrestling in the mud that takes place, and at one humorous point, Jaime pulls off Denise's shoe and just chucks it across the court. Then, we reach a point where, as Jeff Probst puts it, "everybody pulling everybody's clothes off." Yeah, it's something else. Amanda ends up completely topless, but she is able to get free, and while everyone else is caught up wrestling in the mud, she is able to score a point, exclaiming in joy "my mom is going to kill me!" It's a fantastic moment, very worthy of being the episode title, and if you recall in my Guatemala entry, I said that every time this challenge appears it has some sort of iconic moment; this was the China version's iconic moment. Now, don't sleep on the second round either though! It's still very entertaining, as we get more wrestling around in mud before James scores the winning point for Fei Long.

5/5

episode 2 immunity challenge

Gatecrasher Physical Race / Mental

The second Immunity Challenge of the season is underappreciated in my opinion. I'm actually kind of shocked that they do in fact bring it back in Cagayan, given it so perfectly fits the location of China specifically; I guess production must like this challenge as much as I do. Each tribe begins holding a log, which they must use to smash through a series of walls. I'm not sure what the exact history is on using this method to break through doors, but I when I see this challenge, I just immediately imagine some crazy, abstract scene taking place hundreds of years ago in Ancient China; the dynasty is being overthrown, and their temple is being stormed by a small but powerful army. It fits the cultural and historic theme of the season so well. The challenge itself is also very inventive. Similar to the first challenge of the season, the large object, in this case, a log, being carried by the tribe throughout the challenge, will be used to solve a puzzle at the end of the challenge. The puzzle involves sliding, pushing, and pulling the log through a maze, kind of similar to a table maze. The final step is to have one person from the tribe hit a gong. Things start off pretty poorly for the Zhan Hu tribe, largely due to Dave becoming extremely worn out by the gate-smashing portion of the challenge. This is pretty humorous to watch as the viewer, because Dave had pretty much built himself up as the leader of the tribe, and so to see him stumble here feels like poetic justice. However, by the time the tribes reach the maze section, the tribes were even again, and Zhan Hu actually takes the lead for a brief period. Fei Long doesn't panic though, which allows them to reclaim their lead and ultimately win the challenge. I would once again like to commemorate the great work of the art department this season; everything looks so authentic and detailed. The puzzle logs are particularly impressive looking. There are a whole bunch of Chinese characters written on them. Super cool! So far, this season is off to an amazing start with its challenges!
4/5

episode 3 reward challenge

Clear the Deck Physical Race

Back to back episodes with a physical contact challenge! Exciting! And this is an entirely one-off physical contact challenge, so it should be interesting to talk about. This challenge is kind of like a combination of Pilfering Pirates and Sumo at Sea. Much like in Sumo at Sea, the goal is to knock your opponent off the platform and into the water, but there is no sumo bag involved; in teams of three, the sole purpose of the challenge is to push, throw, whatever you need to do, the other team into the water. This is essentially Robb Zbacnik's dream challenge— the entire course is the Attack Zone! The course itself is made of two ships, connected by two narrow planks. I like this design; there is an inherent risk in crossing to the other team's turf, because you are much more vulnerable while on a plank. The first, all women round is pretty interesting, although it goes by pretty quickly. In Round 2, Dave is up, and he decides to take a page out of Morgan's playbook and do the entire round naked. This strategically proves to be equally effective as when Morgan tried it; his team loses the round. I believe this is the last time we ever see someone go intentionally naked in a challenge, which I would say is for the better. In fact, just thinking about it right now, I'm actually shocked they allowed Dave to do this given what happened in All-Stars, but hey, they needed something to ask Dave about at the reunion show. James is pretty much an unstoppable force in this challenge; Zhan Hu have next to zero chance at winning any round against him. With that being said, you would think that Fei Long would have a good shot at winning this challenge, but they run into a problem. Each round alternates between all women and all men, and although they always win the men-only round with James, the Fei Long women always lose to the Zhan Hu women. and because the challenge started with an all women round, Zhan Hu is able to win the challenge 3-2. I continue to love these types of challenges. I'm not sure where most other people stand on this particular one, since it's a bit more obscure, but it is unsurprisingly another one of my favorites of the season. I would also like to say that the location is very nice; we actually don't get a lot of water-action this season. There are just a few challenges that take place in the glistening lakes of the Zhelin Reservoir, and I appreciate each and every one of them.

5/5

episode 3 immunity challenge

Blade Runner Physical Race / Mental

For this Immunity Challenge, each tribe designates four "choppers" and two "puzzle builders." One at a time, each chopper has to use a sword to cut through wooden beams, revealing ropes. Chopping the ropes releases a bundle of wooden discs. Once all of the bundles of discs have been released, the puzzle builders have to stack the discs on a puzzle pole, so that all of the discs stack on top of each other. I appreciate this next part, especially because it is somewhat rare for a challenge to go physical race, mental, and then back to physical race again— the puzzle pole is attached to a heavy stone base, and once the puzzle is completed, it has to be dragged with a rope across the finish line. At first glance, while a novel idea for a challenge, there is nothing here related to Chinese culture or history, but actually, I think it is present here, it just isn't explained. The wooden discs are almost certainly a reference to either "Dropa stones," or "bi," both being of Chinese origin, and both with pretty interesting stories. Bi are circular artifacts made from Chinese jade, and were produced by several ancient dynasties dating back to about 3000 BC. Even more fascinating are Dropa stones. They are said to have been 716 circular stone discs dating back to 12,000 years ago, on which tiny hieroglyphic markings could be found. They were supposedly discovered in 1938, by a Chinese professor in a cave, which also had rock art of the sun, moon, earth, and stars. After four years of studying, the professor allegedly deciphered the writing on the discs, one of which apparently detailed how the Dropa people came down from the clouds in their aircraft. In 1968, a Russian scientist is said to have conducted tests on the stones and determined they had very peculiar properties, which would have been very hard for humans at the time to carve into, adding credence to the idea that the Dropa were an alien race. By 1994, the Dropa discs were said to have been destroyed. Many people believe that the Dropa discs never existed in the first place, and were simply a hoax. Whether you believe the Dropa ever existed or not, you cannot deny that this would have been a great story to use for Survivor Folklore, a challenge that I am absolutely floored does not appear this season, given they are filming in China— the possibilities are absolutely endless. But enough with that little tangent, let's get into the challenge! The one part of this challenge that everybody remembers is Courtney's rope-chopping skills. Listen, chopping through rope with a sword is simply not Courtney's forte, don't judge! The Zhan Hu tribe completely finishes their chopping before Courtney is able to release even the first bundle of discs for Fei Long. There is an especially funny moment, where she gets down to one final rope to cut, and her tribe is like "alright Courtney, one more, do a big slash!" And she does this pitiful swing that doesn't cut through the rope at all. One thing I find interesting to track as I rewatch all of these challenges is the wildly varying degree of reinforcement Jeff uses when narrating these challenges. You never know whether it's going to be positive or negative. I think most people would have been totally destroyed by Jeff here. After all, Jeff loves to say things like "the biggest challenge blunder in survivor HISTORY!"  But he's actually quite nice to Courtney here, reminding her that there is still a puzzle and she still has a chance. It's like Jeff's tone during the challenges entirely hinges on what side of bed he woke up on that morning, and I love him for it. During this season, we are going to see a couple of instances of the editors playing around with different effects to use during challenges. To be honest, it's really funny. The editors are just having some fun, that's all, and it actually gives a couple of these challenges a unique sense of identity. During this challenge, every time someone chops through a rope, the camera zooms in to their face and time slows down, in an overly dramatic scene. You know what, I like it! The puzzle makers at Zhan Hu aren't very good, which amazingly allows Fei Long to pretty much catch all the way up, but Zhan Hu is still able to win the challenge, it's just a lot closer than you'd expect. Probably a 3/5 challenge most seasons, but Courney moves it up a point!

4/5

episode 4 reward challenge

Great Balls of Fire Skill

NIGHT TIME CHALLENGE! CHINESE CULTURE! UNNECESSARY FLASHINESS! It's like they designed this challenge specifically to appeal to me. There is so much to talk about here, and I'm worried I won't be able to do this challenge justice. Let's just break it down one piece at a time, and let's start with the title of the challenge. It's named after a song, which you've likely heard before, Great Balls Of Fire by Jerry Lee Lewis. I point this out, because another thing that's interesting to track about Survivor challenges is that they become increasingly named after songs of the 20th century, and I think it would be fun to actually track which songs get subtly referenced by Survivor in this way. I think this is largely because the head of the challenge team, John Kirhoffer loves his music; he is especially fond of metal groups, which will become evident in many future challenge names. This definitely isn't the first challenge to be named after a song, but now's as good a time as any to start paying attention to which challenges are! Alright, next, and just to reiterate, NIGHT TIME CHALLENGE! I love night time challenges, as I've expressed time and time again throughout this series. This is the first night time challenge to appear since "Q and A" all the way back in Survivor: The Amazon, and this is the last night time challenge we are going to get until Survivor: Cambodia! That's a long time from now! And please note, when I say that, I am not counting challenges like Bob-Bob Buoy that start during the day and only go into the night because they last so long, or challenges that take place at Tribal Council simply because of a double elimination, à la Redemption Island and South Pacific. Night time challenges are simply beautiful to look at, and beautiful because of the variety they add to the show. In a way, I almost like how they are uncommon. Don't get me wrong, right now they are way, way, too uncommon, but if they did them every season, I probably wouldn't get so excited over them. But this challenge takes the beauty a step further, and adds fireworks into the mix. Yes, this is a Survivor challenge that involves igniting fireworks and watching them explode in radiant colors in the night sky. It is absolutely amazing. On one hand, you have the inherent wow factor. Much like when they use fireballs or replica machine guns, there is just something special to these types of really dramatic challenge props. To use that word "inherent" again, there is just something inherently epic about fireworks. They make extremely satisfying sounds as they launch into the sky, followed by an array of beautiful colors and finishing off with an even more satisfying boom, crackling sound. The fact that this was turned into a Survivor challenge is unbelievable. I'm telling you, the ambition production had with this season is astounding. There's a reason people consider Survivor: China the start of the "Golden Age" of Survivor, and although I don't think everyone realizes it, a lot of what helps make it give that impression is production, which played almost as important a role as the cast did. But the fireworks aren't just there to be flashy— they also, geniously, play into Chinese culture and history. Fireworks are quintessentially Chinese; as a challenge later in the season points out, gunpowder was invented in China, and if you close your eyes and imagine a Chinese festival, you can't tell me fireworks aren't a part of that vision. The inclusion of fireworks isn't the only example of Chinese culture being incorporated into the challenge; there is another, somewhat silly way they also do it, and it involves the actual rules of the challenge. You see, the goal is, in teams of two, two transport a fireball across a clearing and drop it into a wok, a bowl used for Chinese cooking. And how do you transport the fireball to the wok? A giant pair of chopsticks. Yes, even the culinary aspects of Chinese culture will not go unappreciated by Survivor: China. The challenge itself is a great test of coordination between tribemates. A tribe needs to transport three fireballs to win the challenge, and every time a fireball is successfully brought to the wok, the challenge becomes more difficult, because the chopsticks become longer. Ultimately, Fei Long wins this challenge, and get to enjoy the best post-challenge celebration of all time, as a whole bunch of fireworks are set off at the same time, lighting up the skies and making that exciting sound that makes me wish it were Independence Day right now. What I really love is when Jeff does the thing with his arms to say "FEI LONG, wins reward!" A firework booms at the exact moment he does that, and you can even see his face flash red from the reflection of it. Listen everyone... this is about as good as a Survivor challenge can get. For as much as I enjoyed it in this season, I would absolutely lose my mind if they surprised me and brought it back for a future season. Like, I wouldn't even be able to process what I was seeing. Preferably, Survivor challenge team, bring it back in the second half of a 2 hour episode so I don't get spoiled about its existence from the press photos and it really catches me off guard. Please?!

5/5

episode 4 immunity challenge

Warriors' Duel Skill

Jeff begins explaining the rules of this challenge by telling the contestants that they will be wearing traditional Chinese armor "for their own protection." Survivor: China, you've got to stop! I can't only take so many awesome challenges in one season! And this is only episode 4?!!! So yes, we can obviously check the culture box for this challenge, and it is a really cool implementation. The challenge takes place in a "gladiator arena" (is Survivor allowed to sound this grand?!), and each tribe has a number of porcelain vases perched up on narrow podiums. Of course, this is also a culture thing; porcelain is famously a Chinese material. Each tribe has three meteor hammers, which they swing and throw across the arena to try and knock down the other tribe's vases. Two things; first, this is, of course, another culture thing, as meteor hammers are ancient Chinese weapons. Second, and I cannot stress this enough, HOW?!!! Like really, how did this challenge actually happen? I mean, think of the journey this idea must have gone on. First, someone actually had to have the idea for this challenge, and even if you put the ambitiousness of the idea aside, it is a very creative concept, even more so by the amount of different elements of Chinese culture they are able to squeeze into it. Then, this idea actually had to be approved, which I feel like is a miracle in itself. Again, meteor hammers are weapons. The castaways are essentially playing a culture shock version of dodgeball. When a vase is shattered, paint spills out of it which matches its respective tribe color, which is a great detail. Each tribe has a designated defender that can try and block the meteor hammers being thrown at them with a bamboo pole, and I don't even have to say anything about that one; even a five year old would notice the fun incorporation of Chinese culture. There are three rounds to this challenge. One round has two men on a team, the second round has two women on a team, and the final round has one man and one woman. Whichever tribe cumulatively breaks the most vases of the other team wins the challenge. This challenge is another example of the editors having fun, trying out some new styles. Here, we get consistent, slowed down shots of the meteor hammers flying through the air, just before they smash into a vase. Again, I like it, it's fun. Ultimately, Fei Long wins this challenge which was nothing short of entertaining and exciting.

5/5

episode 5 immunity challenge

Plunge, Pull, Pop Physical Race / Mental

We're headed back to the water for a pretty interesting Immunity Challenge! Each tribe selects two members to swim out to a pontoon which they must climb, and then dive into the water to pull bamboo poles out of a cage (A nod to the season's location, yay!). Releasing these poles allows a bunch of light puzzle discs to rise to the surface of the cage, where they can be collected and brought back to the beach. Each puzzle disc represents one of the Chinese zodiac symbols (a nod to the season's location's culture, awesome!). I quite like this idea of removing blockades from a cage so that the objects inside the cage can float to the top. It's pretty creative and is also challenging. Both tribes were able to find success at this portion, and there is a fun Courtney moment where she yells "Go Jean-Robert!" and then turns to Amanda and says "it broke a little bit of my heart to say that." The real story to track during this challenge though is Zhan Hu's plan to throw the challenge. In case you forgot, earlier in this episode there was a tribe switch where each tribe got to choose two members from the opposite tribe to switch over, and Zhan Hu chose James and Aaron. Peih-Gee and Jaime realized that they could even out their tribe's numbers going into the Merge if they threw the next two challenges to eliminate James and Aaron. Peih-Gee and Jaime don't tell the rest of their tribe they were doing this, and James becomes increasingly frustrated with their attitude throughout the challenge. First, while Erik and Aaron, the tribe's divers, are out at their pontoon, Jaime yells over to them, telling them to slow down for a bit and get their breath back. "Wait a minute... wait a long minute," Jaime says, and then she starts giggling, which really peeves James, who calls the girls children and tells them to focus. Once the divers get all of their discs, they have to place them in a boat and drag the boat back to shore. Zhan Hu gets to this point with a slight lead over Fei Long, and Jean-Robert almost knocks all of the discs into the water, but it was just a close call. When Zhan Hu's pieces arrive at shore, Jaime, with no one looking, picks up one of the pieces and throws it off to the side, and let me tell you, this was a memorable moment. Never before in Survivor had we seen such a blatant self-sabotage in a Survivor challenge. The puzzle itself is pretty simple, it's sort of like a jigsaw puzzle but inverted, where the spaces the pieces fit into are sticking out of the board. Each disc can only fit into a specific place, so the tribe just needs to figure out where all of the pieces go. Fei Long is able to get their puzzle going without much struggle, but over at the Fei Long table, Jaime and Peih-Gee are working very slowly, and Jeff actually calls them out on it. "You'd never know there was anything on the line," Jeff muses. James continues to get frustrated, and at one point, Jeff asks Peih-Gee if she's good at puzzles, and Peih-Gee replies cheeringly, "I'm good at sudoku!" This prompts a comical reaction from James, "oh f*** sudoku, pay attention!" Suffice it to say, Fei Long wins this challenge. I'm very high on this one; it has a very memorable design, as well as a very memorable moment, regardless of how you felt about that moment when originally watching this season.

4/5


episode 6 reward challenge

Search & Decode Physical Race / Mental

This next challenge is a throwback to Survivor: Borneo! The Survivor Wiki does not concede, but Jeff says it himself in a behind the scenes video. This is clearly inspired by the "Abandoned Barracks" challenge from season 1, which was played at night, and in which the teams had to race into an abandoned building collecting specific materials. I always thought that was a cool idea for a challenge, and I especially loved the night time factor, but I had some issues with how that challenge was shot in that season. I think the idea was just a bit too ambitious for a show in its first season, still figuring out the best way to capture challenges in a way that the audience could easily understand what was happening. Fast forward fourteen seasons, and I think they've nailed it. It's not played at night this time, which is a bit disappointing, but I think it is ultimately a lot better than Borneo's version for a few reasons, most notably because by now, Survivor knows how to record a challenge relatively flawlessly. I also appreciate the cultural aspect here. There wasn't a ton of symbolism the abandoned barrock we say in Borneo, but here, the players are raiding an abandoned Chinese village. I'm assuming this is an actual abandoned village production found, because I don't think they built an entire village for a five minute Survivor challenge, and that is super awesome. There are some other changes from Borneo as well. For one, there is now a puzzle at the end, which is pretty par for the course by now, but this puzzle is actually very inventive. Essentially, each tribe has a checkerboard-shaped puzzle, where half of the tiles have a letter on them, but the other half are blank. To solve the puzzle and decode the phrase, you need to slide puzzle planks, which have letters of their own, into the puzzle, until you end up with actual words that can be read vertically. Of course, there are many possible ways to arrange the planks, but most arrangements would just spell out gibberish. It's a compelling challenge that you have to find the one exact combination that makes sense. But where do those planks come from? Well, that's the second big change. Instead of searching for random objects, the players are now looking for bundles of planks. As interesting as the original, random ideas version was in its own, charming Survivor: Borneo way, I definitely think making all of the objects the same is a good way of streamlining the challenge and making it easier to follow as a viewer. The challenge ends up being very fun to watch; it's kind of surreal to see a challenge primarily take place inside a building, but I love that kind of unique stuff. We actually see some strategy going on mid-challenge as well, as this challenge offers members from the opposing tribes to mingle with relative secrecy. Peih-Gee reassures Sherea that they are still together, hoping that she doesn't flip. Of course, this conversation isn't really going to matter since Sherea gets voted out this episode, but it's still cool to see. Fei Long ends up winning. While this really isn't the most electric challenge, it is so unique and had so much effort put into it that I wouldn't be comfortable giving it anything below a perfect score.

5/5

episode 6 immunity challenge

Survivor Smorgasbord Miscellaneous Challenge

Food eating challenge! By now you know I love these, and unsurprisingly enough, China's version is very good. It is the same format as Fiji's version we saw last season– timed trials in a team format. The challenge begins with Jeff telling the players they are about to eat some traditional Chinese dishes, that are "anything but pleasant." I've gotta be honest, I do find this somewhat off-putting. Usually, Jeff is a lot more respectful about the food they are eating. Most of the time he says something like "these are all actual foods that the people here have been eating for centuries, it's entirely normal." I don't think it's right to call another culture's traditional cuisine outright "unpleasant." I have seen some people criticize the food eating challenge before because they see it as the show ogling over how gross other culture's foods are, but I typically give the challenge the benefit of the doubt. Usually I see it less as the show mocking other culture's cuisine, and more so the show mocking us childish little Americans for being so squeamish over foods that are entirely normal in other parts of the world. That case doesn't really hold up though when Jeff just comes right out and describes the food as objectively disgusting. It isn't a big deal to me, just something I felt compelled to point out. Anyway, because we are in such a unique location as China, we end up with some of the most unique foods this challenge has ever seen, so let's break down each round one at a time. The first item is entirely new to the challenge, chicken hearts. To quote Jeff himself, they certainly do look unpleasant to me. Frosti wins this round, and he even licks his plate afterwards. The second round is eel, which is probably the easiest item of this challenge. I always feel like the sea creatures, as long as they don't sound too exotic, would be the least intimidating to eat, because there is a degree of normalcy surrounding them. There are plenty seafood lovers in the West! Jaime wins this round, and we see Courtney slowly spit all of her eel out, which, there is a part of me that wishes the editors neglected including this visual in the episode, but alrighty! For me, the third round would be by far the most challenging. Baby turtles! Turtles are so cute, how could you eat one? It's made a lot worse by the fact that the baby turtles look exactly like baby turtles, as if they could just wake up from a nap at any moment; it's not like the chicken heart, for example, which doesn't really resemble anything as you are eating it. Erik wins this round! The next round, James vs Denise, is the most interesting though, because once again, strategy is colliding with Survivor challenges. You see, Fei Long has this plan where they gave James a hidden Immunity Idol while he was kidnapped, and now they want Zhan Hu to go to tribal council where James would play his idol, blindsiding his new tribemates. It's a pretty great strategy, but it doesn't quite pan out. As James is in on the plan, he knows that he needs to throw the challenge and let Denise score a point to ensure his tribe goes to tribal council. The problem is, this round is balut, and Denise absolutely cannot get hers down. Those guys in Survivor: Palau made it look so easy, didn't they, Denise?! James waits as long as he can without looking extremely suspicious, but at a certain point, he just has to finish his balut, spoiling Fei Long's plans as Zhan Hu takes the lead 3-1. The next round is also the last round, as Frosti wins and scores Zhan Hu's winning point. This item is a "thousand-year-old egg," and if you're anything like me, your first reaction to this was something like "wait, what?! Doesn't this egg belong in a museum?!" But it turns out that, and what the show never actually tells us for some reason, is that the name of this food is a bit of a misnomer. These eggs actually take about a few weeks to a few months, depending on the method, to make, and are not, in fact, relics from an ancient time during which dynasties ruled and the iPhone didn't even exist yet.

4/5

episode 7 immunity challenge

Feast Memory Mental

We are kicking off the Merge with a purely mental challenge, now that's a change of pace! In addition to their Merge feast, the Survivors are rewarded with an awesome Chinese performance rich with talent and culture. It's a great, impactful scene, and is the type of treat you could only expect to see in one of these older, culture-focused seasons like Survivor: China. We get some fun confessionals from Courtney at the start of the feast, as she "boos" traditional challenges and excites over alcoholic beverages. This entire ceremony is preceded by an ominous note from Jeff though— this game never stops. No one is quite sure what to make of this, but it all makes sense later that day when Jeff shows up to Hae Da Fung to host the Immunity challenge right there at camp. I'm immediately reminded of the scene in Survivor: Island of the Idols when Jeff shows up to the Lumuwaku camp to announce Dan had been ejected, and Lauren gives a confessional saying that this is strange, Jeff never just shows up to camp. Well hold on there Lauren, are you forgetting about the first Immunity Challenge after the Merge in Survivor: China? And you call yourself a fan?!!! But okay, let's see here. Jeff is going to ask some trivia questions about the performance they just saw. The entire thing is very Big Brother-esque; the players watch a little performance or video, and then they are quizzed about it. The format is even similar, where one incorrect answer means you are out of the challenge. The questions themselves are pretty tricky from the audience's perspective, which I'm not a big fan of. If you were actually there, then sure, you may subconsciously remember what the centerpiece was on the table, but I only saw two minutes of the ceremony and I wasn't looking at the table, I was watching the performance. I think it would have helped if the show had more explicitly clued the audience in about the fact that there would be a quiz afterwards. With that all being said, I'm a bit conflicted about how to score this challenge. If they were planning on doing a ceremony all along and then just tacked this Immunity Challenge on at the end, I don't really find it all that impressive. However, if they did this whole ceremony specifically because they had this challenge idea, then huge respect from me, that is an amazing amount of effort for one little challenge. There's really no way of knowing, but I'm thinking I'll settle on a middle-of-the-road score for this challenge.

3/5

episode 8 reward challenge

The Bucket Stops Here Miscellaneous Challenge

My favorite challenge from Survivor: Pearl Islands has returned! And for the last time, sadly to say. This challenge is just such a fun, awesome idea. Sink the other tribe's boat. Now I will say straight up, this version isn't as good as the Pearl Islands version. They made some pretty major changes to the format, and I think they are for the worse. Still, it is a greatly engaging, unique challenge, and another one of the few challenges this season out on the water. So, let's compare the two versions. In Survivor: Pearl Islands, there was one large, square-shaped arena, and each tribe had two boats, each with three people on board. To sink the other tribe's boats, you would use grappling hooks, which were multi-purpose. You could either use them to uncork plugs in the boats, allowing water to start spilling in, or, you could use them to press down on the other tribe's boats, allowing a whole bunch of water to spill in. It was extremely intense, and it perfectly fit that season's pirate theme. In this season, the format has completely changed. Now, there are two separate, smaller arenas, surrounded by wooden framing. Each tribe chooses one person, presumingly their lightest member, to get into a boat, and then members from the opposite tribe, standing on the wooden framing, use buckets to bail as much water into the boat as they can, as quickly as possible. This means that the person in the boat's sole objective is survival. They can use their hands to try and paddle further away from the bucket wielders, but that's about it. Again, it isn't as dramatic as what we saw in Pearl Islands, but it is still a great, refreshing challenge. If something like this appeared in modern Survivor, I would flip out, because it's such a cool, unique idea among so many challenges that feel a bit "samey." That's something I have been doing throughout this whole series, by the way; I imagine how the challenge would rank if it appeared in modern Survivor, because doing that can give a sense of clarity to just how unique a certain challenge is. When a challenge is in Survivor: China, it is surrounded by a bunch of other phenomenal challenges which could distract you from how great a specific challenge is on its own, but stepping back and looking at the bigger picture helps me give a more accurate sense of a challenge's quality.

4/5

episode 8 immunity challenge

Dragon Rider Endurance

I absolutely love this challenge. I nominate this challenge for "Best Culturally-Inspired Endurance Challenge," "Coolest-Looking Endurance Challenge," and "Most Creative Endurance Challenge." Whether this challenge definitively wins any of those titles is entirely up for debate, but the fact that I can nominate it for all three speaks for itself. It is a beautiful design; a colorful, twisty dragon on which this challenge entirely takes place. I really love how everyone shares the same set piece. Like, in most endurance challenges, everyone has their own little station, but I think it's really cool how in this one, everyone shares one giant station, each with their own little section. The fact that the "giant station" is a huge, cool-looking dragon is just bonus points. The way it works is, each person has to balance on a designated segment of the dragon, which are actually camouflaged barrels. At the start of the challenge, the barrels are full of water, so it isn't difficult to keep your balance; any subtle movements from your body wouldn't actually have much effect on the barrel with so much added weight from the water. However, there is a hole in the barrel through which water slowly drips out (kind of like Fiji's Final Immunity Challenge), which causes the challenge to naturally become a lot more difficult over time. I love how creative this is, and I also love the uniqueness of the challenge constantly getting more difficult, rather than only after predetermined intervals of elapsed time. I also love that Courtney wins! In the words of Sandra Diaz-Twine, you go girl! Obviously this challenge is easier for lighter contestants, but that's completely fine, other challenges are better for other body types. As long as it's not the Final Immunity Challenge, I really don't care at all. There is also a great moment here which I'm sure is in one of those "Jeff Probst Sass Compilation" videos, where Jean-Robert declares that his barrel isn't balanced properly, and Jeff responds "Glad you're still around Jean-Robert. Always need a complainer." Courtney thought she was the complainer!

5/5

episode 9 reward challenge

Drum Roll Skill

Oh maaaaan, am I the only one who really loves this one? I don't know, it's just, I don't think I ever seen someone bring up this challenge in conversation, even when listing examples of how great the challenges in this season are. Simple but effective strikes again; each team member carries a different sized Chinese drum, and they have to work together to bounce a ball to the finish without letting it hit the ground. The first team to score two points wins. And I have to say, while the Merge Immunity Challenge reminded me of Big Brother, this challenge gives me some giddy, The Amazing Race vibes. This feels like it could be a Detour or something, and let me make this clear, that's a great thing; I love that show! The drums make really satisfying sounds as the balls bounce across them, and the course is interesting. I just want to get a group of friends together and try this out for myself, it looks so fun. I actually don't have that much to say about it (shocking, right?!), it's just a great challenge.

4/5

episode 9 immunity challenge

Chinese Zodiac Symbols Mental

Here we go, we finally have a Survivor: China challenge that will go on to become a sort-of Survivor classic! That's something I've noticed about this season; there are a lot of awesome new challenges, but most of them do not return more than once, or at all. It's a shame, but let's appreciate what we've got, and what we've got here is a great memory challenge! One of my favorites! A while ago, I commented that the generic memory match challenge was kind of meh, nothing special, and that later on, Survivor would introduce a much better memory challenge. This is the challenge I was talking about. Basically, a Survivor version of Simon. Jeff gives you a series of symbols or colors, and you have to repeat them back to him. The exact presentation can differ from season to season, but the format stays the same. The presentation in this challenge's debut season is probably the best, because it's Survivor: China, of course this version is going to go above and beyond. We are once again paying homage to the Chinese zodiac symbols (the literal name of this challenge), in that the symbols Jeff reads out are different animals from the Chinese zodiac. What's really good though is how you repeat the sequence back to Jeff. Each person has a table in front of them with different tiles representing different animals, and you have to use a knife to stab the tiles in the correct order. To see if you are right, Jeff simply slides the tiles off the knife and determines whether they are correct. It's such a novel way of approaching this game, and a little bit of unnecessary flashiness, which is always a good thing. What I really love about this challenge is that you can participate from home. This is the quintessential audience-can-play-too challenge. We've seen other challenges where the audience can play along, like Survivor Quiz Show, but let's be real, we are guessing most of the time. This is great though, not only can you play along, but it is so satisfying when you know someone else answered incorrectly before Jeff tells them. Overall, a wonderful challenge, perhaps the best memory challenge to appear on the show? I think so, at least, until Survivor: One World... To Be Continued.

4/5

episode 11 reward challenge

Confucius Said Mental

Wait, did you think when I said "To Be Continued" I was talking about that interesting memory challenge from Survivor: One World, whatever it may be? How foolish of you! I was clearly building up suspense for this next challenge here in Survivor: China, which was absolutely befitting of a "To Be Continued." Yes, in case you forgot, CBS really made sure that everyone was on the edge of their seat going into this episode. In fact, this has to be the most dramatic lead-in to a challenge of all time. Let's just break this down for a moment, because it's absolutely hilarious. Going all the way back to episode 8 (we're in episode 11 now!!), we get to the end of tribal council, and okay, let's see the coming attractions for next week. Next time on Survivor... wait, what's this? "We have more business to attend to here..." Wow, there's going to be a big twist in the next episode! Okay, so flash forward a week, I wonder what it could be. Maybe a Cook Islands style double elimination? Well hold on just a minute, let's put on our thinking caps here. This is a 16 person season which likely has a Final 3, they wouldn't eliminate 2 people in one episode, right?! So what could it be... we get to the end of the episode and— To Be Continued. You've got to be kidding, so close! Alright, next week then... Alright, here we are, a full second week later, heading into episode 10, and finally, the big surprise twist is..... Oh, it's a recap episode. Forgot they did those... Like, there's just no way. I did not get to experience this season live and that may actually be a blessing, because this would have driven be absolutely crazy. And then we finally get to episode 11, and what is the big surprise? A Reward Challenge. I think production just "baited" us, and... again, I think it's quite funny. But I digress, let's talk about this challenge, the return of Survivor Quiz Show, actually not using the coconut chop format this time, for the first time since Africa, and actually, this is the first time since Borneo that they did this challenge without the coconut chop format and as an individual challenge. I don't have a lot to say here, it's a good challenge, the audience can play, it highlights some of the culture and history of the location... it's good, I just... they hyped this up for 3 entire weeks, I can't get over how funny that is.

3/5


episode 11 immunity challenge

Star Struck Skill

Here's an interesting precision-based challenge. Each person gets three metal stars which they throw at a target, trying to score as many points as they can. The top three finishers move on to a "sudden death round," where each person only gets one metal star, and whoever scores highest with that wins the challenge. It's quite enjoyable to watch, and there is some obvious culture here, as "shurikens" do invoke a Chinese image, although they are actually much more prominent in Japanese culture. I do find the targets to be an interesting choice; they aren't traditional, circular-shaped target boards. Instead, they are sort of abstract, silhouettes of people in various poses holding a sword. You know what, I like weird, so I'm a fan. The challenge plays out in a somewhat interesting way; instead of a top three, there ends up being a four-way tie between James, Courtney, Amanda, and Erik. In the final round, Erik wins the challenge.

3/5

episode 12 reward challenge

Marco Polo Physical Race

The loved ones have made it to China, and much like for the previous Loved Ones Visit in Cook Islands, Survivor has cooked up a challenge that the players and loved ones compete in together. I like when this happens, and I think the challenge is pretty interesting, if only a bit short for my taste. Everyone is blindfolded, and each player starts on opposite ends of a maze from their loved one. The pairs have to find each other by communicating to one another, and the first pair to reunite and make it to the center of the maze wins the challenge. The maze is kind of cool; the center has a yin and yang symbol, something you may be familiar with from either Ancient Chinese philosophy, the Heroes vs Villains merge tribe name, or that one level in Peggle. We see a pretty interesting strategy from Amanda and her sister. They make bird noises that sound eerily realistic, which helps them block out other voices as they attempt to find one another. In the end though, Denise and her husband are the first to meet up, and they are also the first to make it to the center, winning them the challenge.

3/5

episode 12 immunity challenge

Swamp Donkeys Physical Race / Mental

So next we have what is probably my least favorite challenge of the season. It isn't a bad challenge, I just don't think it has much going for it, memorability-wise or design-wise. The design is very strange. That isn't to say that strange ideas are inherently bad, sometimes they work out amazingly, but I just don't think this challenge's set-up clicks. It's sort of like a combination of Around the Bend and that challenge from The Amazon that involved paddling out to read a trivia question about the location. Each player races out, attached to a rope, which is looped around a few logs, so you need to untangle yourself from those. Once you get to the end, you open a box, revealing a true or false question about Chinese inventions. Sort of like in Folklore, you have to grab a key from the option that represents what you think the correct answer is, and bring it back to the start, hoping you are correct. I guess it's a decent set-up, I don't know exactly what it is... I just don't find the challenge to be super engaging. One thing I really like about this challenge though, is the ending. Peih-Gee really needs to win immunity, and she is right behind Todd with her last key. Todd gets back first, but he is wrong, allowing Peih-Gee to come in and win. It's a very satisfying ending to an overall, alright challenge.

2/5

episode 13 reward challenge

Zen Archery Skill

Next up, we have another precision-based challenge, with a format that I actually think is really cool. It's entirely one-off, and I never see anyone talking about it, but I think it's worth discussing. This challenge is like the one from Survivor: Palau with the replica World War II gun, but this time, to fit China, it is a 4th-century repeating crossbow, which is definitely a great touch. The interesting thing though, is that not everyone gets the same amount of shots. Before the challenge starts, each person is given 5 arrows, which they must then give, secretly, to the other players. They can approach this anyway they want, be it giving all of their arrows to a single person, or dividing them equally. I just find this to be seriously interesting. It's a Reward Challenge, so I see no problem giving some players advantages over others, and this opens the door to a lot of interesting strategies. If you are confident that everyone has an equal chance to win, then it makes sense to divide them equally. What we see in Survivor: China though, and what I find fascinating, is that the players award the vast majority of their arrows to Courtney, someone who they were confident would not win. This is very interesting, they are essentially trying to eliminate any player having an advantage by piling their extra arrows onto someone who they believe has almost no chance at winning no matter how many arrows they get. But it is a double-edged sword, because Courtney ends up with so many arrows that she actually does become a huge threat to win the challenge. I just love all of the possible strategies. You could also, theoretically, try to give all of your arrows to the best competitor, to ensure they win, most likely not because you are dying to see them win, but because you are trying to ensure someone else, possibly the target for the next tribal council, does not. Rewards can fuel you for the Immunity Challenge, so I think this strategy could make a lot of sense, especially if the best competitor is in your alliance. This type of format also rewards players with good social games, and much like the coconut-chop format, the players on the outs don't have much of a chance. Peih-Gee ends up with only a single arrow, a generous donation from Courtney. It isn't "fair," but it does have the capacity to potentially reveal the pecking order, which might give the person on the outs something to capitalize on. Again, it's pretty similar to the coconut-chop format. Denise even spells it out. She only gets two arrows, and declares out loud that she is on the bottom of the totem pole, which is a very bad strategy in my opinion, but it's okay, we have a better Denise coming in 10 seasons. Now, let's get to the shooting part. While I compared the shooting element to the "Shooting Gallery" challenge from Survivor: Palau, the actual format more closely resembles a different challenge from that season, "Kamikaze." That was the challenge where you had to throw balls at a grid of names, trying to smash your own tiles, but knowing full well it was possible to accidently smash someone else's. Here, you are shooting your arrows at a similar grid of names, where you are aiming for your own tiles, but you can certainly miss and award points to your opponents. One unique thing about this challenge's format is that players do not take turns. Instead, the person with the least amount of arrows fires all of their arrows, and then the person with the next least amount goes, and so on, until we get to Courtney, who fires an absolute barrage of arrows, one after the next. Courtney is bad at this, as her tribemates expected, but it opens up a bit of a unique problem that they didn't see coming. See, Courtney's aim is terrible, and it turns into a very funny scene of Courtney's arrows just going all over the place, randomly awarding points to her competitors. This is especially troublesome for Todd, who had a nice lead going into this final round, which he had earned by doing a great job on his turn, but which he steadily loses as Courtney's arrows continue to hit other people's tiles. After an amazing back and forth, the score ends up tied between Denise and Todd, and Courtney is down to her last arrow. It is a total Mario Party "chance time" at this point as to who is going to win, but Denise amazingly ends up getting the final point, someone who only had two arrows to begin with. I just love this challenge's format and the comical way it actually plays out, so yes, another perfect score from me.

5/5

episode 13 immunity challenge

Chinese Leftovers Skill / Miscellaneous Challenge / Physical Race / Mental

After a bit of a break between Survivor: Cook Islands and Survivor: Fiji, the Survivor Pentathlon is back! A second chance at challenge elements from earlier in the season, and as per usual, I love this trip down memory lane. I also love that they called this version "Chinese Leftovers," it's such a silly name. The first round is a fairly recent throwback, it's the return of the shuriken-throwing challenge. The second round is eating balut, and once again, I really like it when they incorporate the food eating challenge into the Survivor Pentathlon. And of course, this is bad news for Denise, who essentially quits at this part of the challenge. The third round is really fun, it's the return of the "Drum Roll" challenge, but this time, it's everyone for themselves, no teams. I like seeing this spin on the challenge, it's a blast from the past that still manages to be something new. The final round goes all the way back to the "Blade Runner" challenge with chopping the rope and solving the disc puzzle, and sadly, Courtney does not make it to this round, but she does give a funny little reaction to this part as Jeff is explaining the rules of the challenge. Also sadly, the editors do not bring back the dramatic slow motion shots when someone breaks through a rope, but it's still enjoyable to watch, I guess. Amanda ends up winning this challenge.

4/5

episode 14 reward challenge

Great Wall of Zhelin Physical Race / Mental

The final Reward Challenge of the season is a big one. It's an obstacle course that is impressive in size, pays homage to the location, and has some fun, unique elements. The lead-in to the challenge is very clever. It starts by showing the actual Great Wall of China, and then shades to the fake Wall of China used in this Reward Challenge, which isn't quite as impressive as the real thing, but I think it is still pretty impressive for a Survivor challenge. They didn't build this in a day, I can tell you that. The players all start on the wall, and they have to climb down, cross a bridge, and then reach a second bridge, which they have to fill in before they can cross it. It's a puzzle bridge! Once they reach the end, they find a traditional Chinese yoke; hooray for culture! They use the yoke to transport semi-large puzzle blocks all the way back to the Great Wall, which looks exhausting, especially considering this will likely take multiple trips. Once all of the puzzle pieces are back, the puzzle is solved, and it's another pretty cool puzzle. It's one of those 3-dimensional block puzzles that looks like it would be really tricky, and the puzzle is actually a part of the wall, which is very neat. It's definitely a solid challenge overall, even if nothing super memorable happens during it. On its own, it's probably a 3/5 challenge, but all of the cultural stuff definitely bumps it up for me.

4/5

episode 14 final immunity challenge

Broken China Endurance

And finally, the last Immunity Challenge of the season: Broken China. This is the challenge where everyone has to balance porcelain dishes on a wobbly balancing arm, and the last person to not let their dishes fall and shatter wins the challenge. Throughout the challenge, Jeff will continuously tell the players which type of dish they have to add to their stack next. I'll just go out and say it, I love this endurance challenge too. It's not as good as "Dragon Rider," but I can safely say that both of this season's endurances challenges are well above average. I like this challenge for a few reasons. First, I think it's one of the most balanced Final Immunity Challenges we've had in a long time. It's less about strength and more about focus, sort of harkening back to the Hands on a Hard Idol days, only a lot more difficult. It's also very unique, I think it's interesting having Jeff constantly being involved in the challenge, telling them which dish is next. The challenge is also delightfully nerve-racking, especially once the stack of dishes becomes very high. The fact that in this season, it comes down to Denise vs Amanda is especially good, because we all know that Denise needs to win this or she is probably going to be voted out, so it's great that she makes it to the end of the challenge and isn't first out or something. When someone loses their balance, all of their dishes fall to the ground and make that quintessential "whoops." sound, of shattering dishware, and it is excruciatingly satisfying. There is also culture here, because, as established earlier, porcelain was invented in China. I mean, they call it "china" for a reason! Eventually, Denise tries to make a deal with Amanda, but Amanda refuses to consider one. I really like how she tries to spin it around on Denise, like "Come on, Denise, you're not a quitter!" Even though it is very obvious she is actually refusing the deal because she wants to vote Denise out. Then, as we get near the end of the challenge, Amanda begins to try out a very interesting strategy. Instead of conventionally stacking her dishes face-up, she realizes that it may be easier to stack them upside-down. I love this move so much. It is very risky on her part; it's not like she's practiced and knows for sure this will work. For all she knows, this could somehow cause everything to fall apart. But she goes for it, and it pays off! Denise ultimately loses her stack, and Amanda wins the Final Immunity Challenge of the season. Also, the location for this challenge is genuinely awesome. Look at the picture, need I elaborate?

4/5

Final Thoughts

Once again, the challenges this season were absolutely phenomenal. There were tons of new ideas, there were returning classics, but most importantly of all, this season's challenges represented China. This season's challenges were one with their location, and it was magical. It is genuinely surreal to look through the list of challenges this season and realize that almost every single one makes at least some nod to Chinese history or Chinese culture. Like I said early on, the production value that went into this season was off the charts; one of the reasons Survivor: China is so good is because everyone who worked on it clearly poured their hearts and souls into making it the best it could be, and it was a privilege to go through each challenge and acknowledge the hard work that went into them. And here is a shocking development— when I averaged the scores for this season, I was amazed to see we have a tie! It turns out that both this season and Cook Islands came down to 93 total points divided by 23 challenges. I wasn't exactly sure how to handle this; I really didn't want any ties in the ranking. I decided to just go with what my gut was telling me, and my gut is that I prefer Survivor: China's challenges ever so slightly. This was a real Ghost Island situation! Thanks for reading, everyone!

Average Challenge Score: 4.04

Ranking Overall So Far: 2/15

If you have any comments, questions, feedback, or just want to reach out to me, send an email to cadebw2@gmail.com!