1941-42
Prophetstown 7-0
Annawan 5-2
Hillsdale 5-2
Erie 4-3
Cordova 2-4
Lyndon 2-5
Tampico 1-5
Port Byron 1-6
1943-44
Prophetstown 7-0
Annawan 6-1
Erie 5-2
Cordova 4-3
Lyndon 2-4
Tampico 2-5
Hillsdale 1-6
Port Byron 0-6
1944-45
Erie 7-0
Cordova 6-2
Prophetstown 6-3
Annawan 4-4
Lyndon 4-4
Atkinson 3-4
Hillsdale 2-5
Port Byron 1-5
Tampico 0-5
1945-46
Erie 8-1
Prophetstown 6-1
Atkinson 6-2
Port Byron 5-3
Annawan 2-4
Hillsdale 2-4
Cordova 2-5
Lyndon 0-8
Tampico 0-3
1946-47
Erie 7-1
Port Byron 7-1
Prophetstown 7-1
Atkinson 5-3
Cordova 4-4
Annawan 2-6
Tampico 2-6
Hillsdale 1-7
Lyndon 1-7
1947-48
Erie 8-0
Prophetstown 7-1
Atkinson 6-2
Port Byron 5-3
Annawan 4-4
Tampico 3-5
Cordova 1-7
Hillsdale 1-7
Lyndon 1-7
1948-49
Atkinson 9-0
Erie 6-2
Prophetstown 6-2
Port Byron 6-3
Tampico 6-3
Hillsdale 4-5
Annawan 3-5
Mineral 2-6
Cordova 1-8
Lyndon 0-9
1949-50
Erie 8-1
Port Byron 7-2
Prophetstown 7-2
Atkinson 6-3
Hillsdale 4-5
Tampico 4-5
Cordova 3-6
Mineral 3-6
Lyndon 2-7
Annawan 1-8
1950-51
Prophetstown 9-0
Erie 8-1
Hillsdale 6-3
Mineral 6-3
Lyndon 5-4
Port Byron 3-6
Annawan 2-7
Atkinson 2-7
Cordova 2-7
Tampico 2-7
1951-52
Mineral 8-1
Prophetstown 8-1
Erie 6-3
Annawan 4-5
Atkinson 4-5
Cordova 4-5
Hillsdale 3-6
Lyndon 3-6
Port Byron 3-6
Tampico 2-7
1952-53
Erie 9-0
Mineral 8-1
Prophetstown 7-2
Atkinson 5-4
Cordova 5-4
Tampico 5-4
Annawan 2-7
Lyndon 2-7
Port Byron 2-7
Hillsdale 0-9
1953-54
Erie 8-0
Lyndon 6-2
Tampico 6-2
Port Byron 5-3
Cordova 4-4
Prophetstown 3-5
Hillsdale 2-6
Annawan 1-7
Mineral 1-7
1954-55
Prophetstown 7-1
Port Byron 6-2
Erie 5-3
Lyndon 5-3
Tampico 5-3
Mineral 4-4
Cordova 2-6
Hillsdale 2-6
Annawan 0-8
1955-56
Prophetstown 7-0
Tampico 6-1
Erie 5-2
Port Byron 4-3
Mineral 3-4
Annawan 2-5
Lyndon 1-6
Hillsdale 0-7
1957-58
Erie 11-1
Port Byron 9-3
Prophetstown 9-3
Annawan 5-7
Mineral 3-9
Tampico 3-9
Lyndon 2-10