1959-60
Pittsfield 7-1
Brown County 6-2
Camp Point Central 5-3
Beardstown 2-6
Rushville 0-8
1960-61
Beardstown 7-1
Pittsfield 6-2
Camp Point Central 3-5
Brown County 2-6
Rushville 2-6
1961-62
Camp Point Central 6-2
Pittsfield 6-2
Beardstown 4-4
Rushville 4-4
Brown County 0-8
1962-63
Pittsfield 6-2
Rushville 6-2
Camp Point Central 5-3
Beardstown 3-5
Brown County 0-8
1963-64
Rushville 5-0
Camp Point Central 4-1
Mendon Unity 3-2
Beardstown 1-4
Brown County 1-4
Pittsfield 1-4
1964-65
Beardstown 4-1
Rushville 4-1
Camp Point Central 3-2
Pittsfield 2-3
Brown County 1-4
Mendon Unity 1-4
1965-66
Camp Point Central 4-1
Rushville 4-1
Beardstown 3-2
Pittsfield 3-2
Brown County 0-4
Mendon Unity 0-4
1966-67
Pittsfield 5-0
Rushville 3-2
Beardstown 2-3
Camp Point Central 2-3
Brown County 1-3
Mendon Unity 1-3
1967-68
Pittsfield 5-0
Beardstown 4-1
Rushville 3-2
Mendon Unity 2-3
Brown County 1-4
Camp Point Central 0-5
1968-69
Pittsfield 5-0
Camp Point Central 4-1
Beardstown 2-3
Mendon Unity 2-3
Rushville 2-3
Brown County 0-5
1969-70
Pittsfield 5-0
Beardstown 4-1
Brown County 3-2
Rushville 2-3
Mendon Unity 1-4
Camp Point Central 0-5
1970-71
Beardstown 5-0
Camp Point Central 3-2
Pittsfield 3-2
Brown County 2-3
Rushville 2-3
Mendon Unity 0-5