1949-50
Lanark 7-1
Oregon 6-2
Mount Morris 4-4
Polo 2-6
Mount Carroll 1-7
1950-51
Mount Morris 8-0
Lanark 4-4
Oregon 4-4
Polo 3-5
Mount Carroll 1-7
1952-53
Lanark 7-1
Mount Morris 7-1
Mount Carroll 4-4
Oregon 2-6
Polo 0-8
1953-54
Mount Morris 8-0
Oregon 5-3
Mount Carroll 4-4
Polo 3-5
Lanark 0-8
1954-55
Oregon 10-0
Mount Morris 8-2
Mount Carroll 4-6
Lanark 3-7
Milledgeville 3-7
Polo 2-8
1955-56
Oregon 10-0
Mount Morris 7-3
Mount Carroll 6-4
Milledgeville 4-6
Lanark 3-7
Polo 0-10
1956-57
Milledgeville 8-2
Oregon 7-3
Mount Carroll 6-4
Polo 5-5
Lanark 2-8
Mount Morris 2-8
1957-58
Milledgeville 9-1
Mount Carroll 6-4
Polo 6-4
Lanark 5-5
Oregon 4-6
Mount Morris 0-10
1958-59
Milledgeville 8-2
Oregon 7-3
Mount Carroll 6-4
Mount Morris 6-4
Polo 2-8
Lanark 1-9
1959-60
Erie 14-0
Mount Carroll 9-5
Oregon 8-6
Milledgeville 7-7
Mount Morris 7-7
Polo 5-9
Prophetstown 4-10
Lanark 2-12
1960-61
Prophetstown 13-1
Polo 12-2
Erie 9-5
Oregon 8-6
Milledgeville 7-7
Lanark 5-9
Mount Morris 2-12
Mount Carroll 1-13
1961-62
Prophetstown 14-0
Erie 10-4
Oregon 8-6
Mount Morris 7-7
Lanark 5-9
Polo 5-9
Milledgeville 4-10
Mount Carroll 3-11
1962-63
Erie 12-2
Prophetstown 11-3
Mount Morris 10-4
Oregon 9-5
Lanark 5-9
Mount Carroll 5-9
Polo 4-10
Milledgeville 0-14
1963-64
Erie 12-2
Mount Morris 11-3
Prophetstown 10-4
Oregon 8-6
Lanark 6-8
Mount Carroll 5-9
Polo 4-10
Milledgeville 0-14
1964-65
Mount Morris 11-3
Polo 10-4
Prophetstown 10-4
Erie 9-5
Oregon 8-6
Lanark 6-8
Milledgeville 2-12
Mount Carroll 0-14
1965-66
Erie 12-2
Polo 12-2
Oregon 10-4
Mount Morris 9-5
Lanark 5-9
Amboy 4-10
Mount Carroll 2-12
Prophetstown 2-12
1966-67
Erie 12-0
Oregon 10-2
Amboy 6-6
Polo 6-6
Mount Morris 5-7
Prophetstown 2-10
Mount Carroll 1-11
1967-68
Erie 10-2
Mount Morris 9-3
Polo 8-4
Amboy 7-5
Prophetstown 5-7
Oregon 2-10
Mount Carroll 1-11
1968-69
Erie 10-2
Mount Morris 10-2
Polo 10-2
Oregon 6-6
Amboy 2-10
Mount Carroll 2-10
Prophetstown 2-10
1969-70
Mount Morris 12-0
Prophetstown 9-3
Polo 8-4
Erie 5-7
Oregon 5-7
Amboy 2-10
Mount Carroll 1-11
1970-71
Mount Morris 12-0
Prophetstown 8-4
Oregon 7-4
Erie 6-6
Mount Carroll 3-8
Polo 3-9
Amboy 2-10
1971-72
Amboy 10-2
Oregon 10-2
Polo 7-5
Erie 6-6
Mount Morris 5-7
Prophetstown 3-9
Mount Carroll 1-11