1956-57
Glasford 7-1
LaFayette 6-2
Yates City 5-3
Brimfield 2-6
Williamsfield 0-8
1959-60
Brimfield 8-0
LaFayette 6-2
Williamsfield 4-4
Glasford 2-6
Yates City 0-8
1960-61
LaFayette 7-1
Brimfield 6-2
Williamsfield 5-3
Glasford 1-7
Yates City 1-7
1961-62
Williamsfield 8-0
LaFayette 4-4
Brimfield 3-5
Glasford 3-5
Yates City 2-6
1962-63
Williamsfield 5-3
Yates City 5-3
Glasford 4-4
LaFayette 4-4
Brimfield 2-6
1963-64
Glasford 7-1
Williamsfield 7-1
Yates City 3-5
Brimfield 2-6
LaFayette 1-7
1964-65
Williamsfield 8-0
Glasford 6-2
Brimfield 4-4
LaFayette 1-7
Yates City 1-7
1965-66
Brimfield 6-2
Williamsfield 6-2
Glasford 5-3
Yates City 3-5
LaFayette 0-8
1966-67
Brimfield 6-2
Williamsfield 6-2
Glasford 5-3
Yates City 2-6
LaFayette 1-7
1967-68
Brimfield 7-1
Glasford 7-1
Yates City 4-4
Williamsfield 2-6
LaFayette 0-8
1968-69
Glasford 6-0
Toulon 4-2
Williamsfield 4-2
Yates City 3-3
LaFayette 2-4
Brimfield 1-5
Elmwood 1-5
1969-70
Elmwood 6-0
Brimfield 4-2
Toulon 4-2
Illini Bluffs 3-3
Williamsfield 2-4
LaFayette 1-5
Yates City 1-5
1970-71
Illini Bluffs 5-0
Elmwood 3-2
Toulon-LaFayette 3-2
Williamsfield 3-2
Brimfield 1-4
Yates City 0-5
1971-72
Illini Bluffs 5-0
Elmwood 4-1
Williamsfield 3-2
Toulon-LaFayette 2-3
Brimfield 1-4
Yates City 0-5
1972-73
Elmwood 4-1
Toulon-LaFayette 4-1
Illini Bluffs 3-2
Williamsfield 2-3
Brimfield 1-4
Yates City 1-4
1973-74
Illini Bluffs 5-0
Elmwood 3-2
Yates City 3-2
Williamsfield 2-3
Brimfield 1-4
Toulon-LaFayette 1-4
1974-75
Illini Bluffs 5-0
Elmwood 4-1
Toulon-LaFayette 3-2
Williamsfield 2-3
Brimfield 1-4
Yates City 0-5
1975-76
Brimfield 4-1
Toulon-LaFayette 4-1
Elmwood 3-2
Williamsfield 3-2
Illini Bluffs 1-4
Yates City 0-5
1976-77
Brimfield 4-0
Elmwood 3-1
Williamsfield 2-2
Illini Bluffs 1-3
Yates City 0-4
1977-78
Brimfield 4-0
Elmwood 3-1
Illini Bluffs 2-2
Williamsfield 1-3
Yates City 0-4
1978-79
Brimfield 4-0
Elmwood 3-1
Illini Bluffs 2-2
Williamsfield 1-3
Yates City 0-4
1979-80
Elmwood 4-0
Brimfield 2-2
Illini Bluffs 2-2
Williamsfield 1-3
Yates City 1-3
1980-81
Illini Bluffs 4-0
Williamsfield 3-1
Brimfield 2-2
Yates City 1-3
Elmwood 0-4
1982-83
Elmwood 4-0
Illini Bluffs 3-1
Brimfield 2-2
Williamsfield 1-3
Yates City 0-4
1983-84
Elmwood 4-0
Illini Bluffs 3-1
Yates City 2-2
Brimfield 1-3
Williamsfield 0-4
1984-85
Brimfield 4-0
Williamsfield 3-1
Illini Bluffs 2-2
Yates City 1-3
Elmwood 0-4