1959-60
Galesburg 6-1
Pekin 5-2
Peoria Richwoods 4-3
Canton 3-4
East Peoria 3-5
Kewanee 0-6
1960-61
Galesburg 7-1
Peoria Richwoods 7-2
Canton 6-2
Limestone 5-4
East Peoria 3-6
Pekin 1-8
Kewanee 0-7
1961-62
Peoria Richwoods 8-1
Galesburg 7-1
Pekin 6-3
East Peoria 5-5
Kewanee 2-5
Limestone 2-7
Canton 0-9
1962-63
Galesburg 8-0
East Peoria 8-2
Limestone 7-2
Pekin 4-5
Peoria Richwoods 2-7
Kewanee 1-6
Canton 0-8
1963-64
Pekin 8-1
Galesburg 7-1
Limestone 5-4
Peoria Richwoods 4-5
East Peoria 4-6
Kewanee 2-5
Canton 0-8
1964-65
Pekin 8-0
Galesburg 5-1
Peoria Richwoods 4-4
Limestone 3-5
Canton 1-6
East Peoria 1-7
1965-66
Galesburg 5-0
Pekin 5-1
Canton 2-3
Limestone 1-5
Peoria Richwoods 1-5
1966-67
Pekin 6-0
Galesburg 3-2
Canton 2-3
Limestone 2-4
Peoria Richwoods 1-5
1967-68
Galesburg 5-0
Pekin 5-1
Peoria Richwoods 2-4
Canton 1-4
Limestone 1-5
1968-69
Peoria Richwoods 5-1
Galesburg 4-1
Pekin 4-2
Limestone 1-5
Canton 0-5
1969-70
Galesburg 5-0
Pekin 4-2
Peoria Richwoods 3-3
Limestone 2-4
Canton 0-5
1970-71
Peoria Richwoods 5-1
Galesburg 4-1
Pekin 3-3
Limestone 2-4
Canton 0-5
1971-72
Galesburg 4-1
Peoria Richwoods 4-2
Pekin 3-3
Limestone 2-4
Canton 1-4