1945-46
Waterloo 8-0
New Athens 6-2
Valmeyer 4-4
Red Bud 2-6
Columbia 0-8
1946-47
Waterloo 8-0
New Athens 5-3
Red Bud 3-5
Valmeyer 3-5
Columbia 1-7
1947-48
New Athens 8-0
Waterloo 5-3
Columbia 4-4
Valmeyer 2-6
Red Bud 1-7
1948-49
New Athens 8-0
Columbia 5-3
1949-50
Waterloo 7-1
Columbia 5-3
New Athens 4-4
Valmeyer 4-4
Red Bud 0-8
1950-51
Columbia 6-2
Valmeyer 6-2
Waterloo 6-2
New Athens 2-6
Red Bud 0-8
1951-52
Waterloo 8-0
Valmeyer 5-3
New Athens 4-4
Columbia 3-5
Red Bud 0-8
1952-53
New Athens 6-2
Valmeyer 6-2
Waterloo 6-2
Columbia 1-7
Red Bud 1-7
1953-54
Waterloo 8-0
Columbia 4-4
New Athens 3-5
Red Bud 3-5
Valmeyer 2-6
1954-55
New Athens 6-2
Valmeyer 6-2
Waterloo 5-3
Red Bud 3-5
Columbia 0-8
1955-56
Waterloo 7-1
New Athens 6-2
Red Bud 4-4
Valmeyer 2-6
Columbia 1-7
1956-57
New Athens 7-1
Waterloo 6-2
Red Bud 4-4
Columbia 3-5
Valmeyer 0-8
1957-58
Columbia 7-1
Waterloo 7-1
Red Bud 4-4
New Athens 2-6
Valmeyer 1-7
1958-59
Columbia 8-0
Waterloo 6-2
New Athens 2-6
Red Bud 2-6
Valmeyer 2-6
1959-60
New Athens 6-2
Waterloo 6-2
Valmeyer 4-4
Columbia 2-6
Red Bud 2-6