Mar 2020
Bluewater Bulletin
Bluewater Model Engineering Society Sarnia, Ontario
Vol. 35 No.6 March 2020 Editor John Lovegrove
Our next meeting was scheduled for April 20th but this will not now
take place because of the current Covid 19 pandemic. We will let
everyone know nearer the time whether the May meeting can go
ahead.
The March Meeting
As usual we started with the Treasurer’s Report: All is
still well in that department.
Continuing on the cancellations theme; we had notice
shortly after the meeting that NAMES has been
cancelled. There was no mention of it being rescheduled
for later in the year so presumably we will
have to wait until April 2021 for the next show. We
did have some discussion at the meeting about who
planned to go etc. but that discussion is now moot.
Back to the meeting venue situation; Bruce went
along to the Naval Association of Canada hall to find
out if that might be an option. Unfortunately, it was all
closed up – probably will be for a while.
Bruce talked about his latest frustrations working on
his Howitzer. He had soldered the “shoes” on to the
barrel but failed to include the coupling piece that
joins the two parts together. He realized this during
the night and woke up in a cold sweat. So… the
following day it had to be un-soldered and re-done.
(We all have our dumb arse moments and I will tell my
own a little later.) One has to realize that Bruce is
making this whole thing based on very limited
information and is having to guess at how a lot of
things were done on the original and how things go
together.
Getting on to the theme of videos worth watching;
Bruce found three by different people on grinding up
tools: The first is from Jo Pie:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=__A2xtLF0AU
Then there was one from “This Old Tony;”
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DgB1psCFC7o
and lastly, one from Stephan Gotteswinter:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vDa3hwv7_8s
(I have often wondered about that name; it is as it
sounds; God Winter.)
My son-in-law forwarded me a link to an item which is
all about the theft of model railway locomotives in
England. Apparently, they are now much sought after
by wealthy collectors and people will go to
can be calculated and dimensions adjusted until the
desired value is obtained. 3D programs do an even
better job with this kind of thing.
For me, CAD is like having digital readouts on a mill,
once you have the facility and know how to use it you
really wonder how you ever managed without.
extraordinary lengths to steal them. It just goes to
show what a thieving bunch the Brits are!
https://getpocket.com/explore/item/the-great-modeltrain-
robbery
As discussed at the February meeting, I said that I
would put on a demonstration on 2D drafting – so that
is what I did. I used both the older AutoCad 2000
program and the more recent AutoCad 13. (For what
we do, the 2000 version is really quite adequate.)
The problem is that neither it nor version 13 will run
on the later Microsoft operating systems. They were
OK up the Windows 8 stage but that is all.
Fortunately, there is a convertor from Longbow that
allows them to be loaded into and operate in Windows
10. The older AutoCad versions are fairly readily
available.
I have used AutoCad for over 20 years, initially for
work but now entirely for the hobby. If you are
making something from scratch then you need to
make drawings of some kind and you either have to
do this with pencil and paper or learn an electronic
system. Even if you buy a set of castings and
drawings, experience with my last two projects is that
you really cannot make the thing with the drawings
supplied. In some cases, the castings cannot be
machined to the finished dimensions specified, in
other cases there are errors in the drawings so that
things cannot actually be made as drawn and go
together afterwards. With my Sealion I have basically
had to re-draw the whole thing.
In addition to the straightforward drawing part, these
programs allow you to get various properties of the
items you have drawn. For example, when I was
making my single cylinder Wyvern engine, one of the
write-ups I saw suggested that the crankshaft balance
weight was inadequate. I made the piston and
connecting rod first, determined their weights then
worked on re-designing the crank webs to give the
“correct” balance. Drawing programs have a
“properties” function whereby once a component has
been drawn (in 2D in this case), one can find its area
and the centre of gravity. From the area, thickness
and material density, the weight can be calculated,
then given the centre of gravity, the balance moment
This was the second valve body he has made, he
found that the first one had a blow hole at a critical
point and it had to be scrapped.
Melting iron is hard on crucibles – as the picture
below shows:
Show and Tell
Last time Kasey had been working on some
electronics to control the tramway system he is
building.
The “breadboarded” try-out circuit workedOK but the “proper” circuit did not. Having worked onthe circuit some more he found a bad connection -now all is well. Kasey brought along a couple of new“breadboards” in their packages to show us.
Tony Koolen has been doing some screw cutting
using insert threading tools ordered out of China.
Todd Michael has been making more iron castings;
I bought some of these a while back and they do a
very good job – far better than a normal single point
tool. Close inspection of the photograph suggests
that the thread is left-handed?
this is the partially machined crank web casting for histraction engine:
The next items were the main governor piece and the
valve body for the governor:
Tony also brought along the steering shaft for his
traction engine. I milled the (variable angle) helical
grooves on this some time ago using my CNC mill,
Tony has now added an end piece.
Bruce continues to make progress on his howitzer –
despite the setbacks mentioned earlier. Below are
some pictures of the artillery piece showing the status
as of the meeting
side. I built an electronic system that uses a Hall
effect device triggered by a slotted disk on the
crankshaft. This operates a high voltage switching
transistor that does essentially the same job as
contact breaker points did in days of old. The Hall
effect device + switching transistor is the technology
used in cars etc. nowadays but they have a computer
in between to calculate optimum spark timing.
The first problem was that the Hall effect device was
mounted on the engine with all the connections
carefully insulated. This was then connected to the
rest of the ignition system comprising the switching
module, battery and coil. The only other connection
from the ignition system to the engine was the hightension
supply to the distributor/spark plugs.
Everything worked OK for a while but what must have
happened was that the current flowing through the
high-tension system built up a charge on the engine.
When the voltage associated with the charge reached
a high enough value, the insulation around the Hall
effect device broke down and it was zapped.
The solution was ordering a replacement from Digi-
Key and putting in a grounding connection between
the engine and the ignition module - which had I
thought about it properly I would have done in the first
place. (That was my dumb arse moment.)
The other problem was more difficult to find. When I
was assembling the engine, I made up something to
mount the spark plugs so that I could check that they
all worked and fired in the correct sequence. I had
already checked that the timing was right, so
everything in the ignition system looked good.
The engine is mounted in my old lathe so that I can
turn it over continuously whether or not it is producing
any power. Rotated like this it would fire sporadically
and in a somewhat strange way but not actually run. I
won’t describe how I eventually figured out what was
happening but basically, when you have to create a
spark in a cylinder that is under pressure, a
significantly higher voltage is needed than at
atmospheric pressure. There is not much space
inside these small distributors for the rotor arm and
the contacts for the four spark plugs and what was in
fact happening was that the high voltage from the coil
was arcing across to a contact for one of the other
spark plugs (in a cylinder where there was no
pressure) hence finding an easier passage to ground
than through the spark plug which was under
pressure and that actually needed to be fired.
I made a slight modification to the distributor and now
it runs fairly well. It does not run as evenly as I would
like and I suspect that I still have the same problem
but to a lesser degree.
This is the engine on its lathe bed test stand, using
my traditional fruit juice can for the cooling water.
I once described him as the ever-productive Mike
Clark. He certainly lived up to that billing this time
bringing along the Celebration Ball Clock that he
recently completed.
The timekeeping part isclockwork with an escapement wheel and pendulumarrangement that is different from most. You tell thetime by looking at the number of balls in the lowerrack (1 to 12 hours) and the minutes using thenumber of balls in the top rack (5 to 55.) You only get
the time to the nearest 5 minutes - not microsecond
precision here! If you Google the subject quite a lot
comes up including a video of one working. It also
seems that a lot of these have been made from wood,
Mike’s is primarily aluminum.
I have been working fairly intensively on my Sealion
to get it up and running. (This is my main excuse for
not getting the newsletter out earlier.) I was aiming to
have it running for NAMES this year and although that
target has now disappeared, I still wanted to get it
finished.
Although there have not been any real mechanical
issues, I have had some problems on the ignition
The Rest of the Season
Although I have left the scheduled meeting dates
below there is obviously a question mark over
whether we will be able to hold any of them. I have
had official notification that the April booking for the
school has been cancelled and it is likely that May will
be as well. Because there will be no meeting in April
there is not much point in producing a newsletter
either…unless…being confined to home, everyone
has been beavering away in their shops and have
pictures and write-ups of all the items they have made
...that they can send to me so that I can put
something together!?
Scheduled Meetings dates for 2020
These were to have been as follows:
April 20th, 2020 – definitely cancelled
May 11th, 2020 – still questionable
June 8th, 2020 – we will see?
Our Website
https://sites.google.com/site/bluewatermes/
John Lovegrove