Mar. 2019
Bluewater Bulletin
Bluewater Model Engineering Society Sarnia, Ontario
Vol. 34 No.6 March 2019 Editor John Lovegrove
Our next meeting will be on
April 8th, 2019 @ 7:30 pm
Northern Collegiate Room 125, Indian Road, Sarnia.
The March Meeting
As usual we started with the Treasurer’s report and
there is still some money left in the bank.
Bruce started by talking about making and using
broaches. In the last newsletter I showed some of the
components where he had made some square holes
and broaching is about the only way of doing this
easily and satisfactorily. The problem is that proper
commercial broaches have multiple rows of cutting
teeth and are really expensive: Out of interest I
looked in the MSC catalog and a ¼” broach is listed at
$US136 - which is prohibitive for what we do. (Maybe
Banggood has something to offer?) Otherwise, the
home-made option (usually of a very simplified design
with single cutting edges) is really the only one that
makes sense. Here is what Bruce has been using.
problem is that centre drills do not go down to the
very small sizes; 1/16” is fairly common, they do seem
to be made down to 0,5mm (0.02”) but below this you
are out of luck.
Where I have mainly seen the problem is in making
jets for carburettors where very small holes are
needed. Spotting drills are the other option but you
could still be left with the pip in the middle of the
conical starting hole. Maybe a clue to what should
work comes in the MSC catalogue where in the
spotting drill section they say: “designed for accurate
spotting on NC machines where a drill with less of a
point angle will be used for the drilling
application.” The NC part is not really relevant (does
anyone use straight NC machines anymore?) but
these things are made with a point angle as low as
600 so they leave a fairly gently tapered starting hole
and maybe there is a self centering action that takes
out any pip that starts to form? If you come in with a
drill afterwards that has, say a 1200 point angle, the
drill will hopefully contact the sides of the tapered
starting hole first and be guided sufficiently to not be
thrown off by any pip that is left. People who make
components with small holes on a commercial basis
must have found ways around the problem. (Maybe
having higher quality equipment than we can
generally afford helps somewhat?)
Bruce went on to talk about a couple of Joe “Pi”
videos on making wagon wheels. Firstly, with straight
spokes:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gbpe3qdQ0EU&p
bjreload=10
Then flared spokes:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s0HfNx9FdRc
One of the general subjects that came up for
discussion was air bags in cars and some of the
lawsuits that have arisen because of faulty
design/manufacture. Something of an explosive
nature is needed to inflate them sufficiently rapidly to
protect people in a vehicle. (A device is used to
detect the rapid deceleration of the vehicle in a crash,
a computer decides whether it is appropriate to
activate the air bags, the bags then have to be
inflated before you hit the steering wheel etc., then
Stu’s Easton/Anderson Beam Engine
He then went on to talk about the difficulty of startingsmall holes. The same problems arise whether one isusing a drill press/mill, or when drilling the hole in acomponent rotating in the lathe. The difference is thatin a lathe you can see the problem more easily
because the drill “wiggles.” With inaccuracies in the
chuck (and the centering of the tailstock in the case of
a lathe) the axis of the spotting or centre drill is never
exactly on the rotational axis. Therefore a “pip” or flat
is left in the middle of the starting hole.
If a normal centre drill is used and the diameter of the
end is smaller than the drill one will be using, the
problem is not too bad. Assuming the centre drill is
held sufficiently rigidly, the small starting hole will be
slightly oversize with a flat at the bottom, but the
actual drill being used will follow the starting hole,
take out the flat and carry on as intended. The
deflate quickly afterwards.) A highly unstable material
called sodium azide was used in early systems but
the industry has moved on from there and safer
materials are now used. It seems that some
unscrupulous manufacturers have been using cheap
conventional explosives for the purpose and problems
have arisen.
There was then some discussion on rifling of pistol
and gun barrels with Stu Brownlow leading off on this.
Early systems just cut one groove at a time so the
process was very slow. Later systems cut them all in
one go and this speeded things up considerably. Yet
another approach is to have an externally grooved
former inside the barrel blank, then use rollers on the
outside to force this on to the former and create the
grooves on the inside. There never seems to be any
limit to the ingenuity shown by men to make things
that more effectively kill their fellow human beings.
Todd’s Burner
Show and Tell
Having made a lot of the parts for his 4 ½” howitzer,
Bruce has been assembling them to see if all of the
individual mechanisms still function when they have to
work together.
He has had a few problems getting allof this to happen and is in the process of workingthrough them. Here is a picture of the assembledparts he brought along.
Tony Koolen has made more parts for the feed pump
on his Case traction engine, this time the crank and
connecting rod arrangement.
Stu Brownlow brought along his model of an
Easton/Anderson grasshopper beam engine from
1892. It has not been constructed so that it will work
on steam or compressed air but instead it is turned
over by a small battery powered motor inside the
base. The flywheel is smaller than the drawings call
for because of Stu’s equipment limitations. It is fitted
with the governor that he purchased ready made and
brought along to one of our meeting several months
ago. Although it would probably work as intended,
because of the electric drive, you just see the balls
going round, but it does not in fact control the speed.
Todd Michel is planning to get into the metal casting
business – hopefully being able to melt iron. As a first
step he has made up the burner for the furnace: This
has a supply for propane, an air atomized nozzle for
oil (diesel?) and a connection for the forced air
supply. There was some discussion about whether
preheating the air supply, using the hot gasses
leaving the furnace, would help get the higher
temperatures needed for iron.
The magnetic base dial indicator support:
The end of the
connecting rod has to be forked to go around the
pump and act evenly on both sides of the piston rod.
And, no, he confessed that he did not cut the gear that drives the crank himself.
He also brought along a dial indicator mount with
magnetic base and articulated support system that
allows great flexibility in how the indicator is used
Although not strictly show and tell, Tony also brought
along some rolls of emery cloth etc. that were surplus
to his requirements, to give away to anyone who
needed some. (Murray Bennell used to talk about
giving things to the needy, not the greedy!)
available with the magnet and Hall effect transistor
combined in one component where a gap is provided
between the two parts (see below.)
Tony’s Give-Away's
This works inconjunction with a steel disk that has slots in theperiphery. When the solid part of the disk is in thegap, the magnetic field is blocked and the device isturned off but when a slot enters the gap, themagnetic field gets through to the transistor and it
turns on. This is the Hall effect device I bought (on a
mounting bracket) and the slotted plate:
In the earlier systems, the contact breaker cut the flow
of current through the ignition coil to produce the
spark. In present systems the switching is carried out
using a special type of transistor. When you break
the current in an inductive circuit, in this case the
primary windings of the ignition coil, a high voltage is
produced on the primary side (several hundred volts
in fact.) This, when reflected into the secondary
windings, induces the very high voltage needed to
produce a spark (>10kV.) With a conventional
contact breaker, a capacitor is needed for the
arrangement to work. Without this, some current
continues to flow after the points open, resulting in
arcing at the points, a lower voltage being produced
on the primary side and not much of a spark. If a
transistor is used, the same arcing problem does not
exist and so no capacitor is needed. In the special
transistors designed for this purpose, over-voltage
protection is built in to prevent damage to the device.
I do have an experimental Arduino micro computer
and have toyed with the idea of using this to control
the spark timing. However, to get the engine running
I will content myself with using the Hall effect device
in conjunction with a slotted plate shown above to
provide the basic timing, then use the special high
voltage transistor to switch the current through the
ignition coil.
Meetings for the Rest of the Season
April 8th
May 13th
June 10th
Our Website
https://sites.google.com/site/bluewatermes/
John Lovegrove
After my shoulder surgery I had limited use of my left
arm and this put the kibosh on running the lathe and
mill in the workshop. I wanted to maintain some
progress on my Sealion and one on the items that
needed attention was the ignition system. Westbury’s
original design used a contact-breaker/capacitor/
distributor arrangement which was the technology of
the 60s when the engine was designed - but things
have moved on since then.
In the automotive world nowadays, solid state sensors
are used to detect the angular position of the
crankshaft. A computer takes this, calculates engine
speed then uses it, along with other information, to
determine when each spark should occur. It then
activates the ignition coils to fire the spark plugs. The
distributor has gone and individual coils are used for
each cylinder or pairs of cylinders.
For multi-cylinder model engines, the distributor
probably has to stay because there is a limit to how
small ignition coils can be made and using 4 of them
on the Sealion would take up a lot of space.
However, I did want to see what other aspects could
be updated.
The device typically used to detect crank position is a
Hall effect transistor. This is turned on when the
south pole of a magnet gets close to it. Therefore, if a
magnet is mounted on something attached to the
crankshaft and the Hall effect device fixed in an
appropriate position, it can be used to trigger the
ignition. In fact, more suitable devices are now