Unit 1 Writing Task

You have just read two variations of an ancient epic. In "The Coming of Beowulf," the hero muses with Hrothgar on the reasons for standing up to Grendel, saying, "Fate will unwind as it must!" He does not know whether his mission will succeed or fail, but he is willing to try.

Write a brief argumentative essay in which you address this question:

Which counts more--taking a stand or winning?

In your essay, take a clear position on the question. Incorporate your analysis of the Beowulf texts to support your ideas. You may also cite incidents from history or from your own experience or observations to support your claim.

For a model of a well-crafted argumentative essay, see the Launch Text, "A World of Heroes"

Possible Argument Frame

In discussions of heroism, one question that comes up is whether it is more important to take a stand or win. On the one hand, (one side of the argument). On the other hand, (opposite side of the argument).  My own view is...

When considering the question of which counts more, taking a stand or winning, it is important to analyze the texts of Beowulf as well as draw upon historical incidents and personal observations.

One possible viewpoint on this question is that taking a stand holds greater significance than winning, as seen in 'The Coming of Beowulf' where the hero is willing to brave unknown outcomes in order to fulfill his mission.

On the other hand, some may argue that winning is of primary importance, as it ultimately determines the success or failure of one's efforts. However, the Beowulf texts offer a different perspective, emphasizing the value of standing up for what is right regardless of the outcome.

Exemplary Response:

Taking a stand and winning are two important aspects when it comes to making a difference and achieving success. However, in the case of the hero in "The Coming of Beowulf," it is clear that taking a stand holds more significance than winning. The hero's willingness to confront Grendel, despite the uncertainty of the outcome, demonstrates the importance of standing up for what is right, regardless of the ultimate result.

When the hero muses with Hrothgar about the reasons for confronting Grendel, he acknowledges that fate will unfold as it is meant to. This acceptance of fate shows a deep understanding that success or failure is beyond his control. Nevertheless, he chooses to take a stand and face the challenge head-on. This act of bravery is admirable because it displays a commitment to one's values and principles, regardless of the potential outcome.

History is replete with examples of individuals who took a stand, knowing that success was uncertain. Martin Luther King Jr., for instance, fought for civil rights in the face of immense opposition and violence. He recognized that the fight for justice was not guaranteed to result in immediate victory. However, his unwavering determination and willingness to face adversity propelled the civil rights movement forward and ultimately led to significant societal change.

Moreover, personal experiences can also highlight the importance of taking a stand over winning. In my own life, I have encountered situations where the outcome was uncertain, but I chose to stand up for what I believed was right. Even if I did not achieve the desired outcome, I felt a sense of fulfillment and personal growth from knowing that I had the courage to take a stand.

While winning can bring validation and tangible rewards, it is the act of taking a stand that shapes individuals and societies. It is through taking a stand that movements are born, injustices are challenged, and progress is made. It is a testament to one's character and values, and it can inspire others to do the same.

In conclusion, taking a stand holds more significance than winning. The hero in "The Coming of Beowulf" exemplifies this through his willingness to confront Grendel, despite the uncertainty of the outcome. This act of bravery highlights the importance of standing up for what is right, regardless of the ultimate result. History and personal experiences further reinforce the idea that taking a stand can lead to significant societal change and personal growth. Therefore, it is clear that taking a stand outweighs winning in terms of its impact and significance.

Non-Exemplary Response:

The hero in "The Coming of Beowulf" says, "Fate will unwind as it must!" This shows that he doesn't care about winning, he just wants to take a stand. But I think winning is more important than taking a stand. Winning means you're successful and people respect you. Why would anyone want to take a stand if they're not going to win? It's a waste of time and energy. Plus, if you take a stand and lose, people might think you're weak or foolish. So, in my opinion, winning counts more than taking a stand.