It ain't what you prove, it's the way that you prove it...
Act 0; Lesson 0
Teacher: Good afternoon class. For homework I asked you to investigate triangles and to try and find some of their properties. Can anyone tell me what they have discovered?
Alpha: Yes. I have found that the angles of a triangle always add up to 180°.
Teacher: Perhaps you could explain how you came to this conclusion.
Alpha: Well, I drew a great many triangles of varying shapes and sizes and found that in nearly every case the angle sum was 180°.
Beta: Just a moment, did I hear you say 'nearly¹ every case?
Alpha: Yes - I admit there were a few that seemed to come to 181° or even 179°.
Beta: So your result should say that 'The angles of a triangle nearly always add up to 180°.
Alpha: No, the evidence was so strong that I can explain the few that didn't by inaccuracies of measurement.
Beta: What you are trying to say is that you cling to your hypothesis despite evidence to the contrary. These are clearly counter-examples to your theory and it is most non-mathematical to dismiss them so quickly.
Alpha: There is always experimental error when measurement is involved – it must be expected, not considered as a counterexample.
Beta: Teacher I protest. Alpha is using language that is more at home in a science laboratory where vague concepts such as 'strength of evidence' and 'experimental error' may be good enough, but this is a maths class. We are concerned with exactness and absolute truth.
Alpha: Even if I measured my triangles more accurately and got 180° every time, I expect you are such a sceptic that you would always say there may be a counter- example I haven't yet found.
Beta: For once you are absolutely correct, no amount of so-called 'evidence' will convince me that your hypothesis, however likely, must be true. You are using an inductive argument which I cannot accept. I will only believe that when I have a rigorous deductive proof that it is the case.
Teacher: I am sure we all agreed that such a proof would be desirable. Can anybody provide one?
Gamma: Yes. I have a proof that will satisfy Beta. May I demonstrate?
Teacher: Please do.
Gamma: You can see the triangle ABC. It contains angles of size a, b, and c. I have drawn a line passing through C which is parallel to AB. Due to the well-known properties of parallel lines the angles at point C are also a and b as I have indicated. So now a, b and c are on a straight line, so a + b + c =180°. So Alpha's theorem is proven since this process will work for all triangles.
Teacher: Are there any questions about Gamma's proof, or does this satisfy even Beta?
Delta: Just one small point. You have asserted a 'well-known' result about parallel lines. Could you just prove it for me please?
Gamma: OK... it's due to this property. Since (pointing) a + b = 180°, and b + d = 180° then a = d.
Delta: Ah yes, but just one further question, why do a + b = 180°?
Gamma: Well clearly a + c = 180° due to the definition of 180° as the angle (pointing) on a straight line. Similarly d + b = 180°. Now, that means a + b + c + d = 360°. Clearly a + b must be equal to c + d otherwise the lines would not be parallel hence a + b = 180°.
Delta: I see. Are you sure there are no other hidden assumptions in your proof?
Gamma: Er yes (tentatively).
Delta: In which case may I suggest a couple. Firstly you have assumed that it is always possible to draw a parallel line through a given point. Secondly, you have assumed that it is possible to draw only one such line, that is the one with the angle properties you desire. Can you prove these?
Gamma: You are going to question everything aren't you? Look, a proof is merely an argument from what we already know to be true to a new result. In any proof we must start from assumptions. If you continually question the assumptions we will never be able to reach a new truth. If I use the term 'straight line' there is no point in asking me to prove that it is straight.
The same is true with parallel lines. What you are doing is asking for proof that parallel lines are in fact parallel. All I am saying is , if we start with a straight line, then we can deduce certain things. I am not, quite frankly, interested in arguing whether or not it is really straight. I am assuming it is - if it isn¹t then we are talking about a different problem.
Phi: To save all this fuss, why not build the angle property into the definition of a triangle and define a triangle as a shape whose angles add up to 180°?
Gamma: You are being facetious. We define a triangle in terms of a few basic concepts, and from these concepts we prove its properties.
Phi: Perhaps you could give us such a definition.
Gamma: Happily. A triangle is a shape formed by joining three points with three straight lines.
Phi: Now perhaps you will define a straight line.
Gamma: (wearily). A straight line is the shortest path that you can draw between two points. It is what you draw if you start going in one direction and keep going.
Phi: I will not go on to ask for a definition of points because I already have a counter-example to your theorem, based entirely on the definitions you have given. I have found a triangle whose angles add up to 270°.
Teacher: Please demonstrate.
Phi: (holds up football). As you can see this line gives the shortest path between A and B, the same for BC and CA. All angles are right angles, hence the total is 270°.
Delta: He's right, you cannot deny that this triangle fits your definitions, but it clearly doesn't follow the result of the theorem.
Gamma: This is ridiculous, that is not a triangle. A triangle is a shape drawn on a flat plane, not on a curved surface.
Delta: I'm sorry Gamma but you never put that in your definition. A straight line on a sphere, the shortest distance between points, what you get by going in one direction and keeping going is a circle all the way round the sphere and back where you came from.
By your definition there are three straight lines joining three points hence this is a triangle, hence a counterexample.
Gamma: The concept of a triangle being a plane figure is implicit in the definition even if it's not explicit.
Alpha: Even I have to disagree here. If I were to go from Lima to New York to Buenos Aires and back to Lima by the shortest routes you would all call my path triangular, yet as Phi as shown the angles do not add up to 180°.
Gamma: Clearly I must make the implicit explicit. I will rephrase the theorem. The angles of a triangle in a plane surface add up to 180°.
Teacher: Before we discuss this any further may I draw your attention to the proof of the theorem. We were happy with the proof and surprised by the counter- example. Should we not examine the proof to see where it breaks down? Then perhaps we will see if there are any other implicit assumptions that must be made explicit.
Alpha: It is the parallel line bit that breaks down.
Phi: I never liked that bit.
Alpha: If we follow the proof like before then you can see that you get three right angles on the line at C! But that's impossible! So the proof doesn't make sense in this case - and you assumed that it would.
Phi: Mmmm.. yes. We can see that any two lines drawn on a sphere will meet. In fact at 2 places, and so parallel lines are impossible.
And you know I'm not even sure that the two lines are parallel. Can you be certain that parallel lines can be drawn on a plane? I suggest that any two lines you draw will meet somewhere, if we have a long enough piece of paper. I challenge you to provide an infinitely long piece of paper to prove me wrong.
Alpha: Any lines I draw will be subject to error in measurement and inaccuracy in construction.
Beta: Oh don't start that again, we have had enough science for one day. There is a better way round the problem.
Alpha: Which is?
Beta: Which is to state clearly all assumptions that we are going to call on, and make our definitions subject to those assumptions. I shall call the assumptions 'axioms' and from them we can deduce 'theorems'.
Phi: But what if your assumptions are false?
Beta: Truth or falsehood doesn't enter into it. We assume our assumptions, obviously. That's why they are called assumptions. Therefore anything that follows from them is true in any world where they hold. If you can't find a world where they hold then it doesn't invalidate the theorems or the argument used to deduce them.
Phi: Let us hear your axioms.
Beta: Certainly.
(1) There is one and only one straight line between two points.
(2) Any finite straight line can be produced indefinitely.
(3) All right angles are equal.
(4) A circle can be drawn with any point as the centre to pass through a given point.
(5) Through any point one and only one line can be drawn parallel to a given line.
Teacher: (an aside to the audience). The axioms were first suggested by the Greek mathematician Euclid over 2000 years ago. They were accepted as the basis for geometry until the nineteenth century when new systems of axioms were considered and new geometries were explored including that of the sphere.
Gamma: So if we consider these axioms as our starting point, they define what we might call two dimensional Euclidian space and it is not necessary or meaningful to question their truth since they are the starting point.
Phi: Surely we should define the terms that we use! We must be able to say what we mean by point and line or the axioms themselves are meaningless.
Delta: No, that would be too restrictive, even if it were possible.
Teacher: I think you should explain that statement - how are definitions restrictive?
Delta: Well the axioms that Beta gave us were envisaged in a flat plane, and our points and lines would be so defined.
Phi: Indeed, it is flat plane geometry we are talking about.
Delta: But if we can find another system which obeys the same again then all the theorems which are true for the flat plane are true for the other system. Let us take, for example, geometry on a cylinder. The axioms apply on a cylinder and so all the theorems we proved in what we thought was flat plan geometry also work on a non-flat cylinder.
Phi: I am a bit worried about the direction in which we seem to be moving. We seem to have lost our grip on reality.
Teacher: Perhaps you could elaborate on your fears.
Phi: I shall try. When Alpha first suggested the theorem about triangles, he was, quite rightly, criticised for using what one can only call a scientific method. I mean no insult by this. He allowed experimental evidence to guide his thinking and his conclusion was not an accurate deduction from his results. In maths we are not concerned with measurement of angles and the accuracies and inaccuracies that go with it. We are concerned with the theory of angles and triangles, with provable deductions that have a universal truth.
Teacher: Surely that means you must applaud the move towards an axiomatic structure and clearly defined rules of inference.
Phi: Only to a certain extent. It seems to me that we have gone too far. By suggesting that our initial concepts need have no definitions we have lost any relevance that our results may have to a real situation.
Teacher: Alpha, are you in broad agreement with Phi?
Alpha: I agree with him about going too far and leaving reality behind. It seems to me that maths has no value unless it informs us more about the world we live in and Delta's deduction from axioms and undefined terms seems to be little more than a game. I do however still defend the experimental approach as a starting point, because unless I had found the hypothesis by drawing then we would have had nothing to prove and hence no work to do. The correct procedure must be to find a result by experiment and then, using agreed definitions we must prove the result true. The important thing is that the definitions characterise the objects of discussion.
Delta: I am sorry, but I disagree. The picturing of any reality is irrelevant, and to look for such a picture is not the purpose of mathematics. The job of a mathematician is to set up axiomatic systems and to deduce from them theorems. Our conceptions of the real are not fixed, they vary from person to person and they change, within each person from time to time. One only has to look at the confusion caused when Einstein asked scientists to drop their Newtonian ideas of physics or the continuing debate over quantum theory and wave theory to see how any supposed picture of reality is inadequate. Whether or not an axiomatic system is of any value to scientists does not affect its validity as a piece of mathematics. We are not concerned with perceptions of an external reality, we are concerned with objects created by the mind, and rules we use to govern these objects. As such the objects cannot and should not be defined in terms of the real world, since the real world or at least our view of it will change.
Beta: I agree with Delta. I also noticed Alpha's attempt to slander axiomatic systems by calling them games. He is probably so upset at being called a scientist that he wanted to throw a few insults of his own. However, he has failed miserably as I do not consider the word 'game' an insult at all. The game of chess is a very good analogy. In chess the pieces have names and their rules for movement are the axioms. A position is allowable only if it can be reached by using the rules. But the pieces are not defined in terms of anything outside chess. We call a bishop a bishop and a knight a knight but their rules of movement bear no relation to any bishops or knights outside the games of chess (if they did then the phrase queen mates with bishop on back row¹ would have a completely different meaning). No attempt is made to use the game as a picture of reality. The pieces are purely man made concepts and the game is a formal logical structure. Mathematics is a formal logical structure derived from rules in the same way - and the greatest game of all.
Teacher: Without wishing to stop the argument it is clear that the lesson is about to end and I must set homework. So, can you please look into polygons other than triangles for next lesson.
written by Chris Binge
Questions
1. What is the role of experiment in Mathematics? How does this differ from the role of experiment in science?
2. Once mathematicians believe that they have found a result or (theorem), what is the next step? How does this differ from science?
3. What is an axiom? Can an axiom be true or false?
4. In your own words summarise Delta's position on Mathematics. How does he differ from Alpha regarding the status of axioms?`
5. So are the results of Mathematics true? What do we mean by mathematical truth?
Act 1 Lesson 2
Teacher: Now then class. You have been thinking about Polygons. Perhaps someone would like to read out their work.
Alpha: At risk of being attacked by Beta, I can suggest something, Although I will choose my words more carefully this time. My research suggests ...
Beta: Oh no, here we go again.
Alpha (clears throat): My research suggests the following conjecture. The internal angles of a plane polygon of n sides add up to (n - 2) x 180°. Before I am attacked I must stress this is a conjecture and it needs either proof or refutation.
Phi: I have come to the same conclusion, but not by measurement. I made my polygons by adding triangles together and this has lead me to a proof.
Teacher: Let us hear it.
Phi: The proof consists of this thought experiment. Let us assume we have a polygon of n sides where n > 3. If I join a vertex by a straight line to the next but one vertex then it will dissect the Polygon into a triangle and a polygon of (n - 1) sides.
The sum of their interior angles is the same as that of the original. I repeat this process with the (n - 1) sided polygon, obtaining two triangles and a polygon of (n -2) sides. If I do this (n - 3) times I am left exactly (n - 2) triangles the sum of whose internal angles are (n - 2) x 180. Hence, the conjecture is true.
Alpha: I think I need an example of your process.
Phi: Have a look at this dissection of a pentagon.
Alpha: In which case we can now call it a theorem.
Gamma: Just a moment. Phi, you were the first to find hidden assumptions in my proof last lesson. I think we should examine yours before calling it a theorem. To start with, can you be sure that joining one vertex to the next but one vertex will always result in a triangle and an (n-1) polygon?
Delta: And can you be certain that such a dissection will give shapes where the sum of the internal angles is the same as the originals ?
Beta: And can you indeed be certain that (n-3) such operations will always lead to (n-2) triangles?
Alpha: Oh dear, we seem to have made the problem worse. We have split up the problem into three separate problems, each one in need of proof or refutation. Can you prove them Phi?
Phi: Not yet but that doesn't invalidate the process. We can now look at a complex problem in three ways. The proof may not prove the result but it does help us examine it.
Gamma: I was right when I felt suspicious of the first assumption. I have found a counter-example. This arrow head is quadrilateral or 4-polygon and if I join point A to the next but one vertex, C, I certainly don't split it up into triangles.
Phi: But you do if you join B to D, and anyway the angle sum of the arrow head is 360° so it is not a counterexample to the theorem.
Gamma: I am not, at this point, questioning the theorem. I am questioning your proof. The distinction is important. It is clearly a counter-example to your assumption that such a line must split up the polygon.
Phi: Very well. I will have to change the proof by stating that it is possible in any polygon to find an internal angle which is less than 180° and if one joins the vertices either side of it then one will get a triangle.
Gamma: You have improved your proof but how can you tell if it is improved sufficiently to keep out another counterexample? And if you can't be sure about that then you can't be sure that the theorem itself doesn't have a counterexample.
Beta: It does.
Gamma: Pardon?
Beta: I have found a counter-example. This is a hexagon since it contains six vertices and six sides. Your theorem suggests it should have an angle sum of (6 - 2) x 180° = 720° but it in fact only has 360°
Delta: My congratulations Beta, I always thought the theorem false and now we know it is. Can we please go onto the next topic on the syllabus.
Phi: I think this is worthy of some examination before we do.
Alpha: (exasperated) No examination is necessary, it is ridiculous to suggest that this is a hexagon - it is clearly two triangles and so the theorem is upheld.
Beta: Perhaps you would care to explain why it is not a hexagon. I must say that just because you have not encountered it before is not a reason to say it doesn't exist. A polygon is n vertices connected by n sides.
Alpha: It is obvious that a polygon cannot be dissected in this way. Therefore, it is not a polygon but two polygons. A polygon is a single shape formed by n vertices joined by n sides.
Beta: I hope you are not going to claim that you had thought of this before. Please have the intellectual honesty to admit that you have changed the definition of the word 'polygon', because this counter-example shows the theorem to be false.
Alpha: Whenever I thought of polygons I always thought of one shape not two. I assumed that this was implicit in the idea of polygon. All you have done is asked me to make this implicit assumption into an explicit statement.
Beta: But if mathematics is to be rigorous then we must state in our definitions, everything we need to clearly define the concept.
Alpha: In which case I admit that a polygon must be defined as one shape not two.
Teacher: If we all agree to accept this we now have a definition to go with our conjecture and our proof. Can anyone refute it now?
Delta: Yes, my twin triangles do in fact make one shape. This is a pentagon and its angles are 360° and not 540° as you would expect. Your change of definition does not help in this case.
Alpha: First you ask me to accept two polygons as one, and now I have to accept this construction! All you have done is join the two triangles together. The counterexample is a monster and must be banished.
Delta: But this shape is formed by five vertices and five straight lines, and it is one shape not two, by your own definition, Alpha, this is a pentagon. It is the theorem that must be banished. It is false.
Teacher: We seem to have two opposing positions. When we have a theorem and a counterexample we can either follow Alpha and reject the counter-example as a monster, or we can follow Beta and reject the theorem as false. What are the opinions of the class?
Gamma: There is a third alternative.
Teacher: I disapprove of your misuse of the word alternative, but I may approve of your suggestion - go ahead.
Gamma: Well, it seems that Alpha's method denies the truth set out in front of him, whereas Beta's denies some excellent mathematics, in that there are many examples for which the theorem works. I suggest a modification of the theorem, a retreat into a safe domain for which we know the theorem works. For example I shall define 'simple polygons' to be polygons where exactly two lines meet at every vertex. And then say that the theorem holds for all simple polygons.
Phi: I have an objection. How do you know you have retreated far enough? Can you be sure the theory works for all such polygons? I suspect there may still be counterexamples.
Beta: I have a second objection. How do you know you have not retreated too far? In restricting your theorem to 'simple polygons' perhaps you have excluded some for which the theorem does hold.
Phi: Beta is right. You could have withdrawn as far as all regular polygons. That is equiangular and with equal sides, then you would have been absolutely safe, but the new domain is arbitrary, you have no justification for suggesting it.
Teacher: You have made a rash statement in suggesting absolute safety for regular polygons, but I shall let it pass. How is Gamma to decide where to make his safe domain?
Beta: By looking at the proof.
Delta: But the proof is wrong. It has been shown to be wrong by the counter-example. It is not, in fact, a proof.
Beta: It is not a proof in the sense that it proves the theorem, but even if it doesn't do what it was intended to do it may still be useful. Columbus didn't get to India but he discovered something quite interesting.
Delta: Away with your geographical analogies - explain.
Beta: Well, we know that the proof sounds quite convincing, and remains so until we can find counterexamples. We also know we have found a counter-example, but which part of the proof is it that fails ? If we can examine the proof with respect to this counterexample we will see what it is about the counterexample that causes the problem, then we can put it right and modify the theorem with the proof.
Gamma: Yes I can see now where the proof breaks down. If I join A to D and B to D and dissect the shape along these lines I get the two triangles AED and BCD that I would expect, but I don't get a triangle ADB I just get a straight line. So the theorem must incorporate a provision that will prevent D lying on line AB.
Beta: No, there is no need. This is not a counter-example at all. ADB is a triangle, just a flat one, the angle ADB is 180° as we would expect. If we had looked at the pentagon in the first place and measured the angle at D to be 300° instead of two angles of 60° we would have got the correct answer of 540° .
Alpha: But surely that 300° can't be called an internal angle.
Beta: It depends how you define internal angles.
Alpha: Well, you have stretched the concept of polygon so as to include your monsters, so I don't see why you can't stretch the concept of internal angle to include the monster within the theorem. At least your lunacy is consistent.
Phi: So careful analysis of the proof can lead to a new way of looking at a counter-example, by redefinition of the terms we use, and, in this case, a vindication of my proof (smug smile).
Delta: I am afraid your victory is only temporary. I have a counter-example that cannot be altered by a careful redefinition of internal angles. This shape has 8 vertices and 8 sides hence it is an octagon. I shall call it the square polo. It has an angle sum of 1440° and not, as predicted by your conjecture 1080°.
Alpha: More absurdity! This is just another case of Beta's two disconnected triangles, the only difference is that you have put one rectangle inside another. A woman with a child in her womb is not a counter-example to the thesis that human beings have one head!
Delta: You are now being inconsistent. You objected to the two triangles because they were not 'one shape'. This clearly is one shape - it just happens to have a hole in it!
Alpha: The implication was clear to all but the blind! It is implicit in this idea of a polygon that the sides must be connected.
Delta: It seems to me that your definitions are changing all the time and what you claim to be implicit is in fact something you had not even thought of.
Alpha: I know what I understand by the term 'polygon' - it is you who do not.
Delta: I only ask for a clear definition with all the implications carefully stated.
Teacher: If we may stop the bickering for a moment, we can see that Alpha wishes to outlaw the square polo and that Beta wishes to discard the theorem. How does the method of proof analysis cope with this counterexample?
Gamma: It is the first assumption of the proof that is wrong in this case, You said, Phi, that it would always be possible to join two vertices and so cut up the polygon into a triangle and a smaller polygon, this is clearly not the case, due to the hole in the middle. I shall not take Alpha's dogmatic line which is to say this is not a polygon because it has a hole I shall merely say that the theorem holds for polygons without holes. So now we have a new theorem, complete with proof whose domain is more carefully described. You can always get a greater depth of understanding by this method.
Teacher: So can we summarise the method as follows: When you have a conjecture you must try to prove it and also to refute.
Beta: It is psychologically difficult to do both at the same time.
Teacher: Indeed, historically we see this process is carried out by more than one person. For any mathematical conjecture there is always a group of mathematicians, convinced of its truth, seeking to prove it, and another group, equally convinced of its falsity, seeking to refute it.
Gamma: Whereas the correct position would be to expect it to be both true and false. That is, for there to be a domain of truth and a set of counter-examples.
Teacher: Once you have a proof and a counter-example you must analyse the proof to see where the counterexample refutes it, and you will, in general, discover that the mathematics is richer and more complex than you thought.
Beta: You can then redefine the terms of your theorem so as to include the counter-example, as we did with Delta's pentagon.
Gamma: Or you can change the domain of theorem so as to exclude the counter-example as we did with the square polo.
Phi: There is another possibility.
Teacher: Please tell us.
Phi: You can expand the theorem so that it will include both the counter-example and the original theorem as special cases.
Teacher: I think you had better show us what you mean.
Phi: Well, as we have pointed out it is the hole in the polo that causes the problem, so instead of retreating from it, why not analyse what it is about holes that changes the nature of the polygon.
Alpha: I suppose you are going to say that you have spent the last 5 minutes doing just that ?
Phi: Indeed I have! It appears that the internal angles of a polygon with n sides and h holes in it comes to (n+2h-2) x 180°. This includes your square polo as having n=8 and h=1 so we get 1440°. It also includes all the previous examples without holes by putting h=0 and getting the original result.
Alpha: I suppose you have proof of this.
Phi: Well, yes but the algebra will take too long for this lesson.
Teacher: So we have three things, then, to do with our proof and our counter-example.
(i) Examine our definitions and try to include the counter-example.
(ii) Contract the domain of the original theorem so as to exclude the counter-example.
(iii) Try to expand the theorem so as to include both theorem and counter-example in a larger theorem.
Alpha: How did we know that our new theorem (whether it be contracted or expanded) is final? How do we know that there will be no more counter-examples?
Beta: We don't. Proof analysis does not promise finality, only more depth than we have had in the past. It will change our primitive conjecture and its proof into a more sophisticated conjecture and proof, which will tell us more about the nature of the subject under discussion.
Teacher: OK. that will do for our discussion on proof and discovery for the moment. I must point out however that we will have to have another lesson in the distant future which will bring together ideas of the last two lessons. We will have to discuss the search for finality in proof and the method of translation into an axiomatic structure. The ideas involved turn out to be rather more complex than you can imagine.
Meanwhile, has anybody got any suggestions for homework?
Delta: Well I have found a large number of counterexamples to the theorem.
Phi: Even the deeper theorem ?
Delta: Yes, and these counterexample have no holes.
Teacher: In which case I suggest you investigate them for homework. Discuss these counterexamples to the theorem and try to analyse where they refute the theorem. What's your first reaction to the counter-examples?
Alpha: I would ban counterexamples as monsters. They are not polygons.
Delta: I would accept them and say the conjecture therefore is false.
Beta: I would analyse the proof and try to redefine the ideas of angle so as to make the counter-examples into examples.
Gamma: I would also analyse the proof and find a domain for which the theorem works out which excludes the counterexamples as a condition.
Phi: I would try to find a larger theorem that encompassed the old theorem and the counterexample as different special cases.
Teacher: So... today's homework is to explore....
written by Chris Binge,
inspired by Imre Lakatos from 'Proofs and Refutations - the logic of Mathematical Discovery'
Postscript.
Teacher's claim that withdrawing into the domain of 'regular pentagons' is not safe is actually a correct claim. The star pentagon, the second of beta’s counterexamples, has all equal sides and equal angles, but has an angle sum of 180°. This example can be included within the theorem by redefining it as a 2½ sided shape, as suggested and explored by Schröder in 1862.
Beta’s Counterexamples:
The Bow Tie.
A quadrilateral with internal angles of 180° if you count the insides of the bows.
It could also be said to have “internal angles of 720° if keep turning in the same direction.
2. Introspection
An Octagon that turns in on itself. Internal angles 720°?
3. The Star Pentagon or Pentagram
In the regular shape the internal angles are all 36° making a total of 180°.
An aside
This shape is historically fascinating. The sides and their sections are in the Golden Ratio. For this reason it was the symbol of the Pythagoreans. It may be that the infinite regress of the ratio was the first discovery of an irrational number. The dark secrets it contains probably explain its importance in everything from Devil worship to Masonic societies.
Star polyhedra with these as faces were key counter examples to Euler's formula, and inspired Lakatos’ wonderful “Proofs and Refutations”, which in turn inspired this play.
4. The Spideragon
An octagon with either 8 internal angles of 45°, making 360°.
Or 4 internal angles of 315° making 1260°. It depends what you call internal!
Can you find definitions to include or exclude these? Can you expand the theory to encompass them?
What are the key differences between these and polygons you were normally thinking of?
What distinguishes one from the other?