Blood Oath 4⭐
Main Characters:
Maven Oakley (FL)
Baelfire Decimus
Crypt DeLune
Everett Frost
Silas Crane
“Make us your weapons, darling, and no one will stand a chance against our quintet. Let us be yours.”
The story follows Maven Oakley, who recently awakens as a Caster —a rare role in a world where humans and monsters, known as Legacies, coexist. As a result, she must enroll at Everbound University, an academy where Legacies learn to control their powers and, hopefully, break the curses they've been born with.
The only way to break those curses is by forming a Quintet, binding four Legacies to one Keeper. Unfortunately for Maven, that's the last thing she wants. She has secrets of her own, and accepting a quintet would only destroy the plans she's spent years working toward. So she decides to reject her fated mates. The problem? The four men she's matched with refuse to take no for an answer. Instead of giving up, they're determined to earn her trust—and eventually, her heart 😏😏
I have a very complicated relationship with reverse harem books 😅😅 The Bonds That Tie Series was my introduction to the genre, thanks to my best friend, and it completely changed my opinion of reverse harems. Then I picked up Broken Bloodlines, which... let's just say I absolutely hated, and it pushed me right back to where I started 🤦♀️🤦♀️ So I went into Blood Oath with very cautious expectations.
Thankfully, I'm happy to say this one won me over 🥳🥳 The worldbuilding was easily one of my favorite parts. Even though most of the story takes place inside Everbound University, the magic system, different Legacy species, curses, and the Quintet concept were all genuinely interesting. It felt like there was a much larger world waiting beyond the academy, and I'm excited to explore more of it in the next books.
I also loved Maven's friendship with Kenzie. Kenzie is loud, completely unfiltered, and usually the type of character I don't gravitate toward, but she slowly grew on me just like she did on Maven 🥰🥰
If I had one major complaint, it would be Maven's secret—or rather, the lack of any real reveal. I don't mind mysterious protagonists, but I would've appreciated at least some answers by the end of the book 😑😑
Maven constantly tells the boys she can't be with them, can't help them, and can't break their curses, yet she never explains why. If there's a magical reason preventing her from speaking—some kind of silence oath or curse—that's perfectly understandable. But since we aren't told anything, her constant refusal to explain quickly becomes frustrating 🤷🤷
Despite that, I genuinely liked Maven.She's secretive, sarcastic, and just a little unhinged in the best way possible. Her fascination with everything dark and morbid made her surprisingly entertaining to read, and I can't wait for the boys to discover who she really is beneath all those walls 😍😍
“I have no loyalties to anyone but us. As long as I get to keep my dark obsession, the world can fucking burn for all I care.”
As for the boys… Baelfire immediately stole my heart 💘💘 I have a serious weakness for shapeshifters, especially when they're ridiculously loyal and affectionate toward their mates. Bael is basically a walking golden retriever, and if anything happens to him, I'll riot 😠😠
Crypt might actually be my favorite, though the competition between him and Baelfire is incredibly close. I already know his relationship with Maven is going to be chaotic in the best way possible 😝😝 I can easily picture the two of them brutally murdering monsters while shamelessly flirting, and honestly... that's exactly the energy they give off 🤣🤣 The only thing I wasn't sold on was his physical description. It suits him perfectly, but it wasn't how I pictured him at all.
Everett made me unexpectedly protective 😯😯 Compared to the rest of the quintet, he's much more emotional, and even without reading his POV, it was obvious that his cold behavior toward Maven wasn't genuine. Their misunderstandings were frustrating, but in a good way, because you could tell there was much more beneath the surface.
Then there's Silas, our charming, elegant psychopath. He gives off "pretty prince with issues" energy, and I loved every second of it 🥰🥰 His shared interest in botany and potion-making with Maven was adorable, and they had great chemistry together. Unfortunately, one bad decision completely destroyed the trust he'd been building with her, so I'm curious to see how they'll recover from that.
One of my favorite moments in the entire book was when Baelfire and Everett were having a serious conversation, only for Bael to suddenly stop and casually announce that Silas was about to attack his wall. I genuinely laughed out loud 🤣🤣 Moments like that gave the quintet so much personality, and I can't wait to see all five of them together once they're finally on the same page.
Overall, Blood Oath was a fantastic start to the series 💯💯 The worldbuilding was engaging, the romance hooked me, and the characters left me wanting more. My biggest concern is simply whether the later books will deliver on all the promises this one set up. I really hope the series keeps this momentum going instead of losing its way. See you in the next book's review 👋👋