Now and Then: A Bank’s Home, A Banker’s Home
Now — Citizens Bank
Citizens Bank occupies the former Corning House site at 66 West Main Street. Compare the bank’s low, gabled building with the substantial brick residence in the historical photographs. The May 2008 view records an earlier appearance of the bank, with different signs and trim.
Citizens Bank on the former Corning House site.
Citizens Bank at 66 West Main Street, May 12, 2008. Its signs and reddish trim differ from the more recent view.
1983 — A landmark lost
The Corning House was demolished on Thursday, March 24, 1983, despite efforts to preserve it. The following day’s Democrat and Chronicle reported that about forty bystanders watched its destruction. The museum’s history connects the demolition to a proposed McDonald’s development under a ground lease with owner Roberta Kalsbeck, James Netzman’s daughter. McDonald’s ultimately built elsewhere, and a bank later occupied the property.
Rubble of the Corning House following its March 24, 1983 demolition. The photograph was published in the Democrat and Chronicle on March 26, 1983.
A later color view shows the Corning House with red roofs and a broad porch. The image, including the inset portrait, appears in the Webster Museum’s October 2024 newsletter.
By 1940 — A home for several households
The 1940 directory lists three households at 66 West Main: Clarence W. and Grace C. Froniear, William J. and Pauline Herbst, and Donald and Frances King. The former family mansion had become a place where several village families lived.
1930s — The Corning Inn
The 1938 directory identifies the Corning Inn as a hotel operated by Ruth W. Akins. She and her husband, Elmer C. Akins, also lived at number 66. The museum’s account recalls banquets, private parties, and a tea room.
1929 — A brief hospital chapter
The Webster Museum’s timeline dates the opening of a hospital in the Corning House to 1929. Its operator and closing date have not yet been established.
1928 — The house changes hands
After Anne Corning’s death in 1927, the house and furnishings were auctioned. The museum identifies James Netzman as the purchaser, linking this property to another familiar name in the village’s business history.
1830–1840 — The Corning residence
William J. Corning built the brick house between approximately 1830 and 1840. Banker and Webster’s second town supervisor, Corning was closely associated with the village’s early development.
An undated postcard of the Corning residence, showing brick walls, shuttered windows, columned porches, and the prominent tower.
Local historical accounts describe a richly furnished home with a mahogany pipe organ and a chandelier containing 5,000 crystals, lighting dances and social gatherings. They report that the organ and chandelier went to the Henry Ford Museum in Dearborn, Michigan; the specific objects have not yet been traced in museum records.
The residence stood beside what was then Academy Street, now Corning Park. Its larger estate included a working farm, barns, and a carriage house.
The Corning House in an undated winter view, with a horse-drawn vehicle, pedestrians, and the fence along the property.
SOURCES AND RESEARCH NOTES — 66 WEST MAIN STREET
Prepared November 18, 2026 for the Now & Then walking tour.
1. USER-SUPPLIED MATERIAL
Seven supplied files are preserved unchanged in originals. The winter photograph has not been established as a photograph of the hospital period.
2. WEBSTER MUSEUM — PENNY FARTHING, OCTOBER 2024, PAGES 8–9
https://webstermuseum.org/front/Penny_Farthing_October_2024.pdf
Principal secondary source for ownership, the inn, apartment conversion, the wider estate, and demolition/development history. The color exterior, with inset portrait, is extracted intact from the image embedded on page 8.
Additional research details from this account: auction price approximately $10,000; apartment conversion described as five or six units; repairs estimated at $250,000 in 1983. These are attributed historical reports, not newly examined contracts or appraisals.
3. WEBSTER MUSEUM TIMELINE — HOSPITAL, 1929
https://www.webstermuseum.org/webster2.php
Dates hospital opening to 1929. Operator, formal institution name, services, and closing date remain unconfirmed.
4. CONTEMPORARY DIRECTORIES
1938 Webster directory: printed pages 659 and 661 identify Ruth W. Akins with Corning Inn, her husband Elmer C. Akins, their residence at 66 West Main, and the hotel listing.
https://www.libraryweb.org/rochsubdir/1938/1938webster.pdf
1940 Webster directory lists Clarence W. Froniear (Grace C.), William J. Herbst (Pauline), and Donald King (Frances) at 66 West Main. Listed occupations: laborer, mason, and clerk respectively.
https://www.libraryweb.org/rochsubdir/1940/1940names-webster.pdf
https://www.libraryweb.org/rochsubdir/1940/1940street_guides.pdf
5. DEMOCRAT AND CHRONICLE — MARCH 25–26, 1983
March 25 article by Barbara Vancheri and David Galante, “Old Webster building demolished despite preservation efforts,” reproduced as a clipping on Gonechester. Reports the previous day’s demolition, bystanders, and William J. Corning’s role. The clipping is linked, not reproduced as a full-text article in this package.
https://gonechester.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/image-67.png
Original clipping page:
https://www.newspapers.com/article/democrat-and-chronicle-corning-house-dem/147348899/
March 26 rubble photograph, credited in print to Lance Wynn, Democrat and Chronicle:
https://gonechester.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/image-68.png
Original clipping page:
https://www.newspapers.com/article/democrat-and-chronicle-rubble-rubble/147349220/
Context page hosting both clippings:
https://gonechester.com/2024/05/13/no-59-west-main/
The Gonechester article’s principal subject, No. 59 West Main, is a different property in Rochester; only its specifically identified Webster Corning material is used here.
6. MCDONALD’S SUBSEQUENT LOCATION
The Webster Museum’s restaurant timeline records the opening at the former Webster Dairy, 190 West Main, on December 2, 1983.
https://webstermuseum.org/ground-round.php
This supports the distinction between the proposed development at 66 and the eventual restaurant elsewhere.
7. ORGAN, CHANDELIER, AND CARRIAGES
The supplied caption and museum account both associate the organ and chandelier with the Henry Ford Museum. No accession record identifying these particular objects has been found. The supplied caption additionally mentions carriages, dark mahogany, and gold-leaf panels.
Henry Ford research guidance:
https://askus.thehenryford.org/FAQs/faq/210486
8. REMAINING GAPS
Exact construction date and original bank tenant of the present building; full apartment chronology; hospital operator and duration.
IMAGE HANDLING AND CREDITS
Website copies preserve full compositions and are only resized/re-encoded or converted from TIFF. They have not been AI-restored or reconstructed. Preserve credits, especially Webster Museum and Lance Wynn/Democrat and Chronicle.