109 West Main Street

Now & Then: 109 West Main Street, Webster, NY

Now

 Today, 109 West Main Street is home to Cobblestone on Main, a stylish restaurant opened in 2021 by Dan Bresnahan and his daughter Sarah. Housed in a beautifully restored cobblestone building, the space features a cozy farmhouse-style interior and live music, blending modern hospitality with historic charm.

Mid-20th Century to Early 2000s

 For much of the 20th century, the building served automotive needs rather than spiritual ones. It was home to Webster Automotive, preceded by Walco Auto Supply Co., which acquired the property in 1965. Before that, Johnson Brothers Garage transformed the former church into a car salesroom in the 1920s, removing the steeple and adding garage doors.

Church Era

 Built in 1845 by mason and congregant John Farr, the structure originally served as the First Universalist Church of Webster. Constructed with cobblestones gathered from Lake Ontario, it was a vibrant community hub, hosting events like Children’s Day and the Universalist Fair. During the Civil War, members supported Union soldiers with quilts and supplies. The church closed in 1925, following the illness of Rev. Donald Fraser, with occasional services continuing until the congregation disbanded.