19 West Main Street

Now & Then: 19 West Main Street, Webster, NY

Now

 Today, 19 West Main Street is home to the Coach Sports Bar, a longtime local favorite known for its casual atmosphere and community vibe. In March 2025, the building was damaged in a three-alarm fire. The building underwent 14 months of repairs before reopening to the public. Longtime owner Fritz Sierk credited first responders, staff, and the Webster community for helping support the business through its recovery and return to regular hours. The Coach Sports Bar has long operated as a familiar neighborhood gathering place in the heart of Webster Village. Known for its sports-bar atmosphere, wings, pizza specials, casual food, drinks, and loyal local following, The Coach has served generations of Webster patrons from its West Main Street location. 

Mid-20th Century to Present

 The current building was constructed in 1950 and has served various commercial purposes over the decades. The Coach Sports Bar has operated here for over 30 years, becoming a staple in the local dining and nightlife scene.

The Stagecoach Inn was devastated by a major fire in February 1969, which forced a rebuild of the historic structure. This 1969 fire was a significant,,, but not the only, early destructive event for the building, which also survived a fire in 1900. 

Early 19th to Early 20th Century

 Over time, the building changed hands and names, becoming known as the Stage Coach Inn, reflecting its deep roots in Webster’s early transportation and lodging history.

Russell Hotel Era

 In 1849, Alexis Russell purchased the tavern and renamed it the Russell Hotel. After his passing, the Russell family converted the property into a boardinghouse, continuing its role in hospitality.

Spear's Tavern, 1812

The site’s history stretches back to circa 1812, when James Spear built the first permanent frame building on West Main Street. It operated as a tavern and stagecoach stop, serving travelers and locals alike.