Today’s convenience store and gasoline station occupy a site once shared by two neighboring businesses: the Ridge Theatre and a Gulf service station. Their histories came together when Gulf purchased the theater property to expand its corner location.
Now — Convenience store and gasoline station
The property continues its automotive role as a Sunoco station and convenience store. Your May 2008 photographs show an earlier chapter as NOCO Express Shop, with a green canopy over the gasoline pumps.
NOCO Express Shop at 58 West Main Street, May 12, 2008. The convenience store and broad pump canopy show the property’s later development as a combined retail and gasoline business.
1968–1969 — The theater makes way for expansion
In August 1968, Louis and Irene Mentis sold the Ridge Theatre property to Gulf Oil Corporation for expansion of the service station immediately west. According to historian Lynn Barton’s account, the theater was demolished in May 1969, ending nearly twenty-three years of movies on this stretch of Main Street.
1962 — New theater owners
A Webster Herald retrospective records the Mentis purchase of the Ridge Theatre in January 1962, accompanied by a promise to present the best in family movie entertainment. Your exterior photograph captures its distinctive marquee, sidewalk ticket booth, and movie posters, with Gulf pumps visible beside the building.
The Ridge Theatre stood immediately east of the Gulf service station. Its marquee advertises The Eyes of Annie Jones and Shock Treatment. Louis and Irene Mentis sold the theater property to Gulf Oil Corporation in August 1968; it was demolished in May 1969 for expansion of the neighboring station.
1952 — Two businesses side by side
Advertisements in a 1952 Rochester Rose Show program document both businesses. Jack Hackett managed the Ridge Theatre, while Abrey’s Gulf Service, at West Main and Corning Park, offered lubrication, tires, batteries, accessories, and car washing. These advertisements add another operator’s name to the station’s history. mcnygenealogy.com
1946 — Opening night at the Ridge Theatre
The Ridge Theatre opened at 6:30 p.m. on Wednesday, June 12, 1946. Mayor W. R. Hawley cut the ribbon, and approximately 150 people waited in a line extending almost to Alexander’s Gulf Station.
Operated by Crawford Enterprises, the theater opened with The Harvey Girls, starring Judy Garland. Admission was 40 cents for adults and 20 cents for children. Contemporary reporting praised the comfortable seats and modern surroundings—a village movie house that spared residents a trip into Rochester.
1930s–1940s — Vroman and Alexander’s service station
Directories from 1938–1940 list Royal R. Vroman’s gasoline station at 58 West Main Street. They also identify Joyce Alexander as an attendant there. www.libraryweb.org
Your later newspaper profile introduces J. J. Alexander, known as “Alex,” the friendly Gulf dealer. It describes fresh white paint, orange pumps, a newly paved driveway, and his husky, Brownie, serving as the station’s watchdog.
Alexander’s Gulf Service Station at the corner of Corning Park and West Main Street, immediately west of the Ridge Theatre site. J. J. Alexander, known as “Alex,” was remembered as the friendly Gulf dealer. The photograph shows the lubrication bay, gasoline pumps, tire displays, and automobiles.
1912 — Before the pumps and marquee
The 1912 Sanborn map shows no building at the immediate Corning Park corner, with two frame houses farther east along Main Street. The frontage had yet to acquire the service station and movie theater that would make it a familiar village destination.