Now & Then Walking Tour: From a village home to a Pontiac showroom and a longtime diner
Look past the awnings of Golden Boys Family Restaurant and imagine a Pontiac parked outside a showroom, or a diner serving pizza into the evening. All three businesses are documented at 36 West Main Street. Earlier directories record families living at this address, and photographs offer clues to how the frontage changed.
Golden Boys Family Restaurant at 36 West Main Street, Webster. The recent storefront view shows the stone trim, brown awnings, and entrance marked 36.
Today | Golden Boys Family Restaurant
Golden Boys Family Restaurant still lists 36 West Main Street as its home. The present storefront has stone trim and brown awnings. Compare it with the fire photographs below: they show a low brick storefront with a taller, gabled structure behind it. [1] The Village of Webster Historic Preservation Commission recently recognized Golden Boys Restaurant as Site of the Month. Golden Boys opened in 1973. The restaurant was remodeled after a fire in the early 1980's. Prior to there being a restaurant at 36 West Main Street, there was a car dealership and movie theatre. The restaurant is called Golden Boys because customers called the owners "golden boys." The Historic Preservation is proud to recognize this site and its owners Kox Liapis, Gus-Steve Tegas and Kathie O'Neil.
1987 | A fire and a return
A 2019 CITY profile reports that the original Golden Boys burned down in 1987 and that the restaurant returned. Two photographs from the 1987 fire show Webster firefighters responding at 36 West Main Street. In the street view, the sign reads “Golden Boy Restaurant.” In the side view, smoke surrounds the upper part of the yellow, gabled structure behind the storefront. The reopening date and the extent of rebuilding remain unconfirmed. [2]
The 1987 Golden Boys fire at 36 West Main Street. The storefront sign reads “Golden Boy Restaurant.” Webster firefighters work above the low brick storefront, with a yellow gabled structure immediately behind it.
Side view of the 1987 Golden Boys fire at 36 West Main Street. Smoke rises from the upper portion of the yellow structure as firefighters work near the roof and an aerial platform.
1973 and 1976 | Golden Boys serves Main Street
A July 25, 1973 Webster Herald advertisement invited sidewalk-sale shoppers to take a meal break at Golden Boys Restaurant at 36 West Main. It places the restaurant here by that date. Family history credits Stylianos Tegas with opening Golden Boys; CITY identifies Gus and “Uncle Steve” as the original owners and traces the restaurant’s village history to 1973. [2, 3, 4]
By October 1976, the restaurant advertised a daily fish fry, with options that included scallops, clams, and shrimp. The ad also listed 24-hour service on Fridays and Saturdays. [4]
1957 and 1968 | Webster Diner
In December 1957, a classified ad directed applicants for two daytime waitress positions to Webster Diner at 36 West Main. In April 1968, the diner advertised nightly pizza, fish fry for pickup, and 24-hour weekend service. A small pizza was 75 cents. Years later, Golden Boys also advertised round-the-clock weekend service. The ads do not establish when the diner changed hands or names. [4]
1945–1953 | H. J. Henner Pontiac
Henry J. Henner advertised Pontiac sales and service here by December 1945 and again in April and June 1953. The showroom also advertised goods for the home: washers, refrigerators, radios, cabinets, and even tricycles. In 1948, Henner announced that mechanic Charles Miller would work behind the showroom. Henner’s 1971 obituary recalls an earlier career operating dried-apple evaporators around New York State. [4]
The dealership photograph shows a large display window and entrance below three tall upper windows. The gable and horizontal siding are useful clues when comparing this view with the house beside Reitz Garage and the yellow structure in the fire photos. The available views do not establish that all three show the same building.
H. J. Henner Pontiac Sales and Service at 36 West Main Street, date unknown. A car stands outside the showroom, beneath three tall upper windows.
1938–1940 | A residential address
The Rochester Suburban Directory lists John and Gladys Steele at 36 West Main in 1938, 1939, and 1940. Frederick and Frances Conrow appear there in 1938 and 1940, and Wilbert and Florence Culligan in 1939. John Steele was listed as a casket worker and Wilbert Culligan as an instrument worker. The entries establish where the families lived; ownership and the layout of the residence remain unknown. [5]
In two undated photographs of the neighboring Reitz Garage frontage, part of a shuttered house appears at the edge of the frame. The directories distinguish the garage at 32 West Main and Emil Reitz’s residence at 34 from the households at 36. That context makes the house in the photographs a plausible match for 36, although the crops show no house number. [5]
A shuttered house beside E. E. Reitz Garage, likely associated with 36 West Main Street.
Sources
[1] Golden Boys Family Restaurant, official site. https://www.goldenboysny.com/
[2] Dave Budgar, “Rising and shining in Webster: Golden Boys,” CITY, August 20, 2019. https://www.roccitymag.com/culture/rising-and-shining-in-webster-golden-boys-10710225/
[3] Bill’s Long Pond Diner, Tegas family history. https://www.billslongponddiner.com/about-us
[4] The Webster Herald, supplied advertisements, notice, and obituary. Issue dates are listed with the clippings. Archive information from Webster Public Library. https://websterlibrary.org/resources-services/genealogy-local-history/
[5] Rochester Suburban Directory, Webster section, 1938 edition. https://www.libraryweb.org/rochsubdir/1938/1938webster.pdf
[5] Rochester Suburban Directory, Webster section, 1939 edition. https://www.libraryweb.org/rochsubdir/1939/1939webster.pdf
[5] Rochester Suburban Directory, Webster section, 1940 edition. https://www.libraryweb.org/rochsubdir/1940/1940names-webster.pdf