Last Reviewed: 17/09/2026
Next Review Date: 16/09/2027
1. Purpose
1.1 This policy sets out the procedure for managing employees who are unable to meet the required standards of performance due to a lack of capability, skill, or competence. It ensures a fair, consistent, and supportive approach to performance management.
1.2 This policy does not form part of the contract of employment.
2. Scope
2.1 This policy covers performance capability for employees outside a valid contractual probation period, regardless of length of service. Performance during probation follows the separate procedure in sections 5 and 6 of the Recruitment Guide for Managers; see section 5 below. Sections 6 and 7 of this policy describe the standard capability route. Support and review periods will reflect the role, experience and individual circumstances.
2.2 Conduct concerns, such as a deliberate refusal to carry out reasonable instructions, will normally be managed under the Disciplinary Policy and Procedure. Sickness absence and ill-health capability will normally be managed under the Sickness Absence and Attendance Policy.
2.3 If health or disability may be contributing to performance concerns, HDS will consider appropriate medical advice, support and reasonable adjustments before deciding how to proceed. Where the policies overlap, HDS will explain the applicable process and coordinate it fairly, without duplicating formal action for the same issue.
3. Principles
3.1 Employees will be given the opportunity to improve their performance through training, support, and reasonable adjustments where necessary.
3.2 Performance concerns will be addressed promptly, fairly, consistently and without unlawful discrimination, following the relevant principles of the Acas Code of Practice.
3.3 HDS will establish the facts and consider possible causes, including unclear expectations, training, workload, resources, health and disability. Employees will have an opportunity to explain their position and provide relevant evidence.
3.4 Senior and line managers are responsible for applying this policy fairly. Managers should advise the Office Manager and may seek support from them, FSB Legal/HR Advice or another appropriate professional where necessary. If the Office Manager is involved in the matter, advise another uninvolved senior manager instead. The manager handling the matter remains responsible for action and follow-up. Information will only be shared where necessary for the relevant role. Anyone making a decision must be impartial and have appropriate authority.
3.5 Decisions must use objective, job-related evidence. Pregnancy, protected leave, disability-related disadvantage requiring adjustment, or raising a protected concern must not be treated as poor attitude or a lack of fit. Explain any change of procedure; do not retrospectively turn informal feedback into a warning or remove safeguards already promised.
4. Routine Performance and Development Reviews
4.1 Employees will normally have a recorded performance and development review every six months, supported by regular informal feedback and discussion. Concerns and support needs will be addressed as they arise. More frequent reviews will take place where appropriate, including during probation or a performance improvement plan.
5. Probation
5.1 During a valid contractual probation period, use the separate probation procedure in sections 5 and 6 of the Recruitment Guide for Managers and record reviews in HR19. The standard capability stages in this policy do not automatically apply. The probation procedure sets out its own review, decision, accompaniment and appeal arrangements. Contractual commitments and statutory rights continue to apply.
5.2 If this policy becomes applicable while performance concerns remain, explain the process to the employee and consider the support, reviews and formal steps already completed. Do not repeat steps unnecessarily, retrospectively treat informal feedback as a warning, or omit steps needed for fairness. Use the appropriate procedure for misconduct or ill-health, as set out in section 2.
6. Informal Stage
6.1 Where performance concerns are identified, the line manager will:
· Discuss concerns with the employee in a supportive manner.
· Identify any training, support or reasonable adjustments required.
· Set clear, realistic performance expectations and a reasonable timeframe for improvement.
· Monitor progress through regular feedback.
· Keep a brief record of the discussion, agreed actions and review arrangements. An informal discussion is not a formal capability warning.
6.2 If sufficient improvement is not made despite appropriate support, the formal capability procedure in section 7 may be initiated. The employee will be told that formal action is being considered. For employees in probation, see section 5.
7. Formal Capability Procedure
7.1 Before each formal meeting, the employee will receive written details of the performance concerns, any relevant evidence, possible outcomes and the right to be accompanied. Reasonable notice and preparation time will be allowed. Meetings will be held in private and notes kept. The employee may respond, present relevant evidence, identify relevant witnesses and comment on information relied upon. The meeting may be adjourned for further enquiries. HDS will consider the response before deciding an outcome and explain any delay.
Stage 1 Capability Meeting
7.2 The employee will be invited to a formal meeting with their manager and/or senior manager and given the opportunity to respond. Where concerns are substantiated, a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) will be set, detailing required improvements, realistic measurable targets, timescales, training, support, any adjustments and review dates. Progress will be reviewed regularly.
7.3 A first written capability warning may be issued where appropriate. A PIP is not itself a formal warning unless HDS expressly confirms that a warning has been issued. Where formal action is not justified, this will be confirmed to the employee.
Stage 2 Further Review
7.4 If performance does not improve sufficiently within the agreed timeframe, a second meeting will be held to review progress, the reasons and the effectiveness of support. Further support or an extension may be appropriate, and a revised PIP may be issued.
7.5 A final written capability warning may be issued where appropriate. The employee will be told clearly that failure to achieve and sustain the required improvement may lead to dismissal. Progress and support will continue to be reviewed.
7.6 First and final warnings will state the concerns, required improvement and timeframe, support and review arrangements, how long the warning remains active, the consequences of insufficient improvement or further concerns, and the right of appeal. First warnings will normally remain active for six months and final warnings for 12 months. The active warning period is separate from the PIP improvement period.
Stage 3 Final Capability Meeting
7.7 If performance remains unsatisfactory after appropriate support, review and warnings, a final meeting will be held. The employee will be told in advance if dismissal is being considered and given an opportunity to respond.
7.8 Possible outcomes include further support, extending the review period, suitable alternative work or dismissal on capability grounds. Dismissal will be a last resort after considering the individual circumstances, reasonable adjustments and reasonable alternatives. Any change to contractual terms requires contractual authority or the employee's agreement.
7.9 Only an appropriately authorised manager may dismiss. Dismissal will be with the applicable contractual or statutory notice, whichever is greater, or payment in lieu where appropriate and lawful. Capability is not, by itself, gross misconduct.
7.10 All formal outcomes will be confirmed in writing without unreasonable delay, with reasons, any required action and appeal arrangements. A dismissal letter will also confirm the termination date and notice or payment arrangements.
8. Recurrent Performance Concerns
8.1 Where performance improves but concerns recur, HDS will review the previous PIP, the time elapsed, whether any warning remains active and any changes in the role, health, support or working circumstances.
8.2 HDS will discuss the recurrence with the employee and decide whether to update or replace the PIP and which stage is appropriate. The employee will have clear current expectations, reasonable support and an opportunity to respond and improve. For performance during probation, see section 5. Short service does not justify removing applicable safeguards. Expired warnings will not normally be treated as live warnings when deciding further action.
9. Right to Representation
9.1 Employees have the right under this policy to be accompanied at formal capability and appeal meetings by a fellow worker, an official employed by a trade union, or a trade union representative certified by their union as competent to act as a companion. HDS does not need to recognise the union.
9.2 The employee should make a reasonable request and give the companion's name with as much notice as reasonably possible. The request does not have to be in writing or made within a fixed notice period.
9.3 If the chosen companion is unavailable, HDS will postpone the hearing to a reasonable alternative time proposed by the employee within five working days of the original date. Longer postponements will also be considered where appropriate for fairness or reasonable adjustments.
9.4 The companion may put forward and sum up the employee's case, respond to views expressed and confer privately with the employee. They do not normally answer questions on the employee's behalf, speak against the employee's wishes or prevent HDS from explaining its case.
9.5 HDS will consider communication or interpreter needs and reasonable adjustments for disabled employees or companions, including another support person where appropriate. Reasonable requests for accompaniment at informal or fact-finding meetings will also be considered.
10. Appeals
10.1 Employees have the right to appeal against any formal action taken under this policy. Appeals should normally be submitted in writing within five working days of receiving the decision, explaining the grounds. Reasonable requests for an extension will be considered, including where illness or disability affects the employee’s ability to appeal.
10.2 Appeals should be sent to the Director. If the Director was involved in the original decision, the appeal should instead be sent to another appropriate senior manager who was not involved. The appeal will be considered impartially by someone with authority to confirm, change or overturn the original decision. The original decision-maker will not determine the appeal. If no suitable internal person is available, HDS will seek advice on arrangements that ensure a fair and impartial appeal.
10.3 An appeal meeting will be arranged without unreasonable delay, with the right to be accompanied. The reviewer will consider the grounds, any new evidence and whether further enquiries are needed. The outcome and reasons will be confirmed in writing as soon as reasonably possible and will be final under HDS's internal procedure.
10.4 If a grievance is raised during capability proceedings, HDS will consider whether to pause the process, investigate the grievance separately or address related matters together, ensuring fairness. A challenge to a capability decision should normally use this appeal process; this does not prevent a separate grievance or protected disclosure being raised.
11. Confidentiality
11.1 All matters relating to capability management will be handled with discretion and as confidentially as reasonably practicable. Records, including PIPs, meeting notes and outcomes, will be kept securely, shared only where reasonably necessary and retained in accordance with HDS's data-protection and retention arrangements.
11.2 This does not prevent an employee obtaining appropriate advice or support, speaking with their companion, making a protected disclosure or exercising another statutory right.
12. Review
12.1 This policy will be reviewed at least annually and sooner if legislation, guidance or experience indicates that changes are needed.
Joe Charlesworth
Director - Highway Data Systems Ltd