Week 3
Cognitivism
Cognitivism
Cognitivism is a learning theory that originated in the 1950's as a reaction to behaviorism's rigid view of the learner. It focuses on how the mind processes information. It views learning as an internal mental process that involves actively constructing knowledge through connecting new information with what is already known.
Fig. 1. Jean_Piaget.jpg (Source: Norby, 2024)
Fig. 2. Lev-Semyonovich-Vygotsky-1896-1934.jpg (Source: Wikimedia Commons, 2023)
Piaget was a Swiss psychologist credited for his theory of cognitive development which suggests that children build their understanding of the world by actively exploring and engaging with their environment. Therefore, they play an active role in their own cognitive development.
He introduced the concept of schemas. Schemas are conceptual frameworks used to organize and interpret incoming information. They develop from simple to complex as the child ages.
He describes this process of acquiring knowledge as adaptations (adjustments) to the world. Adaptations can happen by any one of four means: assimilation, accommodation, equilibrium, and disequilibrium.
Piaget believed that children proceed through four universal stages of cognitive development, Each stage distinct and increasing in complexity from the one before it. (McLeod, 2024)
Connections to Teaching & Learning
Active learning is important for successful learning to take place. This is preferred to early models of rote learning and corporal punishment.
Keeping in mind the characteristics of each stage of cognitive development, prekindergarten and K-12 instructors must design instruction that is appropriate to the cognitive abilities of their students.
Discovery learning involving concrete, hands-on, experiential activities, and the use of manipulatives in the classroom are important, especially for the youngest of learners.
Vygotsky was a Russian psychologist credited for his sociocultural theory. He emphasized the importance of social interaction in cognitive development. One key concept of his theory is the Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD). Imagine learning occurring along a scale, where there is knowledge you can learn on your own and on the other end, knowledge beyond your reach. The ZPD is the area in between, where through your interactions with and support from more knowledgeable others (MKO), you can bridge the gap between actual and potential learning. (McLeod, 2024)
Connections to Teaching & Learning
Collaboration is important for learning to take place. So allow for students to interact, problem-solve, and to build on knowledge together.
Instructors must present material that is just above a student's developmental level for learning to be meaningful and productive. This obviously points to the importance of knowing where a student is in the learning process.
Allow for heterogenous groupings where more advanced peers can help their less advanced peers progress further.
There are several ways that instructors (as MKOs) can scaffold learning in students. Some examples are as follows:
a) Engage and maintaining the student's interest,
b) Keep student frustration levels under control by adapting the activity and making it more accessible.
c) Demonstrating the task in a simple but clear way.
Fig. 3. Jerome Bruner 1936.png (Source: Wikimedia Commons, 2024)
Fig. 4. Albert Bandura Psychologist.jpg (Source: Wikimedia Commons, 2024)
Bruner was an American psychologist whose research on child cognitive development led him to propose that knowledge is represented and organized in three modes of representation or stages of thinking: enactive (action-based), iconic (image-based), and symbolic (language-based). Bruner's idea of learning readiness differs from Piaget in that he believed that a child was capable of learning any subject matter at any age if the material was organized and presented to them in an appropriate and accessible form and mode of representation.
In his idea of spiral curriculum, Bruner explained how just like a spiral staircase, concepts are revisited by the child at every age, and each time acquiring further complexity and abstraction. Bruner believed that the aim of education is to create autonomous learners who problem-solve through actively organizing the information given them. Along with Wood and Ross, Bruner added onto Vygotsky's work regarding the zones of proximal development (ZPD) by introducing the term of scaffolding. Scaffolding describes how the more knowledgeable other (MKO) helps the learner progress through the ZPD (McLeod, 2024).
Connections to Teaching & Learning
The teacher's role is to help students "learn how to learn": i.e., to know how to independently organize and construct knowledge from given material.
Guided discovery learning is an instructional approach where the teacher acts as a facilitator in the above process.
There are several ways that instructors (as MKOs) can scaffold learning in students. Some examples are as follows:
a) Engage and maintaining the student's interest,
b) Keep student frustration levels under control by adapting the activity and making it more accessible.
c) Demonstrating the task in a simple but clear way, or modeling strategies that could assist the learner in simplifying the task for themselves.
Bandura was a Canadian-American psychologist credited for his social learning theory (later on termed as the social cognitive theory). His theory emphasizes the importance of observational learning, which states that individuals acquire knowledge, skills, behaviors, and beliefs through observing models.
There are three primary models of observational learning: (1) Live models (i.e., an actual person), (2) verbal instruction models (i.e., listening to a description of the behavior), (3) symbolic models (i.e., learning through media/technology such as books, television, movies, and online media)
Bandura further posited that a mediational process occurs after the learner observes the behavior. The process determines whether the behavior will be imitated or not. He described the four components involved: attention, retention, reproduction, and motivation. Factors pertaining to any one of these components can increase or decrease the likelihood that a learner imitate an observed behavior. For instance, increased likelihood of behavior imitation will occur if the learner identifies with the model or sees similarities between the model and themselves. Observing the positive and negative consequences of another's behavior can also affect the likelihood of imitation (i.e., what is termed as vicarious reinforcement). Learners are more likely to imitate rewarded behaviors than punished behaviors.
He also introduced the theory of self-efficacy, which is a learner's belief in his/her ability to accomplish a task. (McLeod, 2024)
Connections to Teaching & Learning
Role models should be relatable and identifiable to the learner.
Positive role models in education, are especially important in breaking the negative stereotypes faced by historically disadvantaged populations (such as women and people of color).
Praising students for the effort they put into a project, more than praising their intelligence, increases self-efficacy.
Learning about the challenges overcome by others in similar situations will help bolster the learner's own performance.
Sweller is an Australian educational psychologist credited for the Cognitive Load Theory. Building on Atkinson & Shiffrin's (1968) model of information processing theory and George Miller's research that the human brain is limited in how many chunks of information it can process at one time, Sweller's theory posits that long term memory acquisition happens best when the learner's working memory is not overly tasked. Therefore, instructional techniques must focus on reducing working load memory (Spencer, 2022; Soloman, H., n.d.).
Connections to Teaching & Learning
Keep cognitive load of learners to a minimum during the learning process. Some ways include:
Provide clear instructions
Reduce redundant information
Allow for multi-modal presentation of material (i.e., visually, auditory, kinesthetically)
Present information in chunks that students can learn separately
Demonstrate problem solving
Allowing advanced students the option to skip over more elementary material.
Mayer is an American educational psychologist most known for his Cognitive Theory of Multi-media learning. He describes three assumptions that have applications in the world of e-learning (McGraw-Hill, Canada, 2019):
Connections to Teaching & Learning
Limited-Capacity Assumption--People have limited capacity to process information, therefore use less pictures and words to bring the point across.
Active-Processing Assumption--Learners actively engage with the material by constructing mental models that allow them to integrate new information with their existing knowledge. Mayer describes five such model structures:
Process structure (i.e., a cause-and-effect chain)
Comparison structure (i.e., a matrix comparing multiple points between two or more items)
Generalization structure (i.e., a branching tree organizing main ideas and subordinate ideas)
Enumeration structure (i.e., a list of items of equal value)
Classification structure (i.e., hierarchies)
Dual-Channel Assumption--People have two separate channels to process auditory and visual information. It is best to keep text and visuals close to each other when presenting information.
Cognitivism highlights the importance of each learner’s unique thought processes in the education process. The goal of instructional design is then to facilitate the student's successful learning of new material by providing the necessary support. The following are ways that cognitivism can be applied to instructional design:
Know Your Audience. Consider the audience when designing the learning experience in order to deliver content for optimal learning to take place. They can do so by conducting user research, pilot tests, and usability studies.
Chunking. Break down large and complex pieces of information into smaller pieces that make the material easier to understand and deliver to the audience. Allow the learner to proceed through at their chosen pace.
Alternative Delivery Methods. Provide the learner various options on how to access the same information. For instance, using audio in the presentations, or combining images with text, and videos. This takes individual learning differences into account.
Brain Breaks. Plan for breaks at strategic places to help give students time to reflect and process information. This may also mean following a cognitively demanding task with one that is less mentally challenging.
Active and Interactive Learning. Design instruction with a clear and notable structure to aid learners in forming their own mental models of the information. Plan for peer interaction, problem-solving and application exercises. Allow for multiple ways and products by which students can showcase their learning (e.g., demonstration, role play, visual display, etc.)
Below are my reflections on the strengths and weaknesses of applying cognitivism in instructional design, with examples given in the context of teacher training and professional development:
Strengths:
Cognitivism encourages a learner-centered approach to instructional design. Individual differences are taken into account when designing teacher training. For instance, seasoned teachers can have the option to skip over more rudimentary training, or they could be provided with more opportunities to reflect and apply concepts to problems they currently experience in the classroom.
Active learning through mentorship programs is critical to help prepare new teachers for the real world of classroom teaching. New teachers can benefit from observing a seasoned educator. The latter can serve as a more knowledgeable other to provide guidance and support to new teacher hires.
Limitations:
Since cognitivism deals with internal processes of the mind, it may be difficult to directly observe or assess whether specific objective learning outcomes have been met.
Cognitivism may not be able to address the affective motivations of individuals towards a subject matter. This may include an individual's unique beliefs, attitudes, and emotions towards the material.
The learning material is a Google slide presentation (containing a total of 23 slides) meant to provide an overview for teachers on the use of Canvas in the classroom. Canvas is a learning management system (LMS) used to create, distribute, and manage the delivery of instructional content.
Link to the material: https://sites.google.com/pgcps.org/pgcpst3/canvas/canvas-for-educators
Fig. 5. Getting started with Canvas video playlist [PowerPoint slides], slide 1. (Source: PGCPS Technology Training Team)
This material addresses two principles of cognitive load:
Reducing extraneous cognitive load
Extraneous cognitive load are the non-relevant elements of a presentation that distract the audience from the learning experience. Each slide uses a minimal amount of text accompanied by a link to a video expounding further on the idea. See a sample slide below:
Fig. 6. Getting started with Canvas video playlist [PowerPoint slides], slide 6. (Source: PGCPS Technology Training Team)
2. Optimizing germane cognitive load
Germane cognitive load is the mental effort required by the audience to process the material and commit it to long-term memory. The material in question supports the learner's germane cognitive load by the following practices:
Chunking. The Google presentation breaks up the content into smaller parts using a main landing slide that contains a visual table of contents with working links to each slide. This allows for self-paced delivery of the information--i.e., learners can skip over slides containing material they already know, or go back to content they need to revisit and review. There is a "Return" arrow that allows them to go back to the main landing slide that further facilitates this process. Sections are also clearly defined by headings.
Use of multimedia elements. The presentation used both visual and verbal channels of learning to support knowledge retention. Specifically, it pairs text with visuals and audio in the form of a video presentation.
Include the necessary resources within the material itself. Links to the videos are embedded within the slides, allowing for a smooth learning experience. The final slide of the presentation also provides the audience with links to further resources they can access later on (see image below).
Fig. 7. Getting started with Canvas video playlist [PowerPoint slides], slide 23. (Source: PGCPS Technology Training Team)
Conclusion
Overall, this material effectively utilized strategies that helped the learner manage cognitive load in an initial overview of the Canvas LMS.
Images
Jean_Piaget.jpg. (2024, October 1). Retrieved 01:11, February 19, 2025 from Norby, S., https://lex.dk/Jean_Piaget
Lev-Semyonovich-Vygotsky-1896-1934.jpg. (2023, April 4). Wikimedia Commons. Retrieved 01:41, February 19, 2025 from https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=File:Lev-Semyonovich-Vygotsky-1896-1934.jpg&oldid=746768919.
Jerome Bruner 1936.png. (2024, August 8). Wikimedia Commons. Retrieved 01:41, February 19, 2025 from https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=File:Jerome_Bruner_1936.png&oldid=907574675.
Albert Bandura Psychologist.jpg. (2024, October 1). Wikimedia Commons. Retrieved 01:42, February 19, 2025 from https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=File:Albert_Bandura_Psychologist.jpg&oldid=931142907.
Prince George's County Public Schools Technology Training Team. (n.d.). Getting started with Canvas video playlist [PowerPoint slides]. PGCPS T3. https://sites.google.com/pgcps.org/pgcpst3/canvas/canvas-for-educators.
Text
McGraw-Hill Canada. (2019, April 16). Richard Mayer’s Cognitive Theory of Multimedia Learning. https://www.mheducation.ca/blog/richard-mayers-cognitive-theory-of-multimedia-learning
McLeod, S. (2024, January 24). Piaget’s Theory and Stages of Cognitive Development. SimplyPsychology. https://www.simplypsychology.org/piaget.html
McLeod, S. (2024, January 24). Vygotsky’s Theory of Cognitive Development. SimplyPsychology. https://www.simplypsychology.org/vygotsky.html
McLeod, S. (2024, February 1). Albert Bandura’s Social Learning Theory. SimplyPsychology. https://www.simplypsychology.org/bandura.html
McLeod, S. (2024, February 1). Jerome Bruner’s Theory of Learning and Cognitive Development. SimplyPsychology. https://www.simplypsychology.org/bruner.html
Soloman, H. (n.d.). Cognitive Load Theory (John Sweller). InstructionalDesign.org. https://www.instructionaldesign.org/theories/cognitive-load/
Spencer, J. (2022, November 15). The Surprising Reason Students Tune Out Lectures [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x1pCaUp0Rtk&t=2s