Conflict Resolution
Conflict Resolution
This section will give you advice on how to recognise and respond to challenging behaviour but the main thing to remember is this: As long as you do not become rude or aggressive yourself, you will never be reprimanded for removing yourself from an unacceptable situation.
As a minimum, all staff working party nights should be encouraged to watch the video from National Pubwatch below.
Ten minute trainers for each area of conflict resolution can be taking from individual sections below.
The Breakaway Techniques video covers simple and safe techniques to escape from a violent situation. If sharing with teams it must be stressed that staff must never engage in physical contact with an aggressive guest (such as restraining or removing someone from the premises), but techniques shown will allow them to breakaway and get to safety.
Conflict Management - Pubwatch Training Video
Safe Breakaway Techniques
All Conflict 10 Minute Trainers
How do you know when a situation has become unacceptable? Conflict generally occurs when people have big feelings that they can’t process properly so those feelings have to come out somewhere. This can be the result of pain, confusion, anger, frustration, disappointment… any number of things. Sometimes in those situations it is right for us to be patient, put ourselves in the guest’s shoes and try to help them work through that by offering a resolution. But there are times when people behave in a way which we are not expected to tolerate.
There is a big difference between an angry person being loud in your presence and someone shouting at you so it is essential teams recognise where the line is? At what point does the behaviour become unacceptable?
Unacceptable behaviour could include:
Intimidation
Threats
Swearing or abusive language
Invasion of personal space
Personal attacks or insults
Discrimination
Sexual Harassment
You will never be expected to tolerate anything which puts your safety or dignity at risk while at work.
Ten Minute Trainer
Triggers things that are either said or done, which, when combined with other problems, spark off aggression. So if a person is already feeling frustrated by long waits, poor service, or personal circumstances, there are many triggers that will spark off a sharp reaction! Remember – you cannot know what someone has been through just before his or her encounter with you and therefore the sort of emotional state that person is in as a result of events/circumstances outside your control.
Common triggers
Being embarrassed
Losing face
Feeling insulted
If they think that people are laughing at them
If they feel like they are not being listened to or taken seriously
Being refused service
Remember: Alcohol tends to increase the likelihood that someone will become unpredictable and less controlled and, therefore, customers who have had a drink may be easier to ‘trigger’.
Inhibitors
Not everybody gets violent when they become angry and inhibitors are things that prevent people from completely losing their temper. This is because everyone has inhibitions based on:
Self-control – most people have built-in control mechanisms which prevent them from turning to violent behaviour
Personal values – the way in which we have been brought up, the values and beliefs that we have learned
Fear that the other person will fight back (retaliation) – most of us do not want to be hurt and realise a fight will risk this
Social or legal consequences – these include being charged with an assault, losing one’s job or licence.
Remember: Alcohol reduces the effect of these natural inhibitions and some people will act and behave in ways that they would not normally dream of doing when they are sober.
Escalation
Anger has a similar effect on people as fear. The body is ‘geared up’ for action. This is why people who are angry can become violent so quickly. The path of escalation can be traced from frustration to violence through four levels:
Frustration > Aggression > Anger > Violence
Level 1
Frustration: Most conflict involves a degree of frustration and this forms the lowest level of arousal. It may not be evident or obvious and the individual can keep it very much under control
Level 2
Aggression: The next level is a deeper level of emotion and will be fairly obvious to an observer. If controlled, it will not be directed specifically at the other party but the individual will be less rational
Level 3
Anger: At the next level, the anger is turned towards the other party. The aggression will be evident through voice level, tone, verbal and non-verbal behaviour
Level 4
Violence: The highest level of arousal occurs when the anger spills over into violence and the other party is physically assaulted by the aggressor
Most aggressors will stay in each level unless something happens that triggers the person into the next level of escalation. To avoid escalation, we need to try and keep the person in the level they are in and preferably to take them down to a lower level. This means:
Avoiding any comments or behaviour that are likely to trigger the person into the next level
Employing de-escalation strategies
When dealing with someone in a conflict situation, you cannot be sure what level they are in. They may be having a bad day, or may be worried or frustrated about something that has nothing to do with you. By the time the person meets you, they may already be in level 2 and, if triggered, will escalate into the aggression of level 3 and turn it towards you.
Ten Minute Trainer
Experienced bar tenders and function staff will tell you they can "just tell" when a night is going sideways or "just feel the mood change". They aren't psychic - this perception has been honed through experience, subconsciously reading little signs and correctly interpreting them as red flags.
But what are they noticing? There are a number of signs that could suggest tensions are rising, someone is getting angry or has the potential to become aggressive. Not all of them will be present in every case but they are worth being aware of so you can read the signs before a situation develops.
Signs to look out for:
Tense jaw or clenched teeth
Red face
Flared nostrils
Dilated pupils
Puffed chest
Teeth licking
Eyebrows lowered or eyes narrowed
Clenched fists
Sneering
Stamping
Invading personal space
Shouting or increased volume
High pitched or aggressive tone
Jokes with confrontational or aggressive undertones
Ten Minute Trainer
If you find yourself faced with a difficult guest, are safe and feel confident enough to try to de-escalate the situation, first and foremost, stay calm. This can be difficult on an already busy or stressful shift so make sure to take a few seconds regularly to drink some water and take 3 slow, deep breaths.
Take slow, deep breaths, relax your shoulders and keep your body language open. Humans are funny creatures and our primitive brains can’t tell the difference between a person with cold risotto and a tiger trying to eat you, so this will send signals to your body that everything is okay and help you control your “fight or flight” response.
Shake your shoulders loose, relax your body and take 3 slow, deep breaths.
How does that feel?
Take deep breaths activates your body’s parasympathetic nervous system – also known as your rest and digest system – which tells your body everything is okay. Slow, deep breathing floods your system with calming, relaxing chemicals and is an easy and subtle way to regain composure and control.
‘Dynamic Risk Assessment’ is a process which helps you assess a situation from a personal safety perspective as it is unfolding.
To complete a Dynamic Risk Assessment, remember: SAFER
Step Back
Assess the threat
Find Help
Evaluate the options
Respond Appropriately
Why is Dynamic Risk Assessment important?
Guests can be unpredictable and on rare occasions, teams can find themselves in situations which are unique and not covered in our risk assessment or assessment of a planned event. These are often the situations where people get hurt because they do not have a way of assessing the risks in the situation they are confronted with, and do not respond appropriately.
How Do You Assess A Threat?
An easy to remember method to assess any threat is the POP method:
Person
Continually assess people to judge whether you may be at risk. If you have met the person before, what do you know about them? Do you know them? Do they have a history of anger or aggression? Are they a known criminal? How do they appear? Are they suffering the effects of drink or drugs? Are they bigger, fitter, younger or stronger than you?
Object
Are there any object either on the person or nearby which could be weaponised? Knives and other edged weapons, syringes. apparently ‘innocent’ articles- bottles or cans, glasses, combs, umbrella, handbags etc.
Place
Assess the situation with regard to where you are – including the time of day, other people around, lighting etc
Noisy, hot, confined environments, dance floors, public areas, isolated areas, staircases, toilets, exit routes
Evaluate the options available
There will always be a variety of ways in which you could deal with any situation. An important rule is not to put yourself in a risky situation unless you have some help available or someone else knows that you are dealing with a difficult situation. Remember that your own safety is your prime consideration.
Your most appropriate option will depend upon the situation itself, the availability of assistance, your experience and what training you have received.
If you are confident that you are able to deal with the situation safely then you should do so – but continue to monitor and assess what is happening in case the situation changes. If you need assistance then you should not try to deal with the situation until help arrives. If the situation is potentially violent and there is a risk of physical assault then you should exit from it as soon as you can do so safely.
Physical intervention (holding, restraining, escorting, physical removal from premises) should only ever be carried out by people who have received appropriate training in how to do it effectively, lawfully and safely, such as badged security.
Ten Minute Trainer
Invite them to take a seat with you
It’s a lot more difficult to maintain aggressive posture in a sitting position and this in itself may help calm the situation. If they are part of a group it is also very helpful to move them away from the rest of the crowd so they have nobody to perform to or to keep them wound up.
Keep the tone of your voice low and the volume reasonably quiet
When emotions run high, our voice tends to become louder and more high pitched. By actively ensuring your voice stays low and quiet, we send signals to both the other person and our own body that the situation is calm and under control. Allowing our own volume to escalate can also encourage the other person to get louder to be heard. By speaking quietly, we encourage them to do the same.
Stay in Control of Your Body Language
Keep your body and jaw relaxed, and take one step back to show that you are giving them physical and emotional space. Keep your shoulders loose and arms uncrossed and open, palms outward. This will demonstrate that you are not a threat and prevent the situation escalating. Hopefully, if you can build a rapport with the person, they will begin to mirror YOUR non-threatening stance.
Eye Contact
Eye contact is a really powerful form of non verbal communication. Refusing to break eye contact is very intense and could lead to escalation. Refusing to make eye contact can look like you aren't listening and lead to further escalation. Breaking eye contact in an upwards direction looks like rolling your eyes and breaking it downwards is overly submissive. Therefore, after an appropriate time of holding somene's gaze, you should break eye contact to the side (the only exception being if you have something to write on and can use note taking as an excuse to break eye contact).
Maintain Space
Keeping a distance of at least "arm length plus a step" between yourself and the aggressor achieves 2 things. Firstly, staying out of their personal space sends the message that you are not a threat and doesn't trigger their fight or flight response. Secondly, if things do escalate, you are outside the range of a kick, punch or grab without the aggressor having to first take a step forward, giving you time to react.
Listen Actively
Show that you are listening, that you are taking their concerns seriously and that you want to help. By empathising and trying to help, you will build a rapport and help bring the person back to calm.
Do not take it personally!
How others behave is a demonstration of their character and values and nothing at all to do with you. A guest losing their cool is not a reflection of your competency or character. It may not be pleasant to be on the receiving end, but people often say things they don’t mean or act in ways they will later be ashamed of when their emotions get the best of them. If you can bring them back to calm without judgement and turn the situation around for them then I guarantee they will be grateful. If you can’t, that’s no reflection on you and not worth getting upset over.
Be prepared in your mind to switch from a passive approach to being more firm.
If someone is feeling particularly upset, they may not even recognise that they are shouting, invading your space or swearing. A firm but non aggressive “Please stop shouting at me”, “Please step back” or “Please don’t swear at me” can be enough to help them recognise they are behaving unacceptably and wind it back. Whatever you say though, don’t say “calm down!”
Escalate the situation to a manager
The company hierarchy exists for a reason! If any employee finds themselves in a situation where they feel out of their depth or someone is behaving unacceptably towards them, they must be empowered to walk away and find a manager to deal with it. When doing so, make sure the safety and wellbeing of your team are your primary priority - prevent escalation but be firm with the guest: we have a zero tolerance policy on abuse of staff and if a guest breaches that we will be unable to honour the remainder of the booking. Your team must not be expected to continue to serve guests who put their wellbeing at risk,
Every person on your team should memorise the sentence "I can see you're upset and I want to make sure we get this right for you - please take a seat and I will escalate this to a manager"... but must know if they are on the receiving end of poor behavior they are completely empowered to walk away without explanation.
Leave!
If at any point you feel unsafe or that the guest has crossed a line, it’s time to get out of there.
Do not argue or otherwise challenge the guest. If you are able to, a sincere “I can see you’re very upset, please have a seat and I will get a manager to help you” will let you politely leave. But if you are unsafe or the guest is being abusive or aggressive rather than just loud and angry in your direction, simply excuse yourself and immediately get a manager, no explanation needed.
Ten Minute Trainer
Make sure you and your team have a bank of assertive but non confrontational phrases which you have practiced in a calm and safe environment so you do not struggle for words (or say the wrong thing) in the heat of the moment.
Examples could include:
Please lower your voice
Please take a step back
Please don't swear at me
I really want to make this right for you but I'm not able to do that while you are shouting at me. Please could we sit and discuss how I can help you?
I want to sort this out for you so I am going to escalate it to my manager to make sure we get it right.
I understand why you are so angry, but if you continue to shout and swear, I will have no option but to ask you to leave – which I don’t want to have to do
We have a zero tolerance policy on abusive behavior towards staff and so will be unable to: continue to serve you/honour the rest of your booking.
We have a zero tolerance policy on abusive behavior towards staff and so will have to ask you to leave
Remember: If you are in an unsafe situation or someone is behaving unacceptably towards you, you do not need to apologise, excuse yourself or explain. It is also an option to walk away without saying anything and immediately seek assistance from a manager or, if the situation calls for it, call the police.
Ten Minute Trainers
Maintain Your Exit Routes
If you sense at any time that a situation could become dangerous, you must always ensure you have a clear exit route and/or safe barriers (such as a bar or reception desk) between you and the aggressor. A good example of this could be addressing an issue in a guest room. Going alone, entering the room and letting the door shut could put you at risk. By staying in the corridor or doorway, wedging the door open (or having a colleague holding the door open) and ensuring you always have a clear route to the door, you minimise risk to yourself should a situation escalate.
The same applies anywhere in the hotel. Consider your surroundings and ensure you always have a clear exit and a place to go where you can put a closed door between yourself and a potential aggressor.
As well as clear, safe exit routes for yourself, where possible it is also a good idea to ensure the guest has a clear exit route too. While you know they aren’t at any risk of physical harm from you, the subconscious fight or flight instinct is a strong one and removing someone’s “flight” option in a high stress situation can leave them feeling their only option is “fight”. You never want to find yourself in a situation where an aggressive person’s only exit route is through you!
Ensure someone is always aware of where you are and have a plan to summon assistance quickly when needed.
Ten Minute Trainer
Refusal to serve
One of the most difficult issues faced by staff in licensed premises is the refusal to serve. This can be necessary for a variety of reasons:
A belief that the customer is under age
A belief that the customer is purchasing for someone under age
A refusal because the person is drunk
A refusal because of disorderly, inappropriate or bad behaviour
A credit card refusal for payment.
The common problem in all these situations is the lack of discretion available – once the need to refuse has been recognised, the member of staff has no alternative but to go through with the subsequent action. Some of the measures that will help to reduce the potential conflict might be:
Ensure you are very clear about the law in relation to licensed premises and age restrictions. You need to be very sure of your ground if the refusal escalates
Reduce the possibility of triggers through embarrassment or loss of face by taking the person aside or to a quieter part of the bar or restaurant
Take the ‘personal’ out of the situation. Instead of ‘You don’t look eighteen to me. I’m not serving you unless you show me some ID’ you could say, ‘We have a policy that people who may be under 25 must show a valid ID before they can be served’
If you are going to refuse someone because they are drunk or engaged in bad behaviour, ensure that it is safe to do so and that you have support from colleagues before you refuse to serve
If a ‘card refusal’ advises you to seize the credit card – then you should do so, unless you feel that the situation will escalate if you do.
Refusing entry or evicting from premises
The licensee and any person in charge of the licensed premises has a legal duty not to allow anyone who is:
Drunk
Violent
Quarrelsome
Disorderly
Or suspected or known to be a drug dealer
to enter or remain on licensed premises.
Trespass – Common Law:
Visitors to premises, including licensed premises, are there with the permission of the owner. If that permission is withdrawn, then they become trespassers
Staff, acting on behalf of the owner, can refuse entry or require a person to leave
Although legally, the minimum force reasonably required can be used if the person fails to leave when requested, this should be avoided by KGH staff and the police called (unless you have sufficient appropriately trained and licensed security staff who can achieve this whilst ensuring the safety of themselves, the public and the individual concerned).
If requested police have a duty to assist a license holder or their staff eject a drunk or disorderly person from the premises, or prevent them from entering.
You should warn the person, by asking them to stop the offending behaviour and telling them that they will have to leave unless they stop
If they continue, then they should be asked to leave – encouraging them to do so of their own accord. Do not let yourself be drawn into a debate
Stay relaxed but assertive. Do not be aggressive or do anything to inflame the situation
Use open hand gestures to reinforce this
Allow the customer where possible to save face – for example by stating they can come back another time or by helping them by giving a taxi number
If they still refuse, the police should be called
Staff should not be involved in physically removing someone from premises
Ten Minute Trainer
It is extremely unlikely that you will have a positive attitude towards everyone that you meet in the course of your work. If you are dealing with someone towards whom you feel negative, you are likely to show those negative feelings in the way that you behave towards the other person. This is shown in the Attitude and Behaviour Cycle:
If you have a negative attitude towards someone, your unconscious behaviour will let that person know how you feel about him or her. When the other person recognises this negative behaviour from you, this will in turn affect their attitude towards you. A negative attitude will come out in their behaviour towards you. Their negative behaviour is then likely to make the negative feelings you had in the first place even more negative.
It is very difficult to change your attitude towards someone. It is, however, possible to change the way you behave towards them:
You can learn to behave so that your negative feelings do not show, so that your behaviour doesn’t reflect your negative feelings
Remember that each party sees the other as the problem. As the staff member, it is your responsibility to break this cycle and diffuse the situation
Recognise that your own behaviour may be the source of the problem and that the customer’s attitude is merely a reaction to your attitude and associated behaviour.
This breaks the cycle and stops it getting worse. A positive attitude makes the cycle work the other way – producing positive behaviours, which in turn produce positive attitudes.
Being the victim of violence or abuse is particularly traumatic because it involves an interaction with another person at a very personal level and this can produce some difficult and complex emotional reactions. Each person has a different way of responding to, and dealing with, the aftermath of a violent or aggressive incident. If you or a team member do encounter a difficult guest or face an issue at work that upsets you, remember there are lots of people and systems in place ready to support you so please use them, and ensure any team member who experiences unacceptable guest behavior is well taken care of afterwards.
Have a chat with a colleague to help you feel better, or if you need a bit more support you can always chat with your GSM, BEM or even the People Team
Find out if your hotel has any Mental Health First Aiders
Call the Employee Assistance Line which is available every day, 24 hours a day
Or even have a look at the health and wellbeing section of your HapiHub Health Benefits app for wellbeing advice and support.
While physical intervention such as restraint or physical removal from the premises must not be attempted by staff, on very rare occasions employees may find themselves on the receiving end of violence.
In these circumstances, your only priority is to break free and get to a place of safety.
This video from the Scottish Ambulance Service details simple and safe breakaway techniques which can be used to escape from a violent situation.
We strongly advise no staff ever engage in any physical altercation and it is our policy that, if you are at any risk, you immediately leave the situation. However, in the event you are ever physically assaulted in the course of your duties, the below, from the National Pubwatch, outlines the law with regards to self defense:
Any person may use such force as is reasonable and necessary in the circumstances in defence of themselves or others and, in certain circumstances, in defence of property.
The force used must be reasonable and no more than is necessary to repel the attack: You must be able to show an honestly held belief that immediate unlawful personal violence was occurring or about to occur towards you or another person and that your actions were necessary to prevent such conduct.
The law relating to self-defence is reasonably clear and unambiguous however, some confusion exists about the legitimacy of retaliation as opposed to self-defence:
This confusion was highlighted in 1999 by the case of the Norfolk farmer who shot a young man dead whilst he was climbing out of the window of his house and similar cases. It is important to realise that, whatever your personal feelings are about such incidents, they do not constitute ‘lawful self-defence’.
The law does not allow us to retaliate – only to defend ourselves from attack.
This confusion extends to the workplace where employees who are faced with angry and violent customers take retaliatory action, rather than action that can be regarded as self defense.
It is important to realise the issues of whether you used lawful force and whether that force was reasonable will ultimately be decided in a court of law and, in circumstances where the facts are not clear-cut, you may find yourself defending yourself on charge of assault:
In deciding if the force used was reasonable, the court will look at a range of factors and this is a very difficult area of the law, as each case is taken on its own merits
Factors that may be considered are the age, sex, size and behaviour of the assailant(s) and those of the victim(s) who retaliated; the skills and support that you had available; the location and the risk presented to yourself and others. However, this list is far from exhaustive and the court may consider many different types of evidence, depending on the circumstances surrounding the individual case
The onus will be on you to prove that you had an honestly held belief that you were in imminent danger and that it was not practical to retreat. It is, therefore, vital that you have all your facts correct (see reporting and recording below) and, if possible, that you have witnesses who can confirm these facts. Other evidence such as tapes from CCTV would also be useful.