Although it sounds like something internal to an individual, self-regulation actually develops through interaction with caregivers such as parents, teachers and others in a supporting role. We call this 'co-regulation'. Through warm and responsive interactions, adults can support, coach and model the ability to understand, express and modulate thoughts, feelings and behaviour. Self-regulation is also supported by predictable, responsive and supportive environments.
Self-regulation can be strengthened and taught, just like literacy, for example, with focussed attention, support and practice across contexts.
Importantly, skills that are not developed early on can be acquired later.
As with literacy, a child's ability to self-regulate is determined to some extent by the child's own temperament but also by the structure, support and teaching that the child receives. Just as literacy develops earlier when young children are immersed in a literacy-rich environment, self-regulation skills will develop earlier where there is a strong foundation of support.
As with other areas of learning, a staged approach is needed from services:
Universal supports for healthy self-regulation development
Modelling, instruction and coaching throughout childhood is needed to build skills into adulthood
Some children may need more intensive, targeted interventions to overcome biological or environmental adversity which has disrupted development.
If you would like to understand more about the science of brain development, there is a series of excellent films available here, created by University of Oxford working in partnership with the Alberta Family Wellness Initiative: Building Brains For Lifelong Health | AFWI | Oxford Brain Story
This diagram shows how self-regulation skills develop gradually throughout childhood. At first a baby or small child is almost entirely dependent upon an adult for regulatory support. As the child grows their capacity for self-regulation increases.
Although our ultimate goal is for children to be able to regulate themselves, this is not normally fully achieved until early adulthood, at about 25 years of age.
There are two clear periods (marked here in red) where self-regulation skills increase dramatically due to neurobiological growth - suggesting particular opportunities for intervention at these points. These occur at the pre-school stage and during adolescence.
Within this overall trend there may be a lot of variation between individuals, and also for each individual, depending on circumstances and contexts. Even as adults we all continue to benefit from some co-regulation, especially in times of stress.
A broad range of factors will influence whether and how well a child is able to self-regulate at any given time.
These include factors inside the child (internal) and outside (external) factors as well as the child's age. Biology includes the temperament a child is born with and the skills that the child has the potential to develop. Biology might also include the child's health and the avaialbility of food and hydration, excercise and sleep. Interaction with parents, caregivers, teachers and the broader environment, over time, as the child grows and develops, all impact upon how the brain develops and is shaped.
Each of these factors may interact and influence one another.
So, every individual has a highly unique way of functioning in the world. In order to best support children and young people we need first to get to know them well so that we can learn what strategies and environments will best support their regulation capacity and their development.
It is important to note the range of individual differences.......
Some learners may present with highly sensitized neurological responses. This may be due to being naturally highly sensitive to environments. For others, neurodiversity (including Autism and ADHD) may be a contributing factor, impacting upon how the nervous system processes environmental stimuli. Sometimes neurological development is disrupted by the impact of trauma. Trauma may be historical, episodic or ongoing. ACE (Adverse Childhood Experiences) studies have highlighted the prevalence of these experiences amongst our populations and the serious, long-term effects that follow in the absence of buffering or effective intervention.
Some learners may be impacted by a combination of the above. These learners may be more easily overwhelmed by physical sensations (e.g. sound, touch, light), social expectations (e.g. communicating in groups) or cognitive demands (e.g. understanding and implementing instructions). They are likely to have strong reactions when they find the environment overstimulating. They are easily pushed out of their 'window of tolerance' (see next section).
Adult wellbeing and Whole School systems for supporting wellbeing are key.
Children learn socially, that is, by copying those around them. They are highly influenced by the adults in the room who are not only responsible for planned learning activities but who also set the emotional tone of the learning space.
Emotional contagion is the unconscious spread of emotions from one person to another and it occurs subconsciously whenever people are together. Put simply, emotional contagion is the process of catching the emotions of someone else. As an adult you are able to to use this influence to set a positive emotional tone that will spread and affect others around you. Emotional contagion is a powerful force that we are often not aware of. It was developed a long time ago in humans as an evolutionary strategy to help spread emotion (especially 'flight' associated emotions such as fear) quickly through a group. In this way, when danger was spotted by an individual, the whole group was able to move quickly and together to a place of safety, without the need for any verbal communication.
As adults, we therefore need to be aware of our own emotion and how it can affect those around us. We also need to be aware that we will be affected by powerful emotions being expressed by some of the children we work with, and we need to be able to stay present and self-aware especially at these times of heightened emotion, if we are to be helpful in the situation. Sometimes the best course of action is to step back and allow another adult to take over.
The first step for any adult is therefore to check-in with themselves and their own capacity for self-regulation.
To co-regulate successfully, adults need to be able to:
pay attention to their own feelings and reactions during stressful interactions with a child or young person
pay attention to their own thoughts and beliefs about the behaviours of others
use self-calming strategies and respond effectively and compassionately
Consider at all stages whether you may need to take a moment for a few deep breaths or to step back for a minute or two, away from the situation.
Consider: are you co-regulating or co-escalating? Sometimes it may be best to 'swap in' a different adult. Self-regulating during a stressful interaction with a learner is not an easy task. Adults in this role may benefit from support, practice and/or coaching to build their own coping and calming skills, which in turn will build their capacity to support the development of these skills in learners.
Creating the space and time for supervision, debriefing and other reflective practices is also helpful in supporting adults in this important and demanding role.
Further information is available here: The Cycle of Wellbeing | Learning resources | National Improvement Hub (education.gov.scot)
Below are some examples of the supports and strategies that will be most helpful within Universal provision at each developmental stage. These strategies match with the skills and capacities that will typically be seen to be developing at these stages. We will look at further ideas in more detail in the section 'Suporting Regulation'.
Children impacted by adversity require strategies that are a good match with their developmental stage rather than their chronological age.
Provide warm, nurturing supporting relationships, anticipating needs and responding to cues
Provide structure and consistent routine and modify environment to decrease demands where needed
Provide physical and emotional comfort when child is distressed or dysregulated: speak calmly and provide affection
Teach age appropriate rules and expectations and provide consistent responses in a calm manner
Label emotions and teach and coach the use of words to express emotions
Model, prompt and reinforce self-calming strategies like taking a deep breath
Teach and coach identifying solutions to simple problems
Provide external structure for calming down e.g. a calm-down space and materials
Continue to provide warm, nurturing, supportive relationships
Assist in problem-solving more complex academic, behavioural and social situations
Model conflict resolution strategies
Prompt and coach coping skills and calming strategies including self-talk and relaxation
Teach and support organisation and planning skills
Provide opportunities to make decisions and self-monitor behaviour
Provide clear rules, structure and consequences in a calm manner
Provide warm, responsive relationship
Provide empathy, especially in times of intense emotion
Model, monitor and coach more sophisticated self-regulation skills across different contexts
Monitor and limit opportunities to make decisions and self-monitor behaviour in less risky situations
Give time and space to calm down in times of conflict
Monitor and prompt use of organizational and planning skills for successful task completion
Continue to use clear rules, boundaries and responses which encourage and support good choices